# OIP-257: Reduce $OVER Additional Payout Incentive

- Space: [Overtime Governance](https://snapshot.box/s:thalesgov.eth.md)
- Author: 0x11219d61e95fC5930762b16868dDB2C9c6fc83fA
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-02-09 10:37 UTC
- End: 2026-02-13 10:37 UTC
- Votes: 5
- Quorum: 1 voting power
- Discussion: https://discord.gg/qk8X2UPh3V
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:thalesgov.eth/proposal/0xb28cc70c878631bc186c5fcbb8e9bb50ceedbe005950822a5edda48ae9b09012

## Results

- Yes: 5 voting power, 100.0%
- No: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

| id | Title | Status | Author | Description | Discussions to | Created |
| ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- | ----------- |
| OIP-257 | Reduce $OVER Additional Payout Incentive | Vote Pending | Danijel | Reduce $OVER additional payout from 2% to 1% to improve base odds competitiveness and reduce margin pressure | https://discord.gg/thales | 2026-02-02 |

## Simple Summary

This OIP proposes reducing the **additional payout incentive for betting with $OVER from 2% to 1%**.

The objective is to rebalance incentives so Overtime can offer **more competitive base odds** (USDC/WETH), reduce structural margin pressure, and improve overall market competitiveness—while still preserving a meaningful advantage for users who choose to bet with $OVER.

## Abstract

Overtime currently offers a **2% additional payout** when betting with `$OVER` token. While this incentive has been effective in driving $OVER usage, it introduces a structural constraint on pricing:

- A 2% additional payout effectively translates into **~1% less margin** on those bets.
- When attempting to match sharp market odds (e.g. Pinnacle) on the base line, the resulting $OVER odds can end up with **30–50% less margin** than the sharpest centralized books.
- This materially limits how aggressive Overtime can be on base (USDC/WETH) odds without overexposing the protocol via $OVER.

As a result, Overtime is often forced to keep **intentionally worse base odds** (by ~1%) to compensate for the $OVER uplift, reducing competitiveness for the majority of users.

Reducing the `$OVER` additional payout to **1%** alleviates this pressure while maintaining $OVER as the best-odds option on the platform.

## Motivation

### Structural pricing limitation

With a **2% additional payout**, the protocol faces a hard constraint:

- If Overtime matches sharp books on base odds:
  - $OVER bets become **significantly under-margined**
  - Risk exposure increases disproportionately
- To compensate, Overtime must:
  - Price USDC/WETH odds **worse than the market**
  - Protect against $OVER-driven overexposure

This dynamic directly limits the protocol’s ability to compete on headline odds.

In practice, the 2% incentive forces a tradeoff where:
- $OVER odds are extremely attractive
- Base odds (which drive ~90% of volume) are less competitive

This is suboptimal for both growth and sustainability.

### Volume reality: base collateral dominates

Despite successful $OVER tokenomics:

- **~90% of total volume** is still placed in **USDC/WETH**
- Most users prioritize:
  - Familiar assets
  - Simplicity
  - Avoiding exposure to alt tokens

While $OVER has strong adoption among core users, the current structure unintentionally **limits onboarding reach** to users who are unwilling to acquire or hold alternative tokens.

### Tokenomics vs reach

The 2% additional payout has been effective in:
- Encouraging $OVER usage
- Creating a clear “best odds” path
- Supporting token demand

However, it also:
- Caps how competitive Overtime can be on base odds
- Creates friction for new or casual users
- Concentrates pricing risk into $OVER markets

Reducing the incentive to **1%** strikes a better balance between:
- Token utility
- Risk management
- Market competitiveness
- User acquisition

### Why 1% is sufficient

A **1% additional payout** still:

- Provides **meaningfully better odds** than the broader market
- Keeps $OVER as the **best-odds collateral** on Overtime
- Results in **significantly lower effective margin** than sharp books
- Preserves $OVER’s value proposition for price-sensitive bettors

At the same time, it:
- Allows Overtime to price USDC/WETH markets more aggressively
- Reduces forced base-odds handicapping
- Improves competitiveness where most volume exists

## Specification

### $OVER additional payout change

- **Before**: +2% additional payout
- **After**: **+1% additional payout**

No other collateral incentives are changed.

### Scope

- Applies uniformly across all applicable markets
- Does not affect existing tickets
- Takes effect only for new bets placed after activation

## Rationale

### Base odds competitiveness matters most

Overtime competes in a market where users benchmark odds directly against sharp books.

Improving base odds:
- Increases conversion
- Improves retention
- Reduces perception of “DEX tax”
- Drives higher sustainable volume

Given that the majority of volume is non-$OVER, optimizing base pricing has outsized impact.

### Risk concentration reduction

Lowering the $OVER uplift:
- Reduces extreme margin compression on $OVER bets
- Lowers tail-risk exposure
- Improves overall pricing flexibility

This makes it easier to:
- Match market odds when appropriate
- Manage exposure without blunt limits
- Scale volume responsibly

### Token utility remains intact

$OVER continues to:
- Offer the best odds on the platform
- Serve as a premium collateral option
- Benefit users who value maximum payout efficiency

This change optimizes, rather than removes, the incentive.

## Expected Outcomes

- More competitive USDC/WETH odds
- Reduced need to artificially handicap base markets
- Better alignment with sharp market pricing
- Improved onboarding for non-$OVER users
- Sustained but healthier $OVER usage

## Backwards Compatibility

This OIP:
- Does not require contract migrations
- Does not invalidate existing tickets
- Is a parameter-level adjustment only

## Implementation

- Update $OVER payout multiplier via governance-controlled parameters
- Frontend copy updates to reflect the new incentive level

## Conclusion

The 2% $OVER additional payout has served its purpose, but now materially constrains pricing flexibility and competitiveness.

Reducing the incentive to **1%** preserves $OVER’s role as the best-odds option while unlocking:
- Better base odds
- Broader user reach
- Lower risk concentration
- More sustainable growth

This change prioritizes **market competitiveness and long-term scalability**, without abandoning the $OVER token’s core value proposition.

## Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.

## Are you in favor of this proposal?

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

