# SIP-12 Defer Special Council and Guiding Contributor Elections

- Space: [Slingshot DAO](https://snapshot.box/s:slingshotdao.eth.md)
- Author: 0xd6159fF1F17B804b9C46eB9ACfd5FcD86b34A9Ae
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2024-05-06 12:00 UTC
- End: 2024-05-11 12:00 UTC
- Votes: 29
- Quorum: 1,088,568 voting power
- Discussion: https://discord.com/channels/1087517906709000342/1234867618226241546
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:slingshotdao.eth/proposal/0x604755ef13db5844d31117f49a96980ff365653628f13ddde55ac92f6e95ad14

## Results

- For: 5,347,652.15 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

This proposal puts forward the deferral of Special Council and Guiding Contributor elections until May 2026 (at the latest), to allow immediate continuity, assurance and focus among DAO contributors.

Original forum post: https://discord.com/channels/1087517906709000342/1234867618226241546 

Link to a PDF copy of the proposal on IPFS: https://slingshot.mypinata.cloud/ipfs/QmPFXpszKbmxBqE32MwVeo66CfqyB7SmonofD8VKpu4q7n 

CID(s): 
- QmPFXpszKbmxBqE32MwVeo66CfqyB7SmonofD8VKpu4q7n
- Qme2rm9MK3bhrn5CW1wtFeeSF8Q85bg3WoxdPmvSt17FZP 

Link to a diff of the affected items in the Governance Framework: https://slingshot.mypinata.cloud/ipfs/Qme2rm9MK3bhrn5CW1wtFeeSF8Q85bg3WoxdPmvSt17FZP 
# Summary
As the web3 industry is heating up and we near the completion of SIP-11 (the treasury diversification and incoming liquid assets for the DAO), I believe that in the near term, it is a critical time for the DAO to come together and focus on improvements and community growth. 

With many people’s attention returning to web3, there’s great opportunity for the DAO in the near future.

However, we have imminent election requirements for the Special Council and Guiding Contributors.

The need for elections causes uncertainty for many contributors in the DAO, who will be wondering what the outcome of the elections will be and how it may affect them, at a time that the DAO needs to be coming together with a sense of urgency, assurance and a clear focus.

Therefore, I propose to defer Special Council and Guiding Contributor elections to 2026 and allow all contributors to the DAO to carry on pursuing the DAOs mission and community growth with security and clarity.

# Authors
winglash

# Sponsorship
gimmers.eth
nftsorbust

# Proposal Type
Governance proposal.

# Community Incentive & Rationale
With SIP-11 coming to a close the DAO is targeting to receive up to $6,000,000 of liquid assets in the near future. Alongside this, the web3 industry has grown quickly in the last 12 months, with the attention of many individuals returning to the space. 
I believe that the near future for the DAO holds great opportunities for community growth and for everyone who participates in the DAO ecosystem.

However, we also have the governance requirements to run Special Council and Guiding Contributor elections in early 2024. 

The need for elections causes uncertainty for many contributors in the DAO, who will be wondering what the outcome of the elections will be and how it may affect them. 

This uncertainty is counterproductive at a time that the DAO stands to benefit greatly from the unified efforts of its contributors.

With this in mind, I propose to defer Special Council elections to **May 2026** at the latest, with the option to be held beforehand if a timely opportunity arises. I propose to defer Guiding Contributor elections to a later time at the discretion of the Special Council.

# Risks
## Risks if this proposal is not passed:
- The DAO spends time and resources on running its first elections instead of pursuing its mission.
- The DAO misses out on opportunities in the rapidly growing web3 industry as its efforts are focused elsewhere.
- Contributors leave the DAO as a result of uncertainty, lowering productivity across the DAO.
## Risks if this proposal passes:
- Risks are limited as any incumbent Special Council Member or Guiding Contributor can still be impeached, as per the Governance Framework.
 # Key Terms
## Special Council
Members of the Special Council are elected to protect the democracy, the integrity and the safety of the DAO. The Special Council advises on proposals, reviews changes to governance, supports the SlingShot Foundation and helps with dispute resolution when needed.
## Guiding Contributors
Guiding Contributors each organize and coordinate the efforts of a Working Group. To give the DAO the best advice, GCs have closely matched past experience and skills to their Working Group.
## Contributors
Community members who collaborate and help the DAO.
## SIP-11
A proposal for treasury diversification, passed at general vote on the 3rd of March 2024.

