# SCP-227: DFC 2027 Renewal and Chairperson Election

- Space: [ShapeShift Ideation](https://snapshot.box/s:ideation.shapeshiftdao.eth.md)
- Author: 0xff75E131c711e4310C045317779d39B3B4f718C4
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-11-12 21:03 UTC
- End: 2026-11-19 21:30 UTC
- Votes: 4
- Discussion: https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/scp-227-dfc-2027-renewal-and-chairperson-election-ideation/3518
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:ideation.shapeshiftdao.eth/proposal/0x975d269abc414b866b9935eb2de2651b8dee7fa9c2f54d8a6019b499ac907912

## Results

- For: 1,842,704.56 voting power, 27.9%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- For with changes: 4,771,046.38 voting power, 72.1%

## Proposal

SCP-227: DFC 2027 Renewal and Chairperson Election — IDEATION
Summary
This proposal renews the DAO Finance Committee (DFC) for calendar year 2027 following the departure of the current Chair and Tokenomics Workstream Leader.

It seats Bishop as DFC Chairperson, moves the DFC to a leaner operating structure, preserves the cost controls established under SCP-213, clarifies DFC voting and treasury authority, and establishes a structured transition before the current Chair exits at year-end.

The intent is to preserve necessary financial governance without recreating the Tokenomics Workstream inside the DFC.

Abstract
SCP-213 established that if the Tokenomics Workstream Leader position was not renewed, a governance proposal should be brought forward to elect a DFC Chairperson if the DFC was expected to continue.

This proposal fulfills that requirement.

The proposed 2027 DFC will operate as a focused financial-governance body responsible for treasury oversight, budget and runway monitoring, DFC-authorized treasury decisions, multisig coordination, and documented financial-governance processes.

Duties that belonged to the Tokenomics Workstream Leader do not transfer to the DFC Chair unless they are separately assigned through governance.

The proposal also addresses areas where existing treasury processes have left room for different interpretations, particularly around revenue recognition, strategic asset treatment, DFC authorization, and multisig execution.

The goal is not to assign fault retroactively. The goal is to reduce ambiguity going forward.

Motivation
The DAO is operating under leaner conditions and the DFC should reflect that reality.

With the current Chair and Tokenomics Workstream Leader stepping away at year-end, several issues need to be resolved before January 1, 2027:

Chair continuity: The DFC needs a defined person responsible for meetings, agendas, research coordination, governance posts, voting administration, follow-up, and DFC coordination.

Scope clarity: Responsibilities historically performed by the Tokenomics Workstream Leader must be separated from the narrower responsibilities of the DFC Chair.

Treasury controls: Recent discussion around the treatment of blue-chip protocol revenue demonstrated that revenue recognition, treasury disposition, DFC authorization, and multisig execution would benefit from clearer boundaries.

Operational continuity: Treasury oversight, approved transaction execution, budget monitoring, and governance decisions should not depend on undocumented institutional knowledge.

Cost discipline: The DFC should remain small and operate within the maximum compensation already authorized under the SCP-213 structure.

The DFC remains relevant so long as the DAO requires independent financial oversight, treasury governance, budget monitoring, and an accountable process between governance decisions and treasury execution.

Specification
Role Structure
The 2027 DFC will consist of:

1 DFC Chairperson — Paid

Responsible for DFC operating leadership and the duties defined in this proposal.

2 Paid DFC Contributors

Expected contribution remains approximately three hours per week per contributor:

approximately one hour of preparation;

one hour for the weekly DFC meeting; and

approximately one hour of follow-up, research, or assigned DFC work.

1 Paid Alternate

The Alternate attends meetings and remains current on DFC matters but has no standing preparation or follow-up requirement unless formally substituting for a voting member.

All DFC members are expected to be reasonably available for emergency votes or urgent discussions when treasury or governance conditions require timely attention.

Seating the Chair
This proposal nominates Bishop as DFC Chairperson effective January 1, 2027.

Bishop is a current DFC contributor and brings more than 20 years of financial-services experience, including risk analysis, DeFi governance, treasury analysis, and financial-control work.

Upon assuming the Chair role, Bishop gives up his paid DFC contributor seat.

Future Chairs will be selected from current DFC contributors by DFC vote and confirmed through governance.

If the Chair position becomes vacant without an immediate successor, remaining voting members may temporarily rotate meeting facilitation until a replacement is confirmed.

Chair Duties and Boundaries
The DFC Chair is responsible for operating the DFC, not replacing the Tokenomics Workstream Leader.

