# MIP-0033: Update and Ratification of Wind-Down Process

- Space: [Movement DAO: Consensus Space](https://snapshot.box/s:snapshot.movedao.eth.md)
- Author: 0xA4e6C2B6264652444B3F0cc1bB37496AE916931c
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2023-11-07 11:00 UTC
- End: 2023-11-14 11:00 UTC
- Votes: 6
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:snapshot.movedao.eth/proposal/0xdc7c8cdda1af937e1fb2788e9ba695d947c181a3d2dccd14931347a2a06ab518

## Results

- For: 1,750,375.26 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

``````
Author: benreed.eth
Creation date: 2023-11-07
Proposal: 0033
Type: Proposal
``````

## Introduction

Movement DAO recently had a complaint (Case No. 23-cv-20727) filed against its Authorized Members, tankbottoms.eth and benreed.eth, by Ryan Breslow, Alex Fine, and Jon Gordon ("Breslow Group") in the Southern District Court of Florida. The Breslow Group was part of the founding team of the Movement DAO ("DAO"), and operated anonymously within the community. Last week, the parties agreed to a settlement in which the Authorized Members, on behalf of Movement DAO, agreed to pay the Breslow Group $10,080,841 USD out of the Movement DAO treasury in return for all interest, title, or rights the Breslow Group may have had in Movement or its assets to be terminated. Furthermore, the Breslow Group agreed to file a stipulation that provides for the dismissal of the Complaint and Counterclaim with prejudice in the Action, which they already have done and has been confirmed by the Court. Both parties also agreed to mutually release one another of any and all current and future claims.

Movement is now faced with the unfortunate reality of dissolution due to the outcome of the settlement. This proposal outlines the wind-down process for Movement DAO, specifically encompassing the distribution of its remaining treasury funds. Our aim is to ensure a structured, transparent, and equitable dissolution process that meets all outstanding obligations, compensates contributors, and allows individual community members to reclaim the majority, if not all of their contributions.

The Authorized Members understand that their is a need for a comprehensive plan to dissolve the organization while preserving the interests of the DAO's community members. This proposal defines the timeline and the order in which the remaining treasury funds will be dispersed, and the criteria for contributors to reclaim their funds while also ensuring that Movement DAO and its stakeholders are safeguarded from potential future claims.

## Thesis

The purpose of this proposal is to outline the process for the wind-down of Movement DAO, including the distribution of its remaining treasury. The wind-down will be conducted transparently and efficiently, ensuring that all outstanding obligations are met, and contributors to the treasury are able to reclaim their contributions, provided they meet specific criteria.

## Motivation

To maintain the integrity of the DAO and protect the interests of its community members, it is essential to have a structured process that has been ratified by the community in place for the dissolution of Movement DAO and the dispersal of the remainder of the treasury. This will also help in resolving all outstanding liabilities and obligations of the DAO.

## Specification

**a. Timeline**

The wind-down of Movement DAO is expected to be completed within the next three months (with options to extend another 3-months). This time-frame allows for careful consideration and execution of each step in the process.

**b. Treasury Dispersal Order**

The remaining Movement DAO treasury will be dispersed in the following order:

Outstanding Liabilities: The first priority is to settle all outstanding liabilities, which includes legal fees, operational costs, expenses that were covered by the Authorized Members while the Movement treasury was ordered to not be used under a TRO, and any other dues. These will be paid from the treasury until all obligations are met.

Past Compensation: Movement DAO will fulfill any outstanding compensation owed to Movement employees and independent contractors, ensuring that all individuals who contributed their time and effort to the DAO are compensated fairly.

Indemnification Trust: Movement's Authorized Members should have resources to protect themselves against any future claims.

Return of Contributions: Following the settlement of liabilities and compensation, the remaining funds will be allocated for the return of contributions made by individual community members to the Movement treasury.

Specifically, the payouts can be viewed in 5 categories:

1. Contributor Developer Payouts
2. Contributor Reimbursements / Expenses / Loans
3. Contribution lists including splits - and breakout ineligible addresses
4. Contributor Contribution Reimbursements (active wallets)
5. Contributor Contribution Reimbursements (inactive wallets)

**c. Contributor Verification and Release**

To have their contributions returned, individual community members must:

i. Specify their name, contact information, and Ethereum wallet address from which they contributed to the treasury.
ii. Provide proof of ownership of the Ethereum wallet used for their contribution.
iii. Agree to a comprehensive release of all past, current, and future claims against Movement DAO and its associated entities, including officers, directors, managers, members, employees, attorneys, affiliates, related corporations and entities, agents, successors, heirs, and assigns.

