# [HIP-37] Add Beets Gauge and Remove Unused Gauges

- Space: [Hermes Protocol](https://snapshot.box/s:hermesprotocol.eth.md)
- Author: 0xc1DaC41a18e8262eDb5e8D0ade4B1B2aa2260c4F
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2025-02-25 16:20 UTC
- End: 2025-02-28 16:20 UTC
- Votes: 2
- Quorum: 2,768,554 voting power
- Discussion: https://common.xyz/hermes-omnichain/discussion/26950-hip37-add-beets-gauge-and-remove-unused-gauges
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:hermesprotocol.eth/proposal/0x42b1aac5ef057ed457636de50fc594dcccb56bdbc1a24df175bc9c4a1241e371

## Results

- Yay: 8,530,159.91 voting power, 100.0%
- Nay: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

**Proposal ID: S1.11** 


## Introduction 


This proposal aims to enhance the utility and efficiency of the gauge system by introducing a **Beets / wS gauge** on Arbitrum while removing underperforming Mainnet meme gauges. To maintain system focus and prevent unnecessary gauge dilution, the following Mainnet meme gauges will be removed: 


- **APU/WETH** 

- **KEKEC/WETH** 

- **SPC/WETH** 

- **BITCOIN/WETH**

- **PEPE/WETH**

- **SHIB/WETH** 

- **ZOOMER/WETH** 

- **JOE/WETH** 

- **MOG/WETH** 


These will be replaced with: 

- [**Beets / wS**](https://arbiscan.io/address/0x46bb2930fFdC1Abe780078FF7957dD813f58Bc42) - 1% (min width: 1800)


## Strategic Alignment 


1. **Strengthening Strategic Partnerships**: Adding a Beets / wS gauge aligns with fostering collaboration with Beethoven X. 

2. **Streamlining System Focus**: The removed meme gauges on Mainnet have shown minimal adoption, liquidity, or strategic value. Pruning these optimizes gauge efficacy, reduces fragmentation, and reallocates incentives to high-potential pools. 


## Gauge Performance Analysis 


- **Meme Gauges**: The proposed Mainnet meme gauges (APU, KEKEC, SPC, etc.) have consistently underperformed, with negligible TVL, low trading volume, and minimal community engagement. Their removal frees resources without impacting ecosystem health. 


- **Beets / wS**: Beethoven X’s established presence on Arbitrum and existing user base position this gauge for rapid adoption. Beets’ collaboration will amplify visibility, driving liquidity and participation. 


## Market Impact Analysis 


- **Positive Growth**: Introducing Beets / wS taps into Beethoven X’s community, attracting new users and capital to the ecosystem. This fosters cross-protocol synergy and fee generation. 


- **Ecosystem Cleanup**: Removing inactive meme pools sharpens focus on high-value gauges, improving user experience and protocol efficiency. 


- **Risk Mitigation**: The proposal avoids over-saturation, ensuring incentives remain concentrated where they deliver maximum impact. 


## Next Steps 


1. Approve Gauge addition. 

2. Launch promotional campaigns with Beets to bootstrap liquidity and engagement.

## Calldata

**Gauge Addition Calldata:**
  0x5d6b2a9d00000000000000000000000046bb2930ffdc1abe780078ff7957dd813f58bc42000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000004000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000200000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000708

**Gauge Removal Calldata:**

0x3a04514500000000000000000000000011baa8622d4ba56cc0716efbf2421cf488bbc9b2

0x3a0451450000000000000000000000003451c0d4507655b1636712d54e46f814812d20c2

0x3a045145000000000000000000000000351a32b84e5869d98e2a429d03923508564dc0e0

0x3a045145000000000000000000000000853789b370c32c7200592b108566c4f705cbdf10

0x3a0451450000000000000000000000008b9147b6657072b6230a3b3d6f03ea2d89e92cfd

0x3a0451450000000000000000000000009bf9b52138846150a9786851e18441cdd98a1ce8

0x3a045145000000000000000000000000b60759615e102986118a2aa7d2645e13e2eb9627

0x3a045145000000000000000000000000e54ff34852bab1f9b09969ff1f8b62317f35f4bf

0x3a045145000000000000000000000000e99838f83bc054811d4aedb1d699aada70b77d3a

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

