# Gnosis, Ledger or Both?

- Space: [JustSomeDAO](https://snapshot.box/s:justsomedao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x371B4BAe7FB2eD01f592263d217b5B9a88Ce0202
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2022-11-14 03:47 UTC
- End: 2022-11-20 07:59 UTC
- Votes: 6
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:justsomedao.eth/proposal/0xfa690c4e24dc652dd129b8f332824e78facc30eeeb93d6e029edd55c9df8a6c8

## Results

- Ledger only: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Gnosis only: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Ledger now, Gnosis later: 25 voting power, 100.0%

## Proposal

Thank you to those that voted on the last proposal. We have missed our 0.07 entry for a Ledger Black on Black Nano X. Although we will not benefit from an inexpensive entry, we still have options. 

I apologize in advance for the length of this proposal. If you have no interest in the details, there is a summary at the bottom. 


We are in strange times and want to find the best safety measure for our situation and ensure that it is a scalable choice. Or, at the very least, we have t plan to transition to an alternative standard as we scale. 

loltapes has brought up the idea of using a Safe Wallet on the Gnosis Protocol. This is a multi-signature wallet that only allows a transaction to be executed after the desired number of signatures is reached. 

For example, we could create a Safe Wallet controlled by three elected members in our community and their corresponding wallets. Transactions in this scenario would require two of the three members to sign off on the transaction before it can be processed. There are pros and cons to this method. 

Pros: The Safe Wallet is more secure than a standard "hot wallet" like MetaMask. For a scammer/hacker to obtain control of the Safe Wallet in the scenario above, they would have to gain access to two of the three wallets. This also means that the treasury is decentralized, and no individual can take control of the DAO funds. 

Cons: Signing for a transaction will take longer than usual. If the purchase is not pre-planned, then executing a purchase or sale could be heavily delayed due to the availability of treasury controlling members. If only one of the three members is available, but the DAO wants to execute a transaction, it will be impossible until one of the other two members become available. 

Here are links to Gnosis and Safe if you would like to read more about the protocol or wallet. 

https://gnosis.io/protocol/
https://app.safe.global/welcome

Besides using a Safe Wallet, we still have the option to execute our original proposal but increase the WETH offering to the current market bid. A Ledger gives the treasury some of the best "cold wallet" storage and security. Given the current cryptocurrency/blockchain climate, it could be wise to move our NFTs to cold storage; however, this is a centralized hold and may be unattractive to new members. 

We can purchase and use a Ledger for the short run and then transition to a Safe Wallet as we grow. As we receive more members and the crypto world stabilizes, we can open a Safe Wallet and use the Ledger for an alternative purpose or even raffle it off. 


In summary: 

The crypto world is crazy right now, and we need better security.
We have three options on the table unless otherwise proposed: 

1) Go with the original option of buying a Ledger. We would increase the offer to market bid. We would then keep all treasury assets on the Ledger until otherwise agreed upon. The Ledger will be in the control of Maaaaahhhaaaaa. 

2) Use a Safe Wallet and determine the number of signatories in the DAO and the number of signatures needed per transaction in the following proposal. 

3) Put in WETH offers for a Ledger Nano Black and use the Ledger until the DAO grows to a larger size, at which time we will switch over to a Safe Wallet and determine the number of signatories and signatures. The Ledger will be in the control of Maaaaahhhaaaaa. Once we have transitioned to Safe Wallet, the Ledger can but used for an alternative DAO purpose or raffled off to members.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

