# AP: Adventure 4 rewards distribution

- Space: [AdmiralDAO](https://snapshot.box/s:theadmiraldao.eth.md)
- Author: 0xe98f0B95292c2c7A3CEe33E091Cc953F0F1C3CBE
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2023-09-09 00:00 UTC
- End: 2023-09-14 00:00 UTC
- Votes: 230
- Quorum: 1,000 voting power
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:theadmiraldao.eth/proposal/0xd494e606c7c55f77d1911390139f187e1b7c58db0211f9c9d5db98582c5b110b

## Results

- Yes - for this proposal: 15,006.65 voting power, 85.9%
- No - against this proposal: 2,464.6 voting power, 14.1%

## Proposal

**What's the big idea?**
This proposal tends to distributes the @Adventure IV - Clipper SAILS!  rewards among; __Adventure Pirates__, __Adventure Captains__ and __other stakeholders__ in this Adventure in a way that is considered __FAIR__ by the majority.

**What is the problem you are trying to solve?**
- **Untimely Rewards:** Previous Adventures rewards were distributed several months after some good pirates lost their qualifying accounts and/or wallets to hackers, we want to ensure rewards are distributed almost immediately Adventure ends and the preparation starts with this proposal

- **Unbalanced distribution:** Bloodsail Bandits Pirates were given extra rewards for sealing 1st position in previous Adventures but other ships were given same treatments regardless of positions be it 2nd or 6th. __This is not fair enough__

**What evidence do you have that indicates this is a problem?**
Now, some pirates don't see fighting and making their ships win as worthy way to get good rewards but prefers to join ships with less number in order to get higher rewards
Here is a **[screenshot](https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/948926259071705088/1147113749266829323/Screenshot_20230901_112013_Discord.jpg)** of pirate choosing individual honours over ships' honours

**What is the desired outcome if the problem is solved?**
People will once again have reasons to fight to make their ship wins and this brings real competition to @Adventure IV - Clipper SAILS!  and competition brings fun.
**FUN-FILLED** Adventure is what we desire and real competition is the driver of the fun

**Who is this for?**
- This proposal will benefit all participating Adventure 4 pirates no matter how little their activities are, but the active Pirates get more reward and Pirates' efforts' to make their ships win will be rewarded and so is Captains' efforts

- This proposal will benefit Adventure Pirates holding SAIL token for Adventure and Governance purposes as this proposal reserves a portion of the rewards to all Adventure Pirates that took Governance part and voted on this proposal

**How might this work?**
The total reward to be distributed is only regarded as 100% but actual quantity is not disclosed and hence should be distributed as follows;

**40% - Distributed to Pirates on __Individual Performances__**
- **15%** equally shared among all pirates with at least 50 points
- **10%** equally shared among all pirates with at least 200 points
- **8%** equally shared among all pirates with at least 500 points
- **5%** equally shared among all pirates with at least 900 points
- **2%** equally shared among all pirates with at least 1200 points

**9% - Distributed to Compensate __Heroism__**
- **5%** equally shared among @VIP - Adventure 4  as a special compensation for their heroism
*Note: it is believed the Code Breakers will be taken into consideration in this category*

- **2%** equally distributed among all Ethereum depositors as shown on [dune](https://dune.com/queries/2777080/4623530) to compensate part of the high gas fee spent om depositing
*Note: Snapshot will be taken at `12AM UTC` on `September 13, 2023` or last day of the Adventure, whichever that comes first to give everyone a fair chance to claim a share*

- **2%** distributed among pirates who holds `at least 10 NFTs` in their wallet to compensate those who spends to buy more NFTs on OpenSea to help their ships get more point before change in scoring rule. The more NFTs you hold, the more your share
*Note: Snapshot will be taken at `12AM UTC` on `September 13, 2023` or last day of the Adventure, whichever that comes first to give everyone a fair chance to claim a share*

**30% - Distributed to Pirates on __Ships' performances__**
- **11%** distributed equally among pirates of 1st position ship
- **8%** distributed equally among pirates of 2nd position ship
- **5%** distributed equally among pirates of 3rd position ship
- **3%** distributed equally among pirates of 4th position ship
- **2%** distributed equally among pirates of 5th position ship
- **1%** distributed equally among pirates of 6th position ship

**16% - Distributed on among Captains**
`General`
- **6%** equally distributed among all the **Active** `30 Captains`
_(Appraisals will be done among Captains in #captains-deck-adv4 at the end of the Adventure to decide Active Captains)_

 `Ships' Performance`
- 3% equally distributed among Captains of 1st position ship
- 2.5% equally distributed among Captains of 2nd position ship
- 2% equally distributed among Captains of 3rd position ship
- 1.5% equally distributed among Captains of 4th position ship
- 0.75% equally distributed among Captains of 5th position ship
- 0.25% equally distributed among Captains of 6th position ship

**5% - Distributed among @SAIL Token Hodler**
All Adventure 4 Pirates that votes on this proposal be in `support` or `against` will equally share in this 5% when the proposal made it to snapshot for onchain voting

**`Note:`** *Voters outside @Adventure IV - Clipper SAILS!  Pirates will not be rewarded.*
*So, Adventure Pirates should send their SAIL token to their Adventure wallet to get voting power and vote with with same wallet to be rewarded*

**Which chains will be affected?**
L2 chain deemed fit by the @Adventure Judge 

**Does the AP require deploying a new contract(s)?**
YES
**Does the AP require redeploying an existing contract(s)?**
NO
**What technologies are needed to execute the AP?**
No new technology required
**Does the AP involve transacting with third-parties?**
No

**Why might this idea fail?**
Some Pirates of the @Flying Dutchman - A4 ship may choose to `downvote` this proposal in defence of their proposal

**How will we measure success?**
Temperature Check and onchain voting outcome

**Important Links:**
- Link to Phase 1 (discussion)
https://discord.com/channels/844729067311202334/1147164487128985661/1147164487128985661

- Link to Phase 2 (temperature check)
https://discord.com/channels/844729067311202334/1142078406188601497/1148285784638640266

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

