# MIP-0032: Proposal for the Cancellation and Voiding of Movement GitBook

- Space: [Movement DAO: Consensus Space](https://snapshot.box/s:snapshot.movedao.eth.md)
- Author: 0xA4e6C2B6264652444B3F0cc1bB37496AE916931c
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2023-11-07 11:00 UTC
- End: 2023-11-14 11:00 UTC
- Votes: 7
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:snapshot.movedao.eth/proposal/0x758b570ac0a71ae27946e6c8c1907d7bda9ca46d3d981a84a2685c6e083b6550

## Results

- For: 1,851,327.23 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

`````
Author: benreed.eth
Creation date: 2023-11-07
Proposal: 0032
Type: Proposal
`````

## Introduction

Movement DAO was founded by four individuals Ryan Breslow, Alex Fine, Jon Gordon (hereafter "Breslow Group") and Mark Phillips. Phillips, referred to as `tankbottoms.eth` was hired by the Breslow Group on December 6, 2021[^1] to develop the DAO source code which was forked from the OpenLaw Tribute DAO Framework and [published anonymously on GitBook on February 2, 2022](https://github.com/themovementdao/move-monorepo). The Breslow Group between the same period of time authored the Movement GitBook and engaged in marketing the DAO through social media using fictitious names and multiple Discord handles. In order to induce the public to contribute to the DAO, the Movement Contribution Website provided a link to the GitBook ostensibly acting as the DAO's white paper. The [Contribution Website](https://original.move.xyz) promised that fifteen (15%) of all contributions would be used for the DAO's Yearly Budget. The original GitBook made a number of promises which will be shown by enumerating the GitBook Change History for users tedoshidansonoto@gmail.com, tedoshij@gmx.com, steve@teddao.xyz, all aliases of the Breslow Group. After the DAO's launch, Phillips transitioned into the DAO's Authorized Member while continuing as its developer. The Breslow Group continued to operate anonymously within the DAO. During the course of the DAO's operations, the Breslow Group took no further action to fulfill the promises made in GitBook or the Contribution Website, despite Gnosis contributions by individuals relying on those statements. The Authorized Members now seek to explicitly disavow any affiliation with the GitBook and its promises after having reached a settlement with the Breslow Group. The Authorized Members and the DAO want to be explicit that no one was a party or privy to the GitBook and its promises other than the Breslow Group and their counsel.

#### Table, GitBook Change History

The following table evidences the GitBook user, date, and changes made to the GitBook by the Breslow Group:

| Date     | User     | File                                                                                                                                                 |
| :------- | :------- | :--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| 01/26 | ted      | [`bafybeib52pfpf3hitgrosar...otfr6oxo3ak2i677l7qtmzw5uqy`](https://bafybeib52pfpf3hitgrosarfb65jsppotfr6oxo3ak2i677l7qtmzw5uqy.ipfs.nftstorage.link) |
| 02/02    | steve | [`bafybeidmmdlxd2f2jkysr64...ujc3msjvqt2dwmavgjojkfylbnq`](https://bafybeidmmdlxd2f2jkysr64sc5gqzugujc3msjvqt2dwmavgjojkfylbnq.ipfs.nftstorage.link) |
|          | -        | [`bafybeibatkwnymevxaegj3w...zqwjojbeep3wfhteaexyd67aj6y`](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafybeibatkwnymevxaegj3whkwk473szqwjojbeep3wfhteaexyd67aj6y) |
|          | -        | [`bafybeia3ejel5ernuf7qf75...krn4r7avba2d66f7jkmbyvy4lze`](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafybeia3ejel5ernuf7qf75wa5usmwxkrn4r7avba2d66f7jkmbyvy4lze) |

