# QIP250: Deprecate QiDao deployment on Fraxtal

- Space: [Qi Dao | Mai.Finance](https://snapshot.box/s:qidao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x044325aCCB1A131cD00B4Cef674E9a8d9b60ad72
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2026-04-25 06:26 UTC
- End: 2026-04-28 06:26 UTC
- Votes: 5
- Quorum: 600,000 voting power
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:qidao.eth/proposal/0x76868a1b00f4792f47016b3afef53be0b4ed981e6cfbbbade098c8f4d6ad0078

## Results

- For: 781,737.36 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

---
network: Fraxtal
author: 0x22cFAE74Ed0B44eeCd9b0cba30D74B47EE13dbFF
created: 2026-03-13
---

## Summary

This proposal seeks to deprecate the QiDao deployment on Fraxtal, including the full sunset of the **sfrxETH collateral vault** and the **MAI token contract**. There is no outstanding debt and no circulating MAI on Fraxtal, making this a **zero-risk, zero-user-impact deprecation**.

---
## Abstract

This proposal deprecates the QiDao deployment on Fraxtal by shutting down the **sfrxETH collateral vault** and permanently removing the ability to mint MAI on the chain. Before shutdown, vault parameters will be standardized to match similar deployment configurations. The vault will have its **borrow limit** and **interest rate** set to zero, preventing any new loans or interest accrual. Given the immutable nature of the MAI token contract, a complete sunset requires calling the function **`renounceOwnership`**, the only mechanism that permanently removes minting capability on the chain.

---
## Motivation

QiDao is present on many chains; however, not all of them gained sufficient traction to justify their maintenance. The goal of this proposal is to **simplify the protocol’s active footprint and focus resources on ecosystems that generate meaningful activity and revenue**. The Fraxtal deployment has seen **no borrowing activity since launch** and currently has **no MAI supply**. Maintaining an inactive deployment introduces unnecessary **smart contract and operational risks** with no benefit to the protocol.

Deprecating Fraxtal will:

- Remove deployed contracts from the protocol's attack surface  
- Permanently remove a native minting capability from the MAI token on this chain  
- Allow the DAO to focus monitoring, maintenance, and growth on active chains  

---
## Specification

The following changes are required on the deployed contracts on Fraxtal.

### sfrxETH Vault  
`0xbf1aea8670d2528e08334083616dd9c5f3b087ae`

| Variable | Value to Set | Function to Call | Timing |
|---------|-------------|-----------------|--------|
| adm | `0xbbbe9837120ab7BA7C2660b399DA27Dfb7188542` (Revenue Manager) | `setAdmin` | Upon approval |
| adminFee / refFee | `10000 / 0` | `setFees` | Upon approval |
| maxDebt | `0` | `setMaxDebt` | Upon approval |
| iR | `0` | `setInterestRate` | Upon approval |
---

### MAI Token  
`0xb84Df10966a5D7e1ab46D9276F55d57bD336AFC7`

| Function | Timing |
|---------|--------|
| `renounceOwnership` | Upon approval |
---

## Rationale

### Parameter Standardization and Vault Shutdown

The Fraxtal deployment uses a **standard QiDao vault contract**, which does not support upgrading. Setting **maxDebt to zero** prevents new borrowing. While there is no outstanding debt, setting the **interest rate to 0** aligns it with other offboarded vaults and prevents any potential interest accrual against historical positions.

In addition, setting the **admin to the Revenue Manager** and standardizing the **admin/ref fee split** ensures all deprecated vaults share a consistent final configuration.

---
### MAI Token Sunset

The Fraxtal MAI token is also an **immutable contract** with no pause or upgrade functionality.
Renouncing ownership is the only mechanism that permanently removes the ability to:

- Mint MAI  
- Seed new vault debt ceilings  

Once ownership is renounced, it **cannot be reclaimed**, making the deprecation **permanent and irreversible at the token level**.

---
## Technical Specification

Configurable values are defined in the **Proposal Payload (PP)** attached.

All five transactions are to be **batch executed by the QiDao Guardians multisig**: `0xe7748203ec71eeBb207700dA94A3F829Bf0632F7` on **Fraxtal**.

Transactions:
- 1. Standardization of fees split to match similar deployments.  
- 2. Set admin address to Revenue Manager Multisig.  
- 3. Disable borrowing by setting MaxDebt to zero.  
- 4. Halt interest accrual by setting Interest Rate to Zero.  
- 5. Renounce MAI token ownership. Guarantees a complete and irreversible chain deprecation at the token level.

---
## Voting Options

- **For**: Deprecate MAI on Fraxtal as specified above.
- **Against**: Do not deprecate; maintain the current deployment.
- **Abstain**

## Transactions

```json
[
  {
    "multisig": "0xe7748203ec71eeBb207700dA94A3F829Bf0632F7",
    "transactions": [
      {
        "chainId": 252,
        "to": "0xbf1aeA8670D2528E08334083616dD9C5F3B087aE",
        "function": "setFees",
        "args": [
          "10000",
          "0"
        ],
        "value": "0",
        "annotation": "Standardize fee split on the sfrxETH vault to adminFee=10000 / refFee=0, matching other deprecated deployments."
      },
      {
        "chainId": 252,
        "to": "0xbf1aeA8670D2528E08334083616dD9C5F3B087aE",
        "function": "setAdmin",
        "args": [
          "0xbbbe9837120ab7BA7C2660b399DA27Dfb7188542"
        ],
        "value": "0",
        "annotation": "Transfer vault contract admin to the Revenue Manager multisig"
      },
      {
        "chainId": 252,
        "to": "0xbf1aeA8670D2528E08334083616dD9C5F3B087aE",
        "function": "setMaxDebt",
        "args": [
          "0"
        ],
        "value": "0",
        "annotation": "Set sfrxETH vault debt ceiling to zero, permanently disabling new MAI borrowing on Fraxtal"
      },
      {
        "chainId": 252,
        "to": "0xbf1aeA8670D2528E08334083616dD9C5F3B087aE",
        "function": "setInterestRate",
        "args": [
          "0"
        ],
        "value": "0",
        "annotation": "Set interest rate to zero, halting any potential interest accrual against historical positions."
      },
      {
        "chainId": 252,
        "to": "0xb84Df10966a5D7e1ab46D9276F55d57bD336AFC7",
        "function": "renounceOwnership",
        "args": [],
        "value": "0",
        "annotation": "Renounce ownership of the MAI token contract on Fraxtal, permanently and irreversibly removing native minting capability on this chain."
      }
    ]
  }
]
```

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

