# [TIP-010] Introduce THORSwap fees for Lending (Borrow)

- Space: [THORSwap Community](https://snapshot.box/s:thorswapcommunity.eth.md)
- Author: 0x060c8C3e672f85c9cA86d7c3d15c27730b7A6E87
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2024-03-07 14:01 UTC
- End: 2024-03-17 14:01 UTC
- Votes: 58
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:thorswapcommunity.eth/proposal/0x63c2d3820f2dacb1af0c95aa0d0d1579c5a535ff4f6c6c1a2d86b051f61fbfbb

## Results

- 100 BPS (1%) fee on Loans: 6,491,989.75 voting power, 96.7%
- 50 BPS (0.5%) fee on Loans: 194,656.58 voting power, 2.9%
- No change - keep it free (0 BPS): 26,592.33 voting power, 0.4%

## Proposal

🔗 [TIP-010 Temp-check poll](https://forum.thorswap.finance/thread/51134)

## THE PROPOSAL
If passed, this proposal will introduce an origination fee to THORChain loans  on THORSwap.

The "base origination fee" will be determined based on the result of this proposal:

- **0 bps** - No fee, remains fee. Best user capture but least sustainable 
- **50 bps (0.5%)** 
- **100 bps (1%)** - inline with industry rates

Additionally, the fee will be charged in a tiered format discounted based on size of loan and amount of vTHOR held. Up to remaining completely free for holders ≥500K vTHOR.

Example based on 1% base fee:
 
![brave_ICUTvVoBma.png](ipfs://bafkreigyunyfpgzv46ukkmf3slmcsj73nibkl7wdb3uk34kzc5b3ti3eri)

Regardless of results of this proposal, there will be no fees charged for Loans under $100 value.

Fees earned will be shared 75/25 between vTHOR stakers and treasury as in-line with current swap fee structure.

___

## Summary
While THORSwap saw significant growth in volume and affiliate fee collection in 2023, the 75/25% fee-sharing structure poses a challenge for long term sustainability to support continued development and growth.

Swaps have been the only product for which THORSwap charges a fee. After the recent TIP-008 passed, a 5BPS fee will be added to Earn (Savers) deposits.

It in the first 200 Days since the launch of THORChain lending, 2000 loans have been opened with a total collateral value of $42.16M. ( [Source](https://flipsidecrypto.xyz/banbannard/%E2%9A%A1-thor-chain-lending-thorchain-lending-fOAKej) )

Following THORNode release v128, 60m $RUNE will be burned to create capacity for 2.1k BTC (or 41k ETH) collateral for lending with a fixed LTV of 50%. This introduces over $100M of new potential loans to the system, with a much more attractive LTV.

This [THORChain update](https://gitlab.com/thorchain/thornode/-/merge_requests/3425) will finally give interfaces the ability to add affiliate fee on loans. These developments present a maturity of the Lending product and another potential source of significant revenue.


## Motivation
**Current Situation**: THORSwap does not charge a fee for Lending (0 bps)
**Need for Change**: THORSwap needs to increase revenue to achieve long term sustainability. This proposal recommends THORSwap begins charging for Lending services which it has previously provided for free for 185 Days.

**Fee references:**

In TradFi, it is common to see 0.5-5% origination fees for loans. 0% for good credit scores/depending on loan terms and conditions (ie. overall lower interest rate). Some other models include Curve who do % per time.

Another model is Liquidity (LUSD) which applies a one time variable fee (and determined algorithmically) and has a minimum value of 0.5% under normal operation. (The fee rate is confined to a range between 0.5% and 5% and is multiplied by the amount of liquidity drawn by the borrower.) 

- Blockfi used to charge 2% and Nexo was flexible up to 2% depending on LTV and loan term.
- Aave charges 0.09% for flash loans.
- Solend: 0.1%
- Hodlhodl: 1 - 5 months: 1%, 6 - 12 months: 1.5%
- NFTY: 1%

### Justification for Fees:
As THORChain Loans do not charge interest, have no expiry and cannot be liquidated. This means the only fee that can be charged is a fair origination for on-going support and maintenance of the product for users.

## Implementation Plan
Lending Origination Fee will be turned if the proposal is passed/THORChain PR is merged. There will be no fees charged for loans under $100 value. 

Fees will be shared 75/25 between vTHOR stakers and treasury as in-line with current swap fee structure.

How fees will be applied:

Currently, users have to pay slip fees when taking out a loan. Previously, large transactions in shallow pools will incur larger fees. If this proposal is passed, additional THORSwap service fee will be applied on inbound amount before slippage is calculated.

## Benefits
Improve THORSwap sustainability.
Additional utility for $THOR/ $vTHOR holders.

## Drawbacks
Potential to be undercut by other THORChain lending interfaces.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