# Specifications

## Proposed Change 1
**Action**:
Amend existing item


**Summary**:
Change Governance framework items to defer SC & GC elections to May of 2026.


**Framework item number:**
[4.2] Term Length


**Parent item number:**
[4] Guiding Contributors


**Current legislation:**
“Guiding Contributors serve terms of up to a maximum of 14 months in a given seat before the seat must be re-elected.:
Any handover period is not included in the maximum term length.
If 14 months is surpassed without an election then the incumbent Guiding Contributor must stand down.”


**Proposed legislation:**
“Following the first elections, Guiding Contributors serve terms of up to a maximum of 14 months in a given seat before the seat must be re-elected:
Any handover period is not included in the maximum term length.
If 14 months surpasses without an election then the incumbent Guiding Contributor must stand down.”

## Proposed Change 2
**Action**:
Amend existing item


**Summary:**
Change Governance framework items to defer SC & GC elections to May of 2026.


**Framework item number:**
[4.4] Guiding Contributor Elections


**Parent item number:**
[4] Guiding Contributors


**Current legislation:**
“An individual can only become a Guiding Contributor as a direct result of a Guiding Contributor election for that seat.
All seats must undergo at least one Guiding Contributor election every 14 months, regardless of any interim elections.”


**Proposed legislation:**
“From the first elections onwards: 
An individual can only become a Guiding Contributor as a direct result of a Guiding Contributor election for that seat.
All seats must undergo at least one Guiding Contributor election every 14 months, regardless of any interim elections.”

# Proposed Change 3
**Action**:
Amend existing item


**Summary:**
Change Governance framework items to defer SC & GC elections to May of 2026.


**Framework item number:**
[4.4.3.1] First & Second Election


**Parent item number:**
[4.4.3] Election Timings


**Current legislation:**
“The first election should be run as and when needed.
Within this first election the schedule for the second election run should also be defined.
The second election must occur within 12 months following the first election. This countdown begins at the moment of the first Guiding Contributor to be voted in.
Any remaining unfilled or newly defined seats must continue to run elections as soon as reasonably possible until all the seats have been filled.”


**Proposed legislation:**
“The first election should be run as and when needed, as advised by the Special Council.
Within this first election the schedule for the second election run should also be defined.
The second election must occur within 12 months following the first election. This countdown begins at the moment of the first Guiding Contributor to be voted in.
Any remaining unfilled or newly defined seats must continue to run elections as soon as reasonably possible until all the seats have been filled.”

## Proposed Change 4
**Action:**
Amend existing item


**Summary:**
Change Governance framework items to defer SC & GC elections to May of 2026.


**Framework item number:**
[12.1] Term length


**Parent item number:**
[12] Special Council


**Current legislation:**
“Special Council members serve terms of up to a maximum of 14 months in a given seat before the seat must be re-elected.
Any handover period is not included in the maximum term length.
If 14 months is surpassed without an election then the incumbent Special Council Member must stand down.”


**Proposed legislation:**
“From the first election onwards:
Special Council members serve terms of up to a maximum of 14 months in a given seat before the seat must be re-elected.
Any handover period is not included in the maximum term length.
If 14 months is surpassed without an election then the incumbent Special Council Member must stand down.

## Proposed Change 5
**Action:**
Amend existing item


**Summary:**
Change Governance framework items to defer SC & GC elections to May of 2026.


**Framework item number:**
[12.4] Special Council Elections


**Parent item number:**
[12] Special Council


**Current legislation:**
“An individual can only become a Special Council member as a direct result of a Special Council election for a seat.
All seats must undergo at least one Special Council election every 14 months, regardless of any interim appointments.”


**Proposed legislation:**
“The first elections for the Special Council should occur no later than the end of May 2026.
From the first elections onwards: 
An individual can only become a Special Council member as a direct result of a Special Council election for a seat.
All seats must undergo at least one Special Council election every 14 months, regardless of any interim appointments.”

## Proposed Change 6
**Action:**
Amend existing item


**Summary:**
Change Governance framework items to defer SC & GC elections to May of 2026.


**Framework item number:**
[12.4.3] Election Timing Requirements


**Parent item number:**
[12.4] Special Council Elections


**Current legislation:**
“Elections for all seats should begin at the start of each calendar year.
The exact timeline for elections is at the discretion of the Working Group currently focused on Governance.
However the elections for all seats must begin before the end of March each calendar year.”


**Proposed legislation:**
“Following the first election, consequent elections for all seats should begin at the start of each calendar year:
The exact timeline for elections is at the discretion of the Working Group currently focused on Governance.
The elections for all seats must begin before the end of March each calendar year.”

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