##### Table, GitBook Promises Community Payouts and Allocations

| No. | Statement(s) _GitBook Pg. No._                                                                                                                                                                                        |   Amount |
| :-: | :-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------: |
|  1  | "Galt donated millions to Movement DAO...locked his **20%** token stake to provide liquidity for Movement DAO." _(pg. 6)_                                                                                             |        20% |
|  2  | "Movement DAO will pay a bounty for all improvements implemented by the community. Movement DAO has **$800,000** worth of _day one tokens earmarked_ to support such community development."_(pg. 6)_                 |      \$800k |
|  3  | "**10%** of all Movement funding is earmarked for product development."_(pg. 7)_, _Minimum **5%** of tokens are to fund product development._ (pg. 90)                                                                | 10%, \$1.6m |
|  4  | "Movement DAO has earmarked **5% of tokens** for the community and will distribute over **\$1,000,000** in tokens over the **first year directly for community contributions**."_(pg. 70)_                            |    \$1m, 5% |
|  5  | "BAYC Giveaway ...The giveaway is a random lottery. 1st place: A bored ape ... mutant ape, a pastel ape."_(pg. 80)_                                                                                                   |   \$318,817 |
|  6  | "Movement DAO commits to: Minimum **5%** of all tokens go towards movements. _Minimum **5%** of tokens are to fund product development._ Minimum **5%** of all tokens are to compensate community members."_(pg. 90)_ |         15% |

The following additional statements were made in reference to describing the DAO's revenue model.

1.  "**John Galt**'s tokens are **“locked”** after launch meaning that none of **Galt**'s tokens can be re-sold to a community member or transferred to a third party for value." _(pg. 72)_
2.  "Exit Tribute. Fixed amount of every token sale that funds the budget. A high exit tribute dissuades pump and dump, but could also ward off potential community members." _(pg. 75-76)_
3.  "Entry Tribute. Fixed amount of every token purchase that funds the budget. A high entry tribute creates less price stability, but will provide more immediate funding." _(pg. 75)_
4.  "Annualized Deflation. A percent of the endowment automatically converted into a spendable budget." _(pg 76)_
5.  "Vesting Period. A predefined time period where token holders cannot access their entire purchased tokens. Vesting reduces vote fraud and pump and dump schemes. Movement DAO recommends vesting periods for most use cases." _(pg. 76)_
6.  "Vesting Penalty. The penalty for selling vested tokens early. The vesting penalty decreases linearly from the specified penalty amount to zero over the course of the vesting period." _(pg. 76)_

The following table represents an aggregate of the Breslow Group's promises in the November 11, 2021 Developer Budget, August 2022 Merkaba Engagement Agreement, September 2021 Ted One Agreement, January 28, 2022 published GitBook, Movement Discord, August 2022 MIP-0003 Bootstrap Development, and August 2022 Gordon promises to the community.

(As of June 14, 2022, the Movement Gnosis had **DAI 14,379,850.00** (**USD 14,352,387.25837**) and **ETH 867.57986098** (**USD 1,063,245**) for a total of **USD 15,415,632.25837** which was memorialized in the [06/14/22 MIP-0001 Snapshot Proposal to convert DAI 555,000 to ETH](https://snapshot.org/#/movedao.eth/proposal/0x5494278f1f52faed8f2a0d61f0909d81d92364fa871a2b9183a61ce179bc7671), which by 08/10/22, the Gnosis balance increased **USD 16,271,642.46** a gain of **USD 856,010**. For the purposes of computing the percentages of the Breslow Group promises, the Gnosis balance will not include the gain but the original contributions of **USD 15,415,632.25837**. The Movement Contribution Website advertised the DAO's **"Yearly Budget"** using the 06/14/22 balance **USD 15,415,632.25837** was contributed, thus about **2,312,344.83876**. Ethereum, in 2022, was as high as USD 1,965 and low as USD 896, and in 2023, as high as USD 2,000.)

