# Opal Restructuring Proposal

- Space: [Opal DeFi](https://snapshot.box/s:opaldefi.eth.md)
- Author: 0xAc2A9e91e63b0E58305d8f6e8d29EDe53F6d7Be8
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2025-05-08 16:33 UTC
- End: 2025-05-10 22:00 UTC
- Votes: 9
- Discussion: https://opaldefi.discourse.group/t/opal-restructuring-proposal/80
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:opaldefi.eth/proposal/0xfec137f8e7f601c451bd8bccd3eab57ee938a830c22f30aab9660c4b3822ce0d

## Results

- Option 1: 209,576.16 voting power, 98.7%
- Option 2: 2,678.79 voting power, 1.3%

## Proposal

TL;DR:

This proposal recommends transitioning Opal to a reserve token model, discontinuing active development, and redistributing value to maintain decentralization through GEM token holders.

Background:

The Omnipool market has experienced a substantial loss of momentum in recent months, a trend that has been particularly highlighted by the shutdown of narrative leaders such as Conic. This market contraction signals broader challenges within the ecosystem that directly impact Opal’s operational viability and growth potential.

Concurrently, we’ve observed a sharp decrease in APRs across LSTs and LRTs pools. This decline in yield generation has significantly undermined the efficiency of omnipools, which rely on competitive returns to attract and retain liquidity providers. The diminished yield landscape presents a fundamental challenge to Opal’s value proposition.

Multichain expansion, which represented the ultimate brick of Opal flywheel, has introduced substantial barriers to the protocol development cycle. The technical architecture faces inherent limitations regarding time-sensitive on-chain operations, particularly in the distribution and rebalancing of Omnipool liquidity between underlying pools. These operations require precision timing and execution that are incompatible with the inherent latency and coordination challenges of multichain environments.

Perhaps most critically, the release of Balancer v3 update necessitates a complete rework of Opal’s contracts. This represents not merely an incremental adjustment but a fundamental redesign of the protocol’s architecture.

Rationale:

In light of these challenges, we propose a strategic restructuring of the Opal protocol, through two viable options for the DAO to consider:

Both options imply halting all maintenance and protocol upgrades. Given the required complete rebuild for Balancer v3 compatibility and the diminishing returns on current development efforts, allocating additional resources to the existing architecture provides questionable value.
Since either path requires halting the protocol and associated emissions, A decision appeared clear to discontinue all token emissions to the omnipools and withdraw PoL tokens. This ensures no further value leakage and reduces the circulating supply of GEM considered in RFV and revenue-sharing calculations, ultimately supporting a higher price per token.

Option 1: Redeemable Fair Value (RFV)

Under the RFV option, we would conduct a thorough verification of all eligible GEM tokens to ensure accurate redistribution of protocol value. This process would include a complete halt to GEM emissions, effectively ending the inflationary aspects of the tokenomics.

The treasury assets would be converted predominantly to USDC to provide stability, though a buffer premium can be defined to retain some exposure to ETH and other strategic volatile assets. This balanced approach protects backing value while maintaining some upside potential.

A clear deadline for all vesting claims would correspond to the date of the proposal approval, after which unclaimed tokens would be burnt. This ensures all legitimate stakeholders have an opportunity to secure their entitled tokens while providing closure to outstanding obligations.

Finally, the duration for the RFV mechanism should correspond to the date of the last vlGEM unlock plus a one week claiming delay, after what remaining assets in the treasury should be airdrop to RFV participants, establishing a timeframe during which token holders can redeem their GEM for their proportional share of treasury assets. This creates a clear path to resolution and value recovery for all stakeholders.

Option 2: Revenue Sharing (RevShare)

The RevShare option presents an alternative approach focused on sustainable yield generation. As with Option 1, GEM emissions would cease immediately to prevent further dilution of token value.

We would establish a comprehensive farming strategy framework built entirely on Protocol-Owned Liquidity.This approach eliminates reliance on external liquidity providers and creates a self-sustaining economic model.

The core of this option is the activation of a revenue sharing module that distributes 50% of all farming rewards directly to vlGEM holders, providing ongoing value to those who have demonstrated long-term commitment to the protocol. The remaining 50% of farming rewards would be automatically compounded back into the Protocol-Owned Liquidity, creating a virtuous cycle of growth. This distribution would operate on a regular epoch-based schedule, providing predictable returns to stakeholders while growing the protocol’s assets.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

