# [Ideation] SCP-228: Accept and distribute the Zcash retroactive grant for ShapeShift's Zcash work

- Space: [ShapeShift Ideation](https://snapshot.box/s:ideation.shapeshiftdao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x1cCb160C00E5e4a81821079E1A6ab75FEe5Cd833
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-11-10 10:51 UTC
- End: 2026-11-17 10:36 UTC
- Votes: 5
- Discussion: https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/ideation-scp-228-accept-and-distribute-the-zcash-retroactive-grant-for-shapeshifts-zcash-work/3520/3
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:ideation.shapeshiftdao.eth/proposal/0x6b605a315c8e86b79e3ea804d79a668a01e9bc5ca6f76f814a0ff38f2b1813c8

## Results

- For: 11,404,707.66 voting power, 100.0%
- For with Changes: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

IDEATION

## Summary
I (gomes) wrote the grant application and this SCP, and this proposal would pay me 25% of the award, in ZEC (about $5,595 if the full $22,380 is awarded), for finding and preparing the grant after my contract ended. On 9 Nov 2026, kaladinlight and I applied on the DAO's behalf for $22,380 from the Zcash Coinholder Retroactive Grants program, covering Zcash engineering that no grant has paid for ([application](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/102)). This SCP keeps the application in, appoints me as custodian of the shielded ZEC unless a treasury ZEC address is ready first, and sends the rest, 75% of the award (about $16,785 if the full $22,380 is awarded), to the treasury under the DFC.

## Background
The Zcash Coinholder Retroactive Grants program is run by the Financial Privacy Foundation and voted on by ZEC holders. It pays for completed, public, MIT-licensed Zcash work. For Q4 2026, applications close on 13 Nov, review runs from 16 Nov to 16 Dec, and ZEC holders vote from 17 to 29 Dec. Payment follows in shielded ZEC about two to three weeks later.

The application covers work since November 2025 that [ZCG#81](https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/81) never listed: Zcash support on Ledger and Trezor, ZEC swaps on NEAR Intents and THORChain, the NU6.2, NU6.3 and NU7 upgrades, ZEC in the public API, and walletless ZEC swaps in the widget. The ask is priced at cost: 1.76 engineer-months, rebuilt from the public GitHub history, at $17,500, the [SCP-224](https://snapshot.box/#/s:shapeshiftdao.eth/proposal/0x5138ce866d18844cec8de87b56c22666f3761535efb7f01d654dcd0e9ebfcf7d) rate, less the $8,420 described below. The [application](https://github.com/Financial-Privacy-Foundation/ZcashCoinholderGrantsProgram/issues/102) contains the full breakdown.

In 2025, [ZCG#81](https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/81) awarded the DAO $50,000: $36,000 for a year of node hosting and $14,000 for marketing, with $0 for engineering. The DAO received 201.06 ZEC on 25 Feb 2026. In December 2025, it had said it would return about $8,420 of the marketing money, but the grant was paid in full in February and we found no record that anything was returned. This application deducts that $8,420 and excludes everything listed in the earlier grant: the node, native wallet, Maya, testing and marketing. The grant was paid to a shielded address, so its path is not public. We have asked the treasury team how it was converted and where the marketing balance went, and will post the answer here.

The application was filed before this SCP because the 13 Nov deadline fell before a governance vote could finish. It can be withdrawn any time before the ZEC holder vote opens on 17 Dec, leaving time for the DAO to decide how to proceed.

## Abstract
If ZEC holders approve the grant, gomes will receive it in a dedicated shielded wallet with a public viewing key. Within 14 days, he will make the approved transfers and publish every transaction ID in this thread. The DFC, as constituted when the ZEC arrives, will manage the treasury share under its existing grant mandate in [SCP-170](https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/2948). If no grant is awarded, there are no transfers and no cost to the DAO.

## Motivation
The grant would reimburse the DAO for engineering it already funded, without treasury spending. The application commits the DAO to keep ZEC signing current through network upgrades and keep ZEC in the app, API and widget, which is existing Engineering work under [SCP-224](https://snapshot.box/#/s:shapeshiftdao.eth/proposal/0x5138ce866d18844cec8de87b56c22666f3761535efb7f01d654dcd0e9ebfcf7d). The work was done by DAO contributors, and kaladinlight remains one. Applying on the DAO's behalf makes that clear; separate individual applications would have looked like a second payment for the same work.

The proposed payment to gomes covers the grant work. His contract ended in March 2026 when Engineering was restructured under [SCP-212](https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/3383). After leaving, he found the round and worked with kaladinlight on the application and this SCP without pay. He will also handle custody. The grant work runs from November until the transfers are done in January: the application and this SCP, the Zcash forum review and Q&A through the 29 Dec vote, custody, conversion and reporting. At the full ask that is about $5,595, under a third of a month at the [SCP-224](https://snapshot.box/#/s:shapeshiftdao.eth/proposal/0x5138ce866d18844cec8de87b56c22666f3761535efb7f01d654dcd0e9ebfcf7d) rate. The DAO already paid him for his Ledger, Trezor and NEAR Intents code; none of that is paid again.