#### Table, Breslow Group Promised Community Payouts/Allocations

| Purpose                         | Source/Exhibit              |  Compensation |        Tokens |      Dollar Value |
| :------------------------------ | :-------------------------- | ------------: | ------------: | ----------------: |
| Legal Services                  | Yurchak Invoice             |               |        44,992 |        $44,991.70 |
| Development Role                | Developer Budget            |               |       100,000 |       $100,000.00 |
| Development Role                | Developer Budget            |               |       100,000 |       $100,000.00 |
| Development Role                | Developer Budget            |               |       100,000 |       $100,000.00 |
| Development Role                | Developer Budget            |               |       100,000 |       $100,000.00 |
| Developer Role Multisig\*       | Developer Budget            | $4,000,000.00 |       600,000 |     $4,600,000.00 |
| Yearly Budget (2022)            | Website                     |               |             - |     $2,312,344.83 |
| Source Code Bounty              | GitBook _(pg. 6)_           |               |       800,000 |       $800,000.00 |
| Product Dev (10%)               | GitBook _(pg. 7)_           |               |  1,541,563.22 |     $1,541,563.22 |
| Community (5%)\*\*              | GitBook _(pg. 70)_          |               |    770,781.61 |       $770,781.61 |
| Community (2022)                | GitBook _(pg. 70)_          |               |     1,000,000 |     $1,000,000.00 |
| BAYC Giveaway                   | GitBook _(pg.79-81)_        |   $318,817.00 |             - |       $318,817.00 |
| Product Dev Fund (5%)           | GitBook _(pg. 90)_          |               |    770,781.61 |       $770,781.61 |
| Movement Grants (5%)            | GitBook _(pg. 90)_          |               |    770,781.61 |       $770,781.61 |
| Community (5%)                  | GitBook _(pg. 90)_          |               |    770,781.61 |       $770,781.61 |
| Authorized Member               | Gordon Budget               |   $150,000.00 |       100,000 |       $250,000.00 |
| Governance, documentation       | Gordon Budget               |   $120,000.00 |       100,000 |       $220,000.00 |
| Marketing, documentation        | Gordon Budget               |    $96,000.00 |       100,000 |       $196,000.00 |
| Marketing, business development | Gordon Budget               |   $150,000.00 |       100,000 |       $250,000.00 |
| Onboarding workflow             | Gordon Budget               |    $96,000.00 |       100,000 |       $196,000.00 |
| Onboarding business dev         | Gordon Budget               |    $60,000.00 |       100,000 |       $160,000.00 |
| Operations                      | Gordon Budget               |   $150,000.00 |       150,000 |       $300,000.00 |
| Service Provider (2%)           | GitBook _(pg. 48, "Steve")_ |   $334,327.41 |             - |       $334,327.41 |
|                                 |                             |     **Total** | **8,219,681** | **16,007,170.60** |

Over the course of the DAO's operations, the Breslow Group never drafted, proposed, or otherwise made any effort to fulfill any of the promises which they made in the GitBook through Discord or Snapshot.

On December 30, 2022, the Breslow Group ordered Phillips to cease all the DAO's spending, in effect, terminate all the DAO's contributors, and to send the Gnosis treasury to them.[^2] On February 15, 2022, Gordon and Fine explained to the DAO that contributions to the Gnosis did not determine voting control, rather the distribution of Movement NFTs by which initial governance was configured, therefore the Breslow Group voting claims were illusory.[^3] On December 24, 2021, Fine shared with Phillips a spreadsheet tracking the entire DAO launch including its GitBook, marketing, and other activities (hereafter "Breslow Group Checklist").[^4] The Breslow Group Checklist evidences that the Breslow Group architected the entire DAO launch. This timeline of events and specific facts are concerning for the Authorized Members and the DAO's community members.

This proposal seeks to make explicitly clear that the Breslow Group authored the GitBook and Movement Contribution Website and that the Authorized Members, the DAO, and its community members had nothing to do with the GitBook promises. This proposal further seeks to ratify the voiding of any references or association with the GitBook.

## Thesis

The Breslow Group authored the GitBook in its entirety. This proposal documents the history, provides the Git evidence, and disavows any affiliation with the GitBook and its promises.

