# Upgrade the Hashflow Governance structure

- Space: [Hashflow](https://snapshot.box/s:hashflowdao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x34E1AE9a9b3F8e6B648A0e8952cf6C553d65fd62
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2023-06-02 21:45 UTC
- End: 2023-06-07 21:45 UTC
- Votes: 161
- Quorum: 100,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://gov.hashflow.com/t/upgrade-the-hashflow-governance-process/610
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:hashflowdao.eth/proposal/0x2e344fd633d84cae7a466d605086e74a3c3548749052df019f913486143117fd

## Results

- Yes: 139,470.01 voting power, 100.0%
- No: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

Simple Summary:

This proposal changes the phases of Hashflow Governance in order to both create more rigor / structure, and allow for more voices to be heard. It introduces a multi-stage governance process that allows for more thorough discussions on the proposals and requires more details to be shared prior to passing a vote. Given that the previous proposal was voted “for” but had trouble reaching quorum, the quorum requirements have been relaxed in this version, which constitutes the only difference between this and the previous version.

Abstract:

We propose to change the governance process into the following phases:

Phase 1: Request for Comment

User creates forum post to gather initial comments.

Proposal maturity:

It must be reviewed & commented on for a minimum of 5 days
It must comply with the designated template
It must contain all relevant information that would be in the HIP
It must have thoughtful discussions addressing feedback from the community
Phase 2: Temp Check

After the 5 days comment period, community member can submit a first [Temp Check] Snapshot vote to gauge initial consensus:

Voting period: 2 days
Create poll: 5K veHFT
Majority (50%) passes
Quorum: 10K veHFT
Phase 3: HIP

If proposal passes the initial [Temp Check], it will advance and become “HIP”

The user:

Tags forum post title with [HIP]
Incorporates any last iterations based on feedback
Guardians:

They are notified to approve or veto
Need majority approval before it can be submitted by community for final vote
The same forum post remains open for minimum of 3 days before final vote
Community submits final Snapshot:

Voting starts after 48h
Voting period: 3 days
Create poll: 25K veHFT
Majority (50%) passes
Quorum: 25K veHFT
Motivation:

The proposal has the following objectives:

Drive & grow active participation by meaningful stakeholders within governance
Streamline end-to-end process & comms
Promote a decentralized community
Specification & Rationale:

This change would require:

changes to the existing Snapshot page
creating another Snapshot page for Temp Check (Snapshot only supports one configuration per page)
changes to forum categories / templates
Benefits (Pros):

more time for people to get familiar with the proposals
higher degree of decentralization
more rigor and quality around the contents of the proposal
Downside (Cons):

longer time to pass proposals
Voting

yes for the structure to change
no for the structure to stay the same

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