**d. Eligible Gnosis Contributions**

| DateTime       | ETH Address | Type |          Amount |         ETH |
| :------------- | :---------- | :--: | --------------: | ----------: |
| 02/02/22 19:23 | 0xAE1…4Dcd1 | ETH  |       $2,089.71 | 1.136076242 |
| 02/02/22 19:23 | 0xC5c…A4b79 | ETH  |       $4,018.68 | 2.184765767 |
| 02/02/22 19:25 | 0x284…0d0A2 | ETH  |         $296.49 | 0.161187555 |
| 02/02/22 19:26 | 0xdeF…06e1c | ETH  |       $3,214.94 | 1.747810439 |
| 02/02/22 20:39 | 0x4Ab…5dB0c | ETH  |           $2.67 | 0.001451552 |
| 02/02/22 20:39 | 0x4Ab…5dB0c | DAI  |           $1.00 | 0.000543653 |
| 02/02/22 21:5  | 0x580…53a54 | ETH  |         $803.73 | 0.436949892 |
| 02/02/22 22:30 | 0xA4e…6931c | ETH  |      $14,136.08 | 7.685116423 |
| 02/02/22 22:30 | 0xc92…0A296 | ETH  |      $39,445.13 | 21.44444686 |
| 02/02/22 22:30 | 0x277…1fC63 | ETH  |     $100,000.00 | 54.36525843 |
| 02/02/22 22:24 | 0x5d9…0d27E | DAI  | $978,679.54[^1] | 532.0616611 |
| 02/02/22 22:41 | 0x277…1fC63 | ETH  |     $100,000.00 | 54.36525843 |
| 02/02/22 22:41 | 0xA4e…6931c | ETH  |      $73,709.84 |   40.072545 |
| 02/02/22 22:41 | 0xc92…0A296 | ETH  |      $40,436.66 | 21.98349471 |
| 02/03/22 0:14  | 0xe49…23763 | ETH  |       $1,077.47 |  0.58576935 |
| 02/03/22 14:17 | 0xdeF…06e1c | ETH  |       $3,232.41 |  1.75730805 |
| 02/03/22 14:28 | 0xAE1…4Dcd1 | ETH  |       $2,065.84 | 1.123099255 |
| 02/03/22 15:9  | 0xC5c…A4b79 | ETH  |       $4,040.52 |  2.19663914 |
| 02/03/22 15:59 | 0x284…0d0A2 | ETH  |         $307.96 |  0.16742325 |
| 02/03/22 16:57 | 0x872…aea97 | ETH  |       $3,016.92 | 1.640156354 |
| 02/03/22 21:17 | 0x74F…C0704 | ETH  |       $8,081.04 | 4.393278279 |
| 02/04/22 0:46  | 0x8ff…0d338 | ETH  |       $7,315.57 | 3.977128536 |
| 02/04/22 1:24  | 0x3D4…4f4C6 | ETH  |       $1,134.66 | 0.616860841 |
| 02/04/22 10:46 | 0x0e2…9820b | ETH  |           $2.98 | 0.001620085 |
| 02/04/22 11:4  | 0x586…a1c74 | ETH  |           $4.47 | 0.002430127 |
| 02/04/22 16:43 | 0x8B4…1bccA | ETH  |         $313.52 | 0.170445958 |
| 02/04/22 18:49 | 0x1F7…Ab82f | ETH  |         $895.78 | 0.486993112 |
| 02/04/22 19:29 | 0x3c7…f2539 | ETH  |         $830.09 | 0.451280574 |
| 02/04/22 21:19 | 0x1F7…Ab82f | ETH  |         $268.73 | 0.146095759 |
| 02/06/22 4:12  | 0xc92…0A296 | ETH  |          $91.85 |  0.04993449 |
| 02/06/22 22:51 | 0xDb8…3Fc70 | ETH  |       $6,430.01 | 3.495691553 |
| 02/07/22 2:20  | 0x580…53a54 | ETH  |       $3,142.03 | 1.708172729 |
| 02/07/22 5:36  | 0xA4e…6931c | ETH  |       $1,176.24 | 0.639465916 |
| 02/08/22 0:27  | 0x715…1744e | ETH  |       $2,336.10 | 1.270026802 |
| 02/08/22 7:36  | 0x5d9…0d27E | ETH  |          $38.93 | 0.021164395 |
| 02/08/22 7:37  | 0x5d9…0d27E | ETH  |          $38.93 | 0.021164395 |
| 02/08/22 7:39  | 0x5d9…0d27E | ETH  |          $38.93 | 0.021164395 |
| 02/08/22 7:40  | 0x5d9…0d27E | ETH  |         $186.88 | 0.101597795 |
| 02/08/22 7:44  | 0x5d9…0d27E | ETH  |         $233.61 |  0.12700268 |
| 02/10/22 0:27  | 0xda9…15fBC | ETH  |          $49.01 | 0.026644413 |
| 02/11/22 6:25  | 0x4ee…fe32B | ETH  |         $937.32 |  0.50957644 |
| 02/11/22 6:36  | 0x4e3…4a525 | ETH  |         $951.97 | 0.517540951 |
| 02/11/22 21:26 | 0xc92…0A296 | ETH  |          $26.36 | 0.014330682 |
| 02/13/22 6:58  | 0x277…1fC63 | ETH  |         $276.96 |  0.15057002 |
| 02/13/22 8:21  | 0x9dE…5326b | ETH  |         $287.00 | 0.156028292 |
| 02/13/22 11:45 | 0xdbb…9a05D | ETH  |         $975.82 | 0.530507065 |
| 02/14/22 16:21 | 0x979…c7991 | ETH  |         $439.56 |  0.23896793 |
