# MIP-0031: Ratification of the Breslow Group Settlement

- Space: [Movement DAO: Consensus Space](https://snapshot.box/s:snapshot.movedao.eth.md)
- Author: 0xA4e6C2B6264652444B3F0cc1bB37496AE916931c
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2023-11-07 10:43 UTC
- End: 2023-11-14 10:43 UTC
- Votes: 6
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:snapshot.movedao.eth/proposal/0xa6e7e5681ac8701dabb1d0688c567c3446daa2c4a48982ba94d686b95dcb9a36

## Results

- For: 1,750,375.26 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

``````
Author: benreed.eth
Creation date: 2023-11-07
Proposal: 0031
Type: Proposal
``````

## Introduction

Movement DAO recently had a complaint (Case No. 23-cv-20727) filed against its Authorized Members, tankbottoms.eth and benreed.eth, by Ryan Breslow, Alex Fine, and Jon Gordon ("Breslow Group") in the Southern District Court of Florida. The Breslow Group was part of the founding team of the Movement DAO ("DAO"), and operated anonymously within the community. On October 20, 2023, the parties agreed to a settlement in which the Authorized Members, on behalf of the DAO, agreed to pay the Breslow Group $10,080,841 USD out of the DAO treasury in return for all interest, title, or rights the Breslow Group may have had in Movement or its assets to be terminated. Furthermore, the Breslow Group agreed to file a stipulation that provides for the dismissal of the Complaint and Counterclaim with prejudice in the Action, which they already have done and has been confirmed by the Court. Both parties also agreed to mutually release one another of any and all current and future claims.

The following represents the contributions made by the Breslow Group to the DAO treasury. While the Breslow Group made the initial contributions to "seed" the DAO, additional later contributions were made using other anonymous wallets enumerated in the Appendix.

## Table, Breslow Group Gnosis Contributions

| ETH Address | Name | Type | Normalized Amount |         ETH |
| :---------- | :--: | :--: | ----------------: | ----------: |
| 0xDbE…B2b57 | R.B. | ETH  |     $8,668,432.86 | 4712.615926 |
| 0x746…2b498 | A.F. | ETH  |     $5,496,004.80 |     2987.92 |
| 0xf6D…1585A | J.G. | ETH  |     $1,014,856.48 |  551.729348 |
|             |      |      |                   |             |
|             |      |      |    $15,179,294.14 |     8252.26 |

Previously, [Snapshot Proposal MIP-0030](https://snapshot.org/#/snapshot.movedao.eth/proposal/0x0e6b5a0af9dac03168d1d126ab786d9539bc3bf76829263c89aa5480060cc31d) authorized the Authorized Members to settle with the Breslow Group for up to a maximum of $8.5m. However, due to the volatility of the market, mounting legal expenses incurred personally by the Authorized Members, and the need to resolve these issues as fast as possible, the Authorized Members agreed to pay the Breslow Group the above aforementioned amount. Continued litigation would have been costly and likely resulted in a pyric victory.

With that said, Movement is now faced with the unfortunate reality of dissolution due to the outcome of the settlement, as the funds involved were a majority of the Movement treasury. This proposal will be followed by subsequent proposals that address key issues and outline action items that are pertinent to the wind-down process, for which the Authorized Members seek approval and ratification from members of the community.

## Thesis

The purpose of this proposal is to have the community ratify the $10,080,841 settlement payment, which was made from the DAO's Gnosis to Breslow's Coinbase account which were primarily transmitted in [two transactions 8,500,000 DAI and 972.48 ETH on 10/20/2023](https://app.safe.global/transactions/history?safe=eth:0x143cC0A996De329C1C5723Ee4F15D2a40c1203c6). This amount was higher than that which was previously approved, as seen in MIP-0030.

## Motivation

The motivation behind ratifying this settlement payment is to bring closure to the legal dispute in a manner that is fair and equitable to both parties. By agreeing to this settlement, Movement DAO avoids prolonged litigation, which can be costly and time-consuming, and focus its efforts and resources on the imminent wind-down process.

## Specification

This proposal seeks to ratify the settlement payment of $10,080,841 USD to the Breslow Group, for which in return the Breslow Group terminated any interests, titles, or rights they may have had in Movement or its assets. The Breslow Group also agreed to dismiss the Complaint and Counterclaim with prejudice in the legal action, confirming their intention not to pursue further legal action against Movement DAO. The agreement also included mutual releases, which prevent both parties from making any current or future claims against each other.

## 5. Rationale

The settlement payment allows the DAO to move forward and resolve the majority of outstanding obligations, liabilities, refund contributors. The settlement payment allows the contributors to move on with their lives.

## Risks

While this settlement seeks to resolve all claims, there are still potential challenges:

Legal and Regulatory Risks: The Breslow Group may decide to later challenge the settlement agreement. Law enforcement or regulatory agencies may decide to pursue individuals for questionable activities which may consume attention by the DAO's Authorized Members or community members.

Community Cooperation: The settlement may pose financial challenges where the DAO is unable to meet all of its obligations.

Resource Allocation: Managing the distribution of remaining funds in the order specified may prove challenging, especially if there are unexpected changes in the financial situation of the DAO or unknown expenses arise.

To mitigate these risks, it is essential to involve legal experts, which the Authorized Members did throughout the settlement process.

