# [GP-9] Maximizing Borrower Value: Why the Move to Morpho Matters

- Space: [Seamless](https://snapshot.box/s:seamlessprotocol.eth.md)
- Author: 0xEDB39288230D41C316542fE3f22B005eD150d342
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2025-03-24 15:01 UTC
- End: 2025-03-27 15:01 UTC
- Votes: 42
- Discussion: https://seamlessprotocol.discourse.group/t/gp-maximizing-borrower-value-why-the-move-to-morpho-matters/930
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:seamlessprotocol.eth/proposal/0x901e2aed03877d64a0414496f69b7febb76272cf4a1526c6d3b8813dac455074

## Results

- For: 1,622,241.26 voting power, 82.2%
- Against: 351,499.99 voting power, 17.8%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

**Abstract**

The Seamless protocol has grown from its origins into a dynamic ecosystem centered on borrowing, leverage, and accessibility. This proposal outlines a pivotal shift: migrating liquidity from the legacy platform to Morpho Vaults. This move optimizes borrower value and supports community expansion, aligning with [Seamless’s vision of a streamlined, 'platformless' future](https://seamlessprotocol.discourse.group/t/gp-what-drives-seamless-core-beliefs-vision-future/584).

**Benefits of Migrating to Morpho Vaults**

Morpho Vaults provide a permissionless, efficient platform that unlocks significant advantages for borrowers. Key benefits include:

* **Significant Liquidity Growth**: Morpho Vaults (supporting assets like USDC, sBTC, and WETH) have achieved $70M in Total Value Locked (TVL) within the past month, dwarfing the legacy platform’s $15M.
* **Improved Borrower Access**: With no permission barriers, Morpho enables broader participation, empowering more users to tap into borrowing opportunities.
* **Cost Efficiency**: Unlike the legacy platform, Morpho eliminates third-party service fees and resource-heavy overhead, making borrowing more affordable.
* **Support for Innovation**: Morpho paves the way for cutting-edge products, such as Leverage Tokens outlined in the [2025 Product Roadmap](https://x.com/SeamlessFi/status/1899912753520808419), offering borrowers greater flexibility.

**Challenges of the Legacy Platform**

The legacy Seamless platform, originally built on an AAVE V3 fork, fueled early success but now poses obstacles to progress. Its limitations include:

* **High Fixed Costs**: Monthly maintenance expenses of $29.8K USD (totaling $443.7K annually) burden core contributors and drain resources.
* **Resource Demands**: Engineering focus is consumed by upkeep rather than innovation, stalling development of new features.
* **User Impact**: These inefficiencies limit user yield opportunities and impose tighter borrow limits, reducing the platform’s competitiveness and appeal.

Sunsetting the legacy platform is a critical step to remove these constraints and refocus efforts on Morpho Vaults.

**Proposal Summary**

I propose a community vote to migrate liquidity from the legacy platform to Morpho Vaults and, over the next 2-3 months, sunset the legacy platform and ILM v1.0. This aligns with the protocol’s roadmap, freeing resources to prioritize a near-term launch of Leverage Tokens and realize the community’s vision. Here is the suggested plan:

* **Snapshot Vote**: Gauge community support for this migration plan, authorizing subsequent on-chain votes without additional discussion periods.
* **Phased Sunset**: Over 2-3 months, pause deposits, phase out rewards, and guide users to Morpho Vaults (for legacy liquidity) and Leverage Tokens (for ILM v1.0 users).
* **Migration Bonus** for ILM v1.0 Users: Since Leverage Tokens are not yet available but on the near-term horizon in the coming month or so, I suggest offering a migration bonus (potentially an airdrop) for loyal ILM v1.0 users who redeposit into Morpho Vaults until Leverage Tokens launch. The DAO can determine the details through discussion or a future vote.
* **Consideration for Legacy Users**: Morpho Vaults have excellent rewards and serve as a direct alternative for legacy platform users.

**Goals and Objectives**

* **Resource Consolidation**: Redirect engineering efforts and SEAM rewards to the protocol’s core mission of borrowing and leverage, emphasized by [Leverage Tokens launching this/next quarter](https://x.com/SeamlessFi/status/1899912753520808419).
* **Maximize DAO Value**: Simplify operations, reduce fixed costs (e.g., third-party provider fees), and improve community outcomes.
* **Ensure a Smooth Transition**: Reward loyal users, especially ILM v1.0 users impacted by the sunset, through suitable incentives and clear communication.

**Proposal Details**

Here is a rough (draft) timeline for the migration and sunset process, spanning approximately ~3 months beginning mid-March 2025:

* **Legacy Liquidity**: Users will see UI banners encouraging withdrawal and redeposit into Morpho vaults (with a clickable link provided).
* **ILM v1.0 Users**: With Leverage Tokens (ILM v2.0) not yet live, I propose a migration bonus, such as an airdrop, for users who redeposit into Morpho vaults within 1 month of the proposal, should it be approved, with a random snapshot to be taken by DAO to inform rewards, until v2.0 is available. The DAO will refine these specifics through discussion or a future vote.

This timeline is flexible, aligning with approximate dates while offering users a clear transition path.

**Technical Details**

**Smart Contract & Backend Actions**

* **GOVERNANCE**: Prevent new deposits via `setReserveFreeze(asset, true)`; allow withdrawals.
* **GUARDIAN**: Stop on-chain rewards with `setEmissionPerSecond(asset, 0)`.
* **GOVERNANCE**: Disable reward emissions using Aave’s `RewardsController`; later vote to clawback surplus SEAM rewards.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