The DAO settled responsibility for the OP grant only after it reached the treasury, through [SCP-170](https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/2948). This proposal settles custody, distribution and reporting before the ZEC arrives.

## Specification

### Custody
1. FPF pays to one shielded address given after the vote. The DAO has no published Zcash address: [ZCG#81](https://github.com/ZcashCommunityGrants/zcashcommunitygrants/issues/81)'s ZEC went to a shielded wallet held by the treasury team, which is not public, and [SCP-214](https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/3390) keeps treasury signers anonymous. ShapeShift DAO contributors are setting up a treasury ZEC address, but there is no guarantee it will be ready in time, so this SCP names gomes as custodian as the fallback. If the treasury address is ready before 17 Dec, the DFC posts it here, the grant is paid there, and every step below applies to its holders.
2. Before the ZEC holder vote opens on 17 Dec, he creates a shielded wallet used only for this grant and posts its **full viewing key** in this thread. The key lets anyone see every ZEC received and sent without giving them access to spend it.
3. Within 14 days of receipt, he completes the distribution below and posts every transaction ID here.

### Proposed distribution
| Recipient | Amount | Asset | Address |
|---|---|---|---|
| ShapeShift DAO treasury, managed by the DFC | 75% of the ZEC received | USDC, or ZEC if the DFC chooses | [`0x90a48d5cf7343b08da12e067680b4c6dbfe551be`](https://app.safe.global/home?safe=eth:0x90a48d5cf7343b08da12e067680b4c6dbfe551be) |
| kaladinlight (current contributor) | none; his work on the code and the application was part of his paid role under [SCP-224](https://snapshot.box/#/s:shapeshiftdao.eth/proposal/0x5138ce866d18844cec8de87b56c22666f3761535efb7f01d654dcd0e9ebfcf7d) | | |
| gomes (Engineering contributor Feb 2022 to Mar 2026) | 25% of the ZEC received | ZEC, shielded | his shielded address, posted here before the final vote |

The custodian executes the distribution as follows:
1. Convert 75% of the ZEC received to USDC through the app's own routes, NEAR Intents or Maya, and send it to the mainnet treasury Safe, unless the DFC posts a decision here to hold ZEC. Slippage above 2% requires the DFC's approval. Network and swap fees come out of this share.
2. Then send gomes 25% of the ZEC received.
3. Publish every transaction ID in this thread.

Both shares are counted in ZEC at the program's payout rate, so until the treasury share is converted, a move in the ZEC price hits both in proportion. gomes's payment comes only from the grant, never from the treasury. Because the payment is a fixed share, a smaller award shrinks it automatically; everything else goes to the treasury.

### If things go differently
- **If this SCP fails,** at Ideation or in the final vote, the Against option below applies: the application stays in and 100% goes to the treasury. The application is withdrawn only if this SCP has had no vote close by 16 Dec. Against does not withdraw it; if FOX holders ask for withdrawal during Ideation, the final vote will add it as an option.
- **If the ZEC holder vote fails,** nothing happens.

### Scope of supersession
This proposal does not supersede any prior SCP and does not set a fee for future grants: any later grant split needs its own SCP. The treasury share remains subject to the DFC's existing grant mandate in [SCP-170](https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/2948).

### KPIs
- The application is listed for the 17 Dec vote, with the "Ready For Vote - All Steps Completed" label on its GitHub issue.
- If the grant is awarded, the viewing key has been posted before 17 Dec, all transfers are completed within 14 days of receipt, and every transaction ID is published in this thread.

## Benefits
The treasury receives money for work the DAO already paid for. The custody and reporting steps can be reused for a later grant.

## Drawbacks
The custodian is also a beneficiary. The public viewing key, transfer deadline and fixed share let holders check that he follows the distribution they approved. If the proposal fails, he must forward the whole grant to the treasury. FOX holders can change the amount during ideation. Paying a former contributor from a grant is new for the DAO.

A named person holds the ZEC in their own name for up to 14 days, with the personal tax and sanctions-screening exposure that comes with it. There is no custody fee. The award is fixed in USD on the payout date, but the value of the treasury share moves with ZEC until conversion.

**Conflict of interest:** I (gomes) wrote the application and this proposal, will hold the grant, and would receive 25% of the award under it, about $5,595 at the full ask. I was a paid Engineering contributor from February 2022 to March 2026 and now work at Vultisig, which has no involvement in this grant. kaladinlight is still a paid contributor; this SCP pays him nothing, since his time on the application was part of his paid role.

## Vote
- **For:** keep the application in, approve the custody arrangement and distribution above, and authorize the transfers. Under either option, the DFC can name a current contributor as custodian in this thread before 17 Dec.
- **For, with changes** (ideation only): support the proposal with amendments and explain the changes in the thread.
- **Against:** make no payment to gomes. The application stays in. The custody steps (grant-only shielded wallet, viewing key before 17 Dec, conversion and transfer within 14 days, every transaction ID posted) still apply so the DAO can receive the grant, and gomes stays custodian, unpaid, unless the DFC names a different one in this thread before 17 Dec. 100% goes to the treasury for the DFC to manage under [SCP-170](https://forum.shapeshift.com/t/2948).

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