The Chair will:

host and facilitate weekly DFC meetings;

prepare and maintain agendas, minutes, and action items;

perform or coordinate research required for DFC decisions and treasury reviews;

administer DFC voting, including asynchronous votes when necessary;

lead DFC-related governance posts and proposal coordination;

serve as the primary liaison to active workstreams and treasury participants on DFC matters;

maintain the DFC operating calendar, runbook, and open-item tracker; and

coordinate with multisig signers and treasury operators to ensure approved actions are executed and documented.

The Chair does not inherit Tokenomics Workstream duties, DAO-wide leadership duties, tokenomics data maintenance, general workstream management, partnership development, or other responsibilities previously performed by the Tokenomics Workstream Leader unless separately assigned through governance.

DFC Scope
For 2027, the DFC is responsible for:

treasury oversight, including regular review of balances, composition, liquidity, and runway;

budget tracking against approved DAO budgets and identification of material variance or runway risk;

review and approval of treasury actions within the DFC’s delegated authority;

direction and oversight of multisig execution for approved DFC and governance decisions;

coordination of approved revenue swaps, FOX Farming renewals, and other existing treasury processes falling within the DFC mandate; and

documenting material treasury decisions, rationale, voting outcome, approving authority, and execution status.

Broader tokenomics strategy, maintenance of tokenomics datasets, or creation of new treasury mandates remains outside the DFC’s scope unless separately assigned through governance.

Treasury and Multisig Authority
The DFC and multisig signers perform different control functions.

The DFC provides oversight and decision-making within its delegated mandate. Authorized multisig signers execute transactions pursuant to governance decisions, DFC decisions, or clearly documented standing instructions.

A multisig signer may execute an action that:

has been explicitly approved by governance;

has been explicitly approved by the DFC and falls within its delegated authority; or

falls under a documented standing instruction that clearly defines the assets, action, limits, and conditions covered.

A transaction that changes treasury asset composition outside an explicit standing instruction requires DFC approval before execution unless broader governance approval is required.

All DFC-approved treasury transaction requests must be posted in the designated #treasury channel with the approving DFC vote or governance authority referenced before multisig execution.

Multisig signers will use that channel to verify authorization, coordinate execution, and report completion.

Discussion in other channels does not, by itself, constitute transaction authorization.

The existing 24-hour notification and 7-day execution standard remains in effect for approved DFC transactions where applicable.

This proposal does not create new unilateral emergency authority. Where existing authority permits immediate action to prevent loss or protect DAO assets, that action should be communicated to the DFC as soon as practicable and documented after execution.

Strategic Blue-Chip Revenue Treatment
For DFC purposes, revenue recognition and treasury asset disposition are separate decisions.

Revenue received in a DAO-designated Strategic Blue-Chip Asset may be recognized at its applicable USD value for revenue reporting without requiring automatic conversion into USDC or another stablecoin.

Strategic Blue-Chip Assets received as revenue will remain in their native asset unless:

the DFC approves conversion or rebalancing;

an existing approved allocation policy expressly authorizes the transaction; or

DAO governance directs the transaction.

A standing instruction to convert protocol revenue does not, by itself, authorize liquidation of an asset specifically designated for strategic treasury accumulation.

The DFC will periodically review designated Strategic Blue-Chip Assets and any applicable retention, concentration, allocation, or rebalancing parameters.

Material conversions should include a documented rationale, approving authority, voting record where applicable, transaction amount, and resulting treasury impact.

DFC Voting
The Chairperson and each seated paid DFC Contributor receive one vote.

The Alternate is non-voting unless formally substituting for a voting member.

Quorum is a majority of currently filled voting seats.

A DFC action requires a simple majority of participating voting members once quorum has been established.

A tied vote does not pass.

Asynchronous and emergency votes are permitted and use the same quorum and approval standards.

The Chair facilitates and documents the voting process but may not unilaterally approve a DFC action.

Cadence
The DFC will meet weekly on Tuesdays at 6:00 PM Eastern Time, with asynchronous updates between meetings and ad hoc meetings or votes when urgent matters require action.

Transition and Handoff
Before the current Chair and Tokenomics Workstream Leader exits, the outgoing and incoming Chairs will complete a structured transition.

The transition will include:

a complete Chair operating calendar covering weekly, monthly, quarterly, annual, and ad hoc responsibilities;

a written DFC Chair and treasury-operations runbook;

an inventory of relevant dashboards, documents, communication channels, multisig resources, recurring processes, and required access;

a documented list of standing treasury instructions, open votes, recurring obligations, unresolved decisions, and known operational risks;

at least three hands-on transition sessions covering process walkthrough, reverse-shadow execution by the incoming Chair, and exception/reconciliation review; and

a final open-items and continuity memo before December 31, 2026.

The objective is for the incoming Chair to independently operate the DFC beginning January 1 without inheriting undocumented Tokenomics responsibilities.