## Motivation

To maintain the integrity of the DAO and protect the interests of its community members, it is essential to have the community ratify the disassociation and voiding of any association with the originally published GitBook. Further proposals seek the dispersal of the treasury to contributors to the DAO's Gnosis.

## Specification

The immediate removal of all GitBook links and the Gitbook's affiliation with the DAO, with the exception of the preservation of evidence.

With that said, the Token Terms of Service are still to be in effect and are not a part of this proposal, and the current snapshot weight will still be in effect through out the wind-down process. There will potentially be an update to remove reversed contributions from the snapshot weights, which will be proposed as a MIP.

## Rationale

The DAO wants to terminate all affiliation with the Gitbook, as it was authored by the Breslow Group, who is no longer a part of the DAO or holds any interest in it.

## Risks

While this proposal seeks to minimize risks, there are still potential challenges:

Legal and Regulatory Risks: The act of publishing false material for the purpose of obtaining property is a matter for law enforcement and likely violates regulatory requirements. The attempt to claim the entire treasury after onboarding contributors, retaliatory legal actions against the Authorized Members, and other false statements may lead to investigations of larger patterns by certain individuals. This proposal seeks to mitigate these risks by publishing evidence of those culpable for the GitBook, it's promises, and the Contribution Website. The only references to GitBook are for the preservation of evidence, and any links, references, or material which may be construed as an endorsement of the GitBook or its promises are hereby voided.

Community Damages: The breadth of damages incurred by the DAO's contributors is unknown, as is the breadth and number of individuals who relied on the GitBook's promises, including those that intended to seek funding from the DAO for its Movements.

To mitigate these risks, it is essential to involve legal experts, adhere to the established timeline, and maintain transparent communication with the community throughout the wind-down process.

## Snapshot Consensus by the DAO Members

Whereas the DAO through its Members voted to adopt the following actions via Snapshot and resolves as follows:

**RESOLVED:** Movement DAO ratifies the cancellation of the GitBook, voiding all association with GitBook promises, or affiliation with the Breslow Group's statements related to the DAO beyond GitBook and Contribution Website, based on what was explained above;

**RESOLVED FURTHER:** That the Authorized Members convened and are hereby jointly and severally authorized to take any and all actions, along with executing or signing any cryptocurrency transactions, and executing and delivering any other documents, agreements, instruments, and/or certificates as he or she may deem necessary, advisable, or incidental, in connection with the preceding resolution, and other resolutions herein, or any related documents. This also includes authorization to perform or resolve the obligations of the DAO, and/or its affiliates.

This approval by the DAO Members by Snapshot vote shall be effective as of the date the DAO Entities receives a majority vote of the DAO at the end of the Snapshot vote.

This action by the DAO may be executed in any number of counterparts, each of which shall constitute an original and all of which together shall constitute one action.

----
[View Proposal →](https://docs.move.xyz/daolabs/daos/move/proposals/mip-0032.md)

[PDF download](https://docs.move.xyz/pdfs/mips/mip-0032.pdf) | [IPFS mirror](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafkreif72jll4ttm6zkie5rnhgy5s7rma2izmkkzyfuis345sxezbkky3a)

[^1]: [December 6, 2021 Breslow IC Agreement with Mark Phillips](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafybeif7nu5e3bl3h5uax6dvpfdff3hpu532hv6sz5mr2xdorfham6w6ke)
[^2]: [December 30, 2022 Breslow email to Phillips Re: Stop All Treasury Spend](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafkreidbaqt6lpk7fvfvlg6wqeu3su6ho6kjo4qltwqhcur5fwribxk4sa)
[^3]: [February 15, 2022 Gordon, Fine Discord Re Movement NFT Voting Governance](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafkreifln2nlyjgs5tffhc7vxtcjtmtlpf6vtsoght3fnqojeeptwh2p2e)
[^4]: [December 24, 2021 Fine Spreadsheet Re Full Launch, Breslow Group Checklist](https://nftstorage.link/ipfs/bafkreicsto4ebcsfnub2ilodbew34v6wca2kz6m62hhk6teo656viyf3vi)

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