| 02/14/22 23:51 | 0xA4e…6931c | ETH  |         $996.35 | 0.541668252 |
| 02/15/22 1:31  | 0x58E…59984 | DAI  |          $50.00 | 0.027182629 |
| 02/15/22 1:31  | 0x58E…59984 | DAI  |          $50.00 | 0.027182629 |
| 02/15/22 8:15  | 0x0F9…ff110 | ETH  |          $31.85 | 0.017315335 |
| 02/15/22 8:56  | 0x9AB…2f9E9 | ETH  |         $318.59 | 0.173202277 |
| 02/15/22 11:22 | 0x3dF…CE03f | ETH  |         $477.89 | 0.259806133 |
| 02/15/22 19:55 | 0xab5…e05Ee | ETH  |         $191.15 | 0.103919191 |
| 02/16/22 2:8   | 0x826…F6929 | ETH  |          $93.68 | 0.050929374 |
| 02/16/22 23:30 | 0x616…C4739 | ETH  |          $40.59 | 0.022066858 |
| 02/17/22 2:50  | 0xa51…8e785 | ETH  |         $863.93 | 0.469677777 |
| 02/17/22 20:41 | 0xB15…D9EC6 | ETH  |       $8,639.34 | 4.696799517 |
| 02/19/22 12:11 | 0xef5…07732 | DAI  |         $500.00 | 0.271826292 |
| 02/19/22 20:29 | 0xb30…49949 | ETH  |         $138.21 | 0.075138224 |
| 02/20/22 0:7   | 0x792…400a9 | ETH  |         $262.13 | 0.142507652 |
| 02/20/22 18:46 | 0x511…5fa52 | ETH  |         $327.41 | 0.177997293 |
| 02/22/22 21:58 | 0xC9f…b39FE | ETH  |         $237.17 | 0.128938083 |
| 02/22/22 22:57 | 0xb30…49949 | ETH  |          $52.70 | 0.028650491 |
| 02/23/22 10:30 | 0xB2b…4b3b7 | ETH  |         $773.74 | 0.420645751 |
| 02/25/22 3:37  | 0x148…0dd31 | DAI  |         $685.00 |  0.37240202 |
| 02/27/22 2:20  | 0x1eb…7b852 | ETH  |          $85.88 | 0.046688884 |
| 03/01/22 0:18  | 0x13b…D7b42 | ETH  |         $297.71 | 0.161850811 |
| 03/01/22 4:52  | 0x9f7…B52C8 | ETH  |         $208.40 | 0.113297199 |
| 03/03/22 1:30  | 0x17d…e829b | ETH  |          $56.71 | 0.030830538 |
| 03/03/22 1:45  | 0x2D1…d61C5 | ETH  |         $283.58 |    0.154169 |
| 03/03/22 3:20  | 0xa7d…69b50 | ETH  |          $93.58 | 0.050875009 |
| 03/08/22 2:1   | 0x1eb…7b852 | ETH  |         $481.09 | 0.261545822 |
| 03/12/22 4:42  | 0x620…775d0 | ETH  |           $2.56 | 0.001391751 |
| 03/12/22 16:30 | 0x252…64220 | ETH  |         $198.91 | 0.108137936 |
| 03/12/22 19:32 | 0xD78…49CCD | DAI  |     $100,000.00 | 54.36525843 |
| 03/15/22 0:54  | 0xC36…1e17C | ETH  |          $52.37 | 0.028471086 |
| 03/15/22 1:23  | 0xC36…1e17C | ETH  |         $366.59 | 0.199297601 |
| 03/15/22 1:49  | 0xe49…23763 | DAI  |         $500.00 | 0.271826292 |
| 03/17/22 9:31  | 0xa65…AE5dA | ETH  |         $196.92 | 0.107056067 |
| 03/17/22 9:40  | 0xa65…AE5dA | ETH  |         $281.32 | 0.152940345 |
| 03/17/22 21:10 | 0x23d…c570E | ETH  |         $281.32 | 0.152940345 |
| 03/22/22 6:11  | 0x54F…45584 | ETH  |         $989.09 | 0.537721335 |
| 04/03/22 1:7   | 0xA1b…6637b | DAI  |          $50.00 | 0.027182629 |
| 04/04/22 2:4   | 0x5b2…7548f | ETH  |         $195.53 |  0.10630039 |
| 04/06/22 12:10 | 0xDab…737c3 | ETH  |          $31.72 |  0.01724466 |
| 04/10/22 21:44 | 0x1F7…Ab82f | DAI  |          $50.00 | 0.027182629 |
| 04/15/22 12:28 | 0x489…6b793 | ETH  |          $20.54 | 0.011166624 |
| 04/21/22 9:3   | 0xb92…b0D10 | DAI  |         $150.00 | 0.081547888 |
| 04/28/22 18:48 | 0xCf7…d9CE3 | ETH  |         $146.94 | 0.079884311 |
| 04/29/22 18:47 | 0xEE6…84e85 | ETH  |         $281.76 | 0.153179552 |
| 04/29/22 23:50 | 0x95a…8F07b | ETH  |       $1,972.38 | 1.072289484 |
| 05/02/22 5:14  | 0xd11…a7d97 | ETH  |       $1,115.30 | 0.606335727 |
| 05/22/22 23:55 | 0xE5a…67305 | ETH  |          $40.81 | 0.022186462 |
| 05/25/22 6:37  | 0x58C…1d013 | ETH  |          $97.02 | 0.052745174 |
|                |             |      |                 |             |
|                |             |      |   $1,530,337.70 |      831.97 |