Membership Rules
Adding a new paid DFC member continues to require both DFC approval and formal governance approval.

All seats remain subject to the annual renewal requirement established under SCP-213.

The proposed 2027 structure authorizes two paid contributor seats and one paid alternate seat in addition to the Chair.

Effective Term
If approved, this structure will remain effective from January 1, 2027 through December 31, 2027, unless amended or superseded through governance.

Renewal beyond 2027 requires a subsequent governance proposal consistent with the annual renewal framework established under SCP-213.

Budget
All DFC compensation will continue to be paid in FOX. Eligible members may elect locked FOX incentives pursuant to SCP-81.

Chairperson:
1 seat × $1,000 FOX-equivalent/month = $12,000/year

DFC Contributors:
2 seats × $500 FOX-equivalent/month = $12,000/year total

Alternate:
1 seat × $125 FOX-equivalent/month = $1,500/year

Total DFC Compensation:
$2,125 FOX-equivalent/month
$25,500 FOX-equivalent/year

This does not exceed the maximum monthly compensation authorized under the SCP-213 structure of four paid contributors at $500/month plus one alternate at $125/month.

The proposed structure reallocates part of that existing compensation capacity to a paid Chair while reducing the number of contributor seats.

Chair Compensation Rationale
Regular DFC contributors are compensated $500/month against an expected workload of approximately three hours per week.

The Chair role is expected to require approximately four to six hours per week when meeting preparation, research, governance coordination, vote administration, treasury/multisig coordination, and follow-up are included.

At approximately six hours per week, the proposed $1,000/month Chair compensation results in roughly the same implied hourly compensation as the existing contributor rate.

This proposal therefore does not require an increase to the maximum DFC monthly compensation established under SCP-213.

Q1 2027 Workload Review
During Q1 2027, the Chair will track time spent across major activity categories.

Before the end of March, the DFC will review whether actual workload remains consistent with the four-to-six-hour weekly assumption used in this proposal.

Any material change to Chair scope or compensation requiring governance approval will be brought separately.

KPIs
The 2027 DFC will evaluate itself against the following operating measures:

Meeting continuity: Weekly DFC meetings occur as scheduled or are formally replaced with an asynchronous process when necessary.

Decision documentation: Material DFC decisions include a recorded vote, rationale, authority, and identified owner.

Treasury execution: Approved treasury actions are communicated to multisig signers within the established notification standard and execution status is reconciled.

Budget oversight: Treasury, budget, and runway conditions are reviewed regularly, with material variances or risks raised to the appropriate governance audience.

Control traceability: Material treasury transactions can be traced from decision or standing authority through #treasury, multisig execution, and completion.

Transition completion: The Chair runbook, access/resource inventory, standing instructions, and transition sessions are completed before the current Chair’s departure.

Workload discipline: Q1 Chair workload is measured against the four-to-six-hour weekly assumption so scope creep can be identified rather than informally absorbed.

Scope of Supersession
If passed, this proposal supersedes SCP-213 only where necessary to establish the 2027 Chair role, Chair compensation, DFC headcount, voting structure, cadence, treasury-control clarifications, and transition requirements described above.

SCP-213 compensation rates for regular contributors, annual renewal requirements, and membership rules otherwise remain in effect.

SCP-181 nomination, election, and removal processes remain in effect except where this proposal explicitly establishes the 2027 Chair selection and operating structure.

SCP-81 remains available to eligible members electing locked FOX incentives.

Benefits
This proposal:

prevents a DFC leadership gap after the current Chair exits;

preserves treasury oversight and budget/runway monitoring during a period of reduced DAO staffing;

separates DFC leadership from the broader Tokenomics Workstream role;

clarifies the relationship between treasury decision authority and multisig execution;

reduces ambiguity around strategic blue-chip revenue;

creates a documented transition before institutional knowledge leaves the DAO; and

maintains the existing SCP-213 maximum DFC compensation ceiling.

Drawbacks
A smaller DFC has less capacity if DAO activity materially increases.

Some responsibilities previously performed by the Tokenomics Workstream Leader may remain unowned unless separately assigned.

The Chair becomes a direct DFC expense rather than being compensated through another workstream.

Additional controls may slow some non-routine treasury transactions when an action falls outside established standing authority.

Annual renewal continues to create governance overhead.

Vote
For — Renew the DFC for 2027 under the structure, scope, compensation, Chair selection, treasury controls, voting rules, and transition requirements described in this proposal.

Against — Do not renew the DFC under the proposed 2027 structure.

For, with Changes — Support continuation of the DFC but request specific modifications before the proposal advances to final governance. Please identify the requested changes in the forum discussion.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

