# Make Scouts with OVR +80 age faster

- Space: [MetaSoccer](https://snapshot.box/s:metasoccer.eth.md)
- Author: 0x0Bae1695AD0034E0Eb1c121DF904AB919Ae4951A
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2024-02-16 12:00 UTC
- End: 2024-02-23 12:00 UTC
- Votes: 77
- Quorum: 1,000,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://metasoccer.notion.site/Scouting-Mechanics-Revamp-Proposal-Refinement-806bfb797da14d188a353d608f7d6b91?pvs=4
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:metasoccer.eth/proposal/0xd51edd3a11adec57cda98da1c18df6bad0a361c631a5d33e8ef50e2386aa108c

## Results

- 2x for Scouts with OVR 80+ AMI: 83,575.25 voting power, 1.0%
- 2x for Scouts with OVR 80+: 60,000 voting power, 0.7%
- 1.5x for Scouts with OVR 80+ AMI: 3,114,319.38 voting power, 35.5%
- 1.5x for Scouts with OVR 80+: 15,599.36 voting power, 0.2%
- Do not increase aging speed: 5,336,703.26 voting power, 60.9%
- Abstain: 155,448.44 voting power, 1.8%

## Proposal

After implementing [Proposal #2 | Cost & Cooldown adjustment (Draft)](https://www.notion.so/Proposal-2-Cost-Cooldown-adjustment-Draft-03a81c636db04ac69e713a9c842a39d5?pvs=21), an important issue will arise: **lower-level scouts will face a considerable challenge in catching up with higher-level ones**, as the latter have improved without aging and requiring a significantly less amount of resources. **We believe this creates an unfair disadvantage for newcomers embarking on their journey in the MetaSoccer Universe**. Not only will they need to invest more resources to attain the same level of skill in a scout, but they will also have to wait longer.

To provide some context, if we implement [Proposal #2 | Cost & Cooldown adjustment (Draft)](https://www.notion.so/Proposal-2-Cost-Cooldown-adjustment-Draft-03a81c636db04ac69e713a9c842a39d5?pvs=21) and we don't implement [Proposal #4 | Restoring balance (Draft)](https://www.notion.so/Proposal-4-Restoring-balance-Draft-ae4e290197764ddb87972084e3b8b029?pvs=21), high-level Scouts will be able to conduct six times more scouting sessions than they currently do, and at a cost that, on average, is 25% lower per session. Naturally, reaching level 99 will require more sessions, thus increasing the need for MSU (almost four times for high-end scouts), but if high-level scout owners can afford these sessions, they will saturate the market with high-level players, depreciating their value and making it difficult for lower-level scout owners to keep pace.

Our proposal is to **make scouts with an Overall Rating (OVR) equal to or greater than 80 [at the time of implementation] age faster,** cutting their lifespan and thus the maximum amount of scouting sessions they can perform.

**If we don’t introduce this change**, we anticipate the following scenario:

- 15% of the teams competing in MetaSoccer will have, on average, 1 player with OVR 90+ (vs only 4.9% if we decrease the lifespan of Scouts).

---

**Voting choices**: AMI means "At the Moment of Implementation", i.e. taking a snapshot when the feature is implemented and consider only those Scouts included in the snapshot.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