_MIP-0031 enumerated the ineligible Gnosis contributions._

_**Disclaimer:** Some of the addresses above are subject to change, and the computation for the value of the Eth to be returned will be based on the **average** close price of ETH/USD between 10/31/2023 and 11/05/2023, as seen in the table below:_

#### Table, USD/ETH Average High Close Past Week

ETH price is based on the **average** close price of [ETH/USD between 10/31/2023 and 11/05/2023](https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/ETH-USD/history/).

| Date       |      ETH/USD |
| :--------- | -----------: |
| 11/5/2023  |     $1881.81 |
| 11/4/2023  |      $1857.7 |
| 11/3/2023  |      $1832.8 |
| 11/2/2023  |     $1800.62 |
| 11/1/2023  |     $1847.09 |
| 10/31/2023 |     $1816.46 |
|            |              |
|            | $1839.413333 |

## Rationale

The proposed wind-down process aims to ensure the equitable distribution of Movement DAO's remaining assets, taking into consideration all liabilities, obligations, and commitments made by the DAO. By verifying and requiring contributors to agree to a release of all current and future claims, it offers a fair and transparent way for individuals to reclaim their contributions, while protecting the DAO and its stakeholders from potential future claims or disputes. This approach adheres to legal requirements and best practices for dissolving an organization and respects the principles of decentralized governance.

## Risks

While this wind-down proposal seeks to minimize risks, there are still potential challenges:

Legal and Regulatory Risks: The wind-down process must comply with relevant legal and regulatory requirements. Failure to do so may expose DAO and its authorized members to further legal challenges.

Community Cooperation: The success of this process depends on the cooperation of the DAO community members in providing accurate information and adhering to the release agreement. Some contributors may not wish to release their claims.

Resource Allocation: Managing the distribution of remaining funds in the order specified may prove challenging, especially if there are unexpected changes in the financial situation of the DAO.

To mitigate these risks, it is essential to involve legal experts, adhere to the established timeline, and maintain transparent communication with the community throughout the wind-down process.

## Snapshot Consensus by the DAO Members

Whereas the DAO through its Members voted to adopt the following actions via Snapshot and resolves as follows:

**RESOLVED:** Movement DAO ratifies the proposed wind-down process for the DAO and its treasury, based on what was explained above;

**RESOLVED FURTHER:** That the Authorized Members convened and are hereby jointly and severally authorized to take any and all actions, along with executing or signing any cryptocurrency transactions, and executing and delivering any other documents, agreements, instruments, and/or certificates as he or she may deem necessary, advisable, or incidental, in connection with the preceding resolution, and other resolutions herein, or any related documents. This also includes authorization to perform or resolve the obligations of the DAO, and/or its affiliates.

This approval by the DAO Members by Snapshot vote shall be effective as of the date the DAO Entities receives a majority vote of the DAO at the end of the Snapshot vote.

This action by the DAO may be executed in any number of counterparts, each of which shall constitute an original and all of which together shall constitute one action.

----

[View Proposal →](https://docs.move.xyz/daolabs/daos/move/proposals/mip-0033.md)

[PDF download](https://docs.move.xyz/pdfs/mips/mip-0033.pdf) | [IPFS mirror](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafkreibcf5jmbibshrln3atev65anvgqmdl2oz66ru6x5untkklbn34uum)

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

