# [RFC] Governance Process Upgrade: Establishing a Statute of Limitations for Temperature Checks

- Space: [Uniswap](https://snapshot.box/s:uniswapgovernance.eth.md)
- Author: 0x3FB19771947072629C8EEE7995a2eF23B72d4C8A
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-03-03 14:00 UTC
- End: 2026-03-08 14:00 UTC
- Votes: 133
- Quorum: 10,000,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://gov.uniswap.org/t/rfc-governance-process-upgrade-establishing-a-statute-of-limitations-for-temperature-checks/26002/1
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:uniswapgovernance.eth/proposal/0x48e56786fd4ab27c5b089b45be1e914d4a3a0f9d067ac51eff0b26a882e49bde

## Results

- For: 5,751,852.64 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 1,009.65 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 1,012.19 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

Author: @Eren_Targ5 (Daoplomats)

## Summary
This proposal seeks to establish a formal "Statute of Limitations" for Uniswap Governance proposals. Specifically, it mandates that any proposal which passes a "Temperature Check" (Snapshot vote) must proceed to an on-chain vote within 90 days.

If a proposal fails to move to an on-chain vote within this 90-day window, the Temperature Check is declared "Expired" (or "Dead"). To proceed, the proposer must restart the governance process with a new Temperature Check to ensure community sentiment remains current.

## 2. Motivation
Currently, Uniswap Governance operates on a continuous cycle. Unlike Optimism or Arbitrum, which utilize specific "Governance Seasons" or "Cycles" that naturally flush out stale proposals at the end of a period, Uniswap proposals can technically remain "pending" indefinitely after passing a Snapshot vote.

This creates critical risks and inefficiencies:
- Market Conditions Change: A proposal approved by the community 6 months ago may be financially dangerous or irrelevant today due to changes in market volatility, token prices, or protocol upgrades (e.g., v3 to v4).
- "Zombie" Proposal Risk: There is currently no rule preventing a delegate from taking a Snapshot vote from 2022 and putting it on-chain today, bypassing current community sentiment.
- Governance Clutter: It is difficult for delegates to track which initiatives are active versus abandoned.

By implementing a 90-day expiration, we align Uniswap with industry best practices (e.g., Sky) and ensure that every on-chain vote reflects the current will of the DAO.

## 3. Specification
We propose adding the following clause to the official Uniswap Community Governance Process:

"Validity of Temperature Checks: A successful Temperature Check (Snapshot vote) is valid for a period of 90 days from the date the vote closes. If an on-chain governance proposal is not submitted within this 90-day window, the Temperature Check is considered Expired. The proposer must post a new Temperature Check and receive fresh community approval before proceeding to an on-chain vote."

### Definition of Proposal States

Status | Definition | Action Required
--- | --- | ---
Live / Active | A proposal that has passed Snapshot within the last 90 days. | Can proceed to On-chain Vote immediately.
Dead / Expired | A proposal that passed Snapshot >90 days ago but has not yet been submitted on-chain. | Must re-run the Temperature Check phase to verify current sentiment.

### Handling Long-Term Initiatives
We recognize that major protocol upgrades or large-scale initiatives often require development timelines longer than 90 days. However, governance mandates should not be indefinite.

If a proposal has passed a Temperature Check but the technical implementation takes longer than 90 days, the proposer must follow the "Re-affirmation Process":
- The "Refresh" Vote: The proposer does not need to start from zero with a new RFC. They simply post a "Re-affirmation Snapshot" (Temperature Check) with the final code/parameters.
- Why this is necessary: In DeFi, 6 months is a long time. A mandate given in January might be dangerous to execute in July if market conditions have shifted (e.g., bridge hacks, new regulation).
- Result: This ensures that when the final "Publish" button is pressed for the on-chain vote, the community's consent is fresh and current.

## 4. Rationale & Precedent
This change brings Uniswap into alignment with the hygiene standards of other mature DeFi protocols.

- MakerDAO (Sky): Enforces a strict 30-day expiration on Executive Proposals.
- Optimism: Utilizes "Governance Seasons." Proposals must be submitted and voted on within a specific seasonal window.
- Uniswap (Current): Lacks both seasons and expiry rules, leaving the DAO exposed to "Zombie Proposals" indefinitely.

## 5. Comparison: Old vs. New Structure

Feature | Current Uniswap Governance | Proposed New Structure
--- | --- | ---
Snapshot Validity | Indefinite (Technically valid forever) | 90 Days (Statute of Limitations)
Stale Proposal Risk | High. A proposal from 1 year ago could theoretically be executed today despite market changes. | Low. Proposals must have a fresh community signal (within 3 months) to execute.
Governance Cycle | Continuous / Unbounded | Continuous, but with a rolling expiration window to ensure freshness.
Re-submission | Not defined / Confusing | Clear Process: If >90 days, you must re-post Snapshot.

## 6. Precedent of Risk
We have already seen 'Zombie Proposals' confuse the governance process.

- The Gnosis Deployment (2022-2023): A deployment passed a vote but sat pending for 11 months. During that time, the bridge provider (Nomad) was hacked.
- The Fee Switch (2024-2025): The fee switch mandate sat dormant for over 12 months, requiring a community member to manually post a 'Re-Temperature Check' to verify if the will of the DAO had changed.

This proposal removes this ambiguity. Instead of relying on the goodwill of authors to 're-check' sentiment, we enforce a hard 90-day expiry to ensure every on-chain execution represents the current will of the DAO.

## 7. Success Metrics
- Zero "Zombie" Executions: No proposals older than 90 days are executed on-chain without a fresh check.
- Delegate Clarity: Delegates can easily view the "active" pipeline without filtering through years of stale posts.
- Safety: Reduced risk of executing outdated parameters (e.g., fee switches or grant distributions based on old token prices).

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