## Snapshot Consensus by the DAO Members

Whereas the DAO through its Members voted to adopt the following actions via Snapshot and resolves as follows:

**RESOLVED:** Movement DAO ratifies the settlement payment of $10,080,841 USD on 10/20/2023 to the Breslow Group from the DAO, based on what was explained above;

**RESOLVED FURTHER:** That the Authorized Members convened and are hereby jointly and severally authorized to take any and all actions, along with executing or signing any cryptocurrency transactions, and executing and delivering any other documents, agreements, instruments, and/or certificates as he or she may deem necessary, advisable, or incidental, in connection with the preceding resolution, and other resolutions herein, or any related documents. This also includes authorization to perform or resolve the obligations of the DAO, and/or its affiliates.

This approval by the DAO Members by Snapshot vote shall be effective as of the date the DAO Entities receives a majority vote of the DAO at the end of the Snapshot vote.

This action by the DAO may be executed in any number of counterparts, each of which shall constitute an original and all of which together shall constitute one action.

----

[View Proposal →](https://docs.move.xyz/daolabs/daos/move/proposals/mip-0031.md)

[PDF download](https://docs.move.xyz/pdfs/mips/mip-0031.pdf) | [IPFS mirror](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafkreigsmukhbb2ozadxq3iczsnfig6okpll2acfxupj247z4itrd3x6vi)

----

## Appendix

### Table, Detailed Gnosis Contributions by the Breslow Group

The following table provides a detailed breakdown of the Breslow Group's Gnosis contributions. Payments made after 2/2/22 were later discovered to be made by members of the Breslow Group using other wallets.

| DateTime       | ETH Address | Name | Type | Normalized Amount |         ETH |
| :------------- | :---------- | ---- | :--: | ----------------: | ----------: |
| 02/02/22 22:21 | 0xDbE…B2b57 | R.B. | DAI  |     $1,200,000.00 | 652.3831011 |
| 02/02/22 22:24 | 0xDbE…B2b57 | R.B. | DAI  |     $5,627,407.07 | 3059.354396 |
| 02/02/22 22:24 | 0x746…2b498 | A.F. | DAI  |     $2,202,028.85 | 1197.138675 |
| 02/02/22 22:24 | 0xf6D…1585A | J.G. | DAI  |       $978,679.54 | 532.0616611 |
| 02/02/22 22:52 | 0xD78…49CCD | A.F. | DAI  |     $3,000,000.00 | 1630.957753 |
| 02/02/22 23:2  | 0x58F…Cac1d | R.B. | ETH  |     $1,841,025.79 | 1000.878428 |
| 02/03/22 0:54  | 0xb44…88461 | J.G. | ETH  |         $2,593.93 | 1.410196748 |
| 02/03/22 3:13  | 0xb44…88461 | J.G. | ETH  |           $980.49 | 0.533045922 |
| 02/03/22 16:51 | 0x58B…E1650 | J.G. | ETH  |           $269.36 |  0.14643826 |
| 02/03/22 22:10 | 0x211…6328E | A.F. | ETH  |         $2,693.68 | 1.464426093 |
| 02/03/22 22:6  | 0x211…6328E | A.F. | DAI  |            $20.00 | 0.010873052 |
| 02/03/22 22:7  | 0x211…6328E | A.F. | DAI  |        $80,000.00 | 43.49220674 |
| 02/03/22 22:9  | 0x211…6328E | A.F. | DAI  |         $1,000.00 | 0.543652584 |
| 2/3/22 22:52   | 0x6C0…Aeb54 | J.G. | ETH  |           $897.89 | 0.488140219 |
| 02/04/22 6:3   | 0x58B…E1650 | J.G. | ETH  |         $2,299.18 | 1.249955149 |
| 02/04/22 16:40 | 0xb44…88461 | J.G. | ETH  |         $1,791.57 |  0.97399166 |
| 02/05/22 16:24 | 0xb44…88461 | J.G. | ETH  |           $575.84 | 0.313056904 |
| 02/07/22 4:16  | 0x211…6328E | A.F. | DAI  |       $200,000.00 | 108.7305169 |
| 02/07/22 14:14 | 0xb44…88461 | J.G. | ETH  |           $314.20 | 0.170815642 |
| 02/07/22 15:1  | 0xb44…88461 | J.G. | ETH  |           $188.52 | 0.102489385 |
| 02/08/22 18:46 | 0xE41…f9033 | J.G. | ETH  |           $155.74 | 0.084668453 |
| 02/09/22 15:17 | 0x156…7e5a3 | A.F. | ETH  |           $162.27 | 0.088218505 |
| 02/10/22 3:4   | 0xb44…88461 | J.G. | ETH  |        $19,176.94 | 10.42559299 |
| 2/15/2022 1:31 | 0x58E…59984 | A.F. | DAI  |            $50.00 | 0.027182629 |
| 2/15/2022 1:31 | 0x58E…59984 | A.F. | DAI  |            $50.00 | 0.027182629 |
| 2/24/2022 2:13 | 0x58E…59984 | A.F. | DAI  |         $3,000.00 | 1.630957753 |
| 2/24/2022 2:16 | 0x58E…59984 | A.F. | DAI  |         $2,000.00 | 1.087305169 |
| 2/24/2022 2:16 | 0x58E…59984 | A.F. | DAI  |         $1,000.00 | 0.543652584 |
| 2/24/2022 2:16 | 0x58E…59984 | A.F. | DAI  |         $4,000.00 | 2.174610337 |
| 03/09/22 15:43 | 0x58B…E1650 | J.G. | ETH  |         $6,933.28 | 3.769295589 |
|                |             |      |      |                   |             |
|                |             |      |      |    $15,179,294.14 |     8252.26 |

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

