# Upgrade the Hashflow governance process

- Space: [Hashflow](https://snapshot.box/s:hashflowdao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x34E1AE9a9b3F8e6B648A0e8952cf6C553d65fd62
- State: Rejected
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2023-05-03 21:25 UTC
- End: 2023-05-08 21:25 UTC
- Votes: 235
- Quorum: 100,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://gov.hashflow.com/t/draft-upgrade-the-hashflow-governance-process/598
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:hashflowdao.eth/proposal/0xa049bc237b77e76e3246f8cf2957932e6776943d2ef053cc803cf4b67eab5f8e

## Results

- Yes: 11,593.6 voting power, 78.1%
- No: 3,257.88 voting power, 21.9%

## Proposal

Simple Summary:

This proposal changes the phases of Hashflow Governance in order to both create more rigor / structure, and allow for more voices to be heard. It introduces a multi-stage governance process that allows for more thorough discussions on the proposals and requires more details to be shared prior to passing a vote.

Abstract:

We propose to change the governance process into the following phases:

Phase 1: Request for Comment

User creates forum post to gather initial comments.

Proposal maturity:

- It must be reviewed & commented on for a minimum of 5 days
- It must comply with the designated template
- It must contain all relevant information that would be in the HIP
- It must have thoughtful discussions addressing feedback from the community

Phase 2: Temp Check

After the 5 days comment period, community member can submit a first [Temp Check] Snapshot vote to gauge initial consensus:

- Voting period: 2 days
- Create poll: 10K veHFT
- Majority (50%) passes
- Quorum: 15K veHFT

Phase 3: HIP

If proposal passes the initial [Temp Check], it will advance and become “HIP”

The user:
- Tags forum post title with [HIP]
- Incorporates any last iterations based on feedback

Guardians:
- They are notified to approve or veto
- Need majority approval before it can be submitted by community for final vote
- The same forum post remains open for minimum of 3 days before final vote

Community submits final Snapshot:
- Voting starts after 48h
- Voting period: 3 days
- Create poll: 100K veHFT
- Majority (50%) passes
- Quorum: 100K veHFT

Motivation:

The proposal has the following objectives:
- Drive & grow active participation by meaningful stakeholders within governance
- Streamline end-to-end process & comms
- Promote a decentralized community

Specification & Rationale:

This change would require:
- changes to the existing Snapshot page
- creating another Snapshot page for Temp Check (Snapshot only supports one configuration per page)
- changes to forum categories / templates

Benefits (Pros):
- more time for people to get familiar with the proposals
- higher degree of decentralization
- more rigor and quality around the contents of the proposal

Downside (Cons):
- longer time to pass proposals

Voting
- yes for the structure to change
- no for the structure to stay the same

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

