# [PROPOSAL-010] Exclusion from possible airdrop of those who don’t read the text of the proposal

- Space: [Guru Network DAO](https://snapshot.box/s:thegurudao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x9092B2EeBe2aA19BC626Bfd25BF225170c3a2d33
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2022-05-13 23:52 UTC
- End: 2022-05-16 23:52 UTC
- Votes: 7,904
- Quorum: 1,270 voting power
- Discussion: https://gov.dex.guru/t/proposal-010-exclusion-from-possible-airdrop-of-those-who-don-t-read-the-text-of-the-proposal/9111
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:thegurudao.eth/proposal/0xcf6a74597ee93b12732784fea55d6d670650b5479196a57ed325b797e3958137

## Results

- Yes: 7,217 voting power, 91.3%
- No: 346 voting power, 4.4%
- Abstain: 341 voting power, 4.3%

## Proposal

# Summary

The proposal suggests excluding from the list of recipients of a possible future Airdrop all addresses that took part in bot detection votes on the snapshot.

Initial post ([Exclusion from possible airdrop of those who don’t read the text of the proposal - Temperature Checks - GuruDAO Governance Forum (dex. guru)](https://gov.dex.guru/t/exclusion-from-possible-airdrop-of-those-who-don-t-read-the-text-of-the-proposal/8913))

# Background

On 04/26/2022 and 05/05/2022 there were published proposals What option will bots prefer? ([1](https://snapshot.org/#/thegurudao.eth/proposal/0x4099606ae52125cc0f581dd0f7b0a4af6e0cf59527ac5a6fae9ab36fa1f8caf8), [2](https://snapshot.org/#/thegurudao.eth/proposal/0x276aeadbc8c68117dc677e6db275891281384e0dfe7c90d5b149389aa60eab32)) that were aimed to detect bots in the governance process. The proposals collected 441 and 165 votes despite the description “If you are a human, please do not vote on this.”. We have a reasonable opinion that all these votes were cast by bots.

# Proposal

Exclude from the list of recipients of a possible future Airdrop ALL addresses that took part in the [seventh](https://snapshot.org/#/thegurudao.eth/proposal/0x4099606ae52125cc0f581dd0f7b0a4af6e0cf59527ac5a6fae9ab36fa1f8caf8) and [eleventh](https://snapshot.org/#/thegurudao.eth/proposal/0x276aeadbc8c68117dc677e6db275891281384e0dfe7c90d5b149389aa60eab32) (IN ONE OR BOTH) votes on the snapshot (What option will bots prefer?). 

Those people who took part in this vote showed by their actions that they do not read the text for which they vote, or at least they are not familiar with the accepted governance process. Such people do more harm to the DAO than good. DAO doesn’t need members who just mindlessly push buttons.

# Pros

- The proposal suggests a straightforward process to identify and exclude bot accounts from the possible future airdrop.

# Cons

- The proposal may affect participants who voted by accident.

# Poll
[https://discord.com/channels/779159507967672360/958820909991477318/973352305040711690](https://discord.com/channels/779159507967672360/958820909991477318/973352305040711690)

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

