# FULL VOTE: Migration to a New Onchain Governance Platform

- Space: [Shutter DAO 0x36](https://snapshot.box/s:shutterdao0x36.eth.md)
- Author: 0x0f853a4c50763e0553Ac44E2546C0178B417c0Ba
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-08-10 12:00 UTC
- End: 2026-08-13 12:00 UTC
- Votes: 11
- Quorum: 30,000,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://shutternetwork.discourse.group/t/migration-to-a-new-onchain-governance-platform/867
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:shutterdao0x36.eth/proposal/0x564c94e3becbf4411a1574738d7e0ebd6914d9104084a86a19ea7ab4b264fec1

## Results

- Anticapture: 10,558,360.26 voting power, 26.5%
- Snapshot X: 29,256,364.16 voting power, 73.5%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

## Background

Decent recently informed us that they will be stopping operations in the near future. They also recommended that Shutter DAO 0x36 migrate to a new onchain governance platform.

## Choices
(Listed in alphabetical order)

- Anticapture
- Snapshot X

## Summary

|  | **Anticapture** (blockful) | **Snapshot X** (Snapshot Labs) |
|----|----|----|
| **What it is** | A frontend on top of the DAO's existing Azorius/Decent contracts | A new onchain governance protocol, added as a Zodiac module on the existing Safe |
| **Contracts** | No change. DAO stays on Azorius | Azorius module swapped for a Snapshot X module. Same Safe, same treasury |
| **Price** | $24k USDC/year | $0 — no migration fee, no protocol fees, no platform fee |
| **Voter gas** | Can be DAO-sponsored if desired | Gasless by default via DAO-sponsored relayer |
| **Other costs** | Execution tx paid by whoever executes | Execution tx paid by whoever executes. Relayer top-ups at "a few dollars per proposal" |
| **SLA** | "Standard SLA." No published uptime or response-time figures. DAO bug fixes and feature requests go "to the front of our queue" | 99% monthly uptime; priority response within 4 hours; spam/malicious proposal detection within 2 hours; dedicated Telegram group with the core team |
| **Migration steps** | None. Live since March 2025 at [shutter.gov.blockful.io](https://shutter.gov.blockful.io/proposals) | 7 steps, 2 already done: (3) create space → (4) internal testing → (5) Safe vote to add module → (6) DAO test transactions → (7) remove Decent module when satisfied |
| **Timeline** | Available today | Parallel run live within August; DAO retires Decent on its own schedule |
| **Migration risk** | Zero — no contracts touched | Additive and parallel; one-action rollback; no treasury movement, no history migration, no downtime |
| **Token / delegations** | Unchanged | Unchanged. SHU used as-is via ERC-20 Votes (EIP-5805); existing delegations carry over automatically |
| **Notable features** | Delegation, voting, proposal creation, complete governance/holder analytics; notification system (telegram, slack), deep data/analytics with focus on security | Gasless voting, execution builder, multisig voting, shielded voting retained, custom domain, delegates dashboard, Discourse in-interface, Snapshot MCP for AI agents |
| **Upgradability** | Bounded by Azorius, which is frozen and no longer developed | Modular — authenticators, voting strategies, proposal validation and execution strategies are swappable by the DAO's controller. No re-migration needed for new features |
| **Long-term maintenance** | blockful maintains the frontend; the underlying contracts currently have no maintainer - blockful has expertise to maintain the contract and update if necessary| Core protocol on Snapshot's onchain roadmap; Shutter engineers are already upstreaming private voting into the Snapshot X monorepo |

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

