# HIP32 - Complete Decentralization of Validator Network

- Space: [Harmony Mainnet](https://snapshot.box/s:harmony-mainnet.eth.md)
- Author: 0xe8f346E689059D5511D15116C4eE88d593cdAE6d
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2024-03-05 14:00 UTC
- End: 2024-03-19 14:00 UTC
- Votes: 51
- Discussion: https://talk.harmony.one/t/hip32-complete-decentralization-of-validator-network/24026
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:harmony-mainnet.eth/proposal/0x2c862da1cc9036a13d0505cba3aeb44f99ae5b7b7c1ef011aa147f73be9022f0

## Results

- Yes: 2,993,376,943.47 voting power, 100.0%
- No: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

# Abstract
This HIP proposes a comprehensive overhaul of the Harmony Validator Network towards achieving complete decentralization, significantly reducing internal validator influence and increasing community involvement in network consensus mechanisms.

# Motivation
Since its inception, the Harmony network has shown a solid commitment to decentralization. However, the current validator network structure, dominated by internal validators, challenges this ethos. Harmony aims to foster a more secure, efficient, and community-driven ecosystem by transitioning to a fully decentralized validator network.

# Specification
## Background
- Genesis and Progress: The Harmony network, since the genesis block on June 28, 2019, and the subsequent introduction of open staking on May 16, 2020, has gradually reduced internal vote power from 68% to 49%.
- Need for Change: Despite these efforts, further steps are essential to minimize centralized control and fully empower the Harmony community.

## Proposed Changes
1) Validator Slot Adjustment per shard:
- Reduce the internal Harmony validator slot count to zero (0).
- Allocate the available slots to external validators, increasing total slots from 180 to 200 on the mainnet

There will be a total of 400 slots available in total for external with two shards (Shard 0 and 1)

2) Voting Power Adjustment:
- Reduce internal Harmony slot voting power to zero (0).

3) External Leader Rotation:
- Implement external leader rotation to enable democratic and fair leadership among validators

## Operational Challenges and Solutions
1) Risk of Network Hard Forks:
- Implement coordination and contingency planning to prevent network forks while transitioning to external validators.
2) Network Synchronization:
- Transition reliance on internal nodes for network sync to a community-driven approach by designating volunteer validators as sync nodes.
3) Security Measures:
- Transition of the blacklist/allowtx list feature management to external validators for enhanced network security and governance. Note HIP-17 suggested the decommission of the feature.

# Rationale
The proposed changes aim to eliminate central control over the validator network, enhancing network security, efficiency, and community governance. This transition is a critical step towards a fully decentralized, equitable, and sustainable blockchain ecosystem underpinned by community-driven innovation and collaboration.

# Implementation
- Hard Fork: 1 or multiple hard fork will be required to implement external leader rotation, adjust validator slots and voting power.
- Community Involvement: Active engagement with the community to designate sync nodes and transition security measure management to external validators.

# Security Considerations
## Risk Mitigation: 
Careful planning and community collaboration are essential to mitigate risks associated with the transition, such as potential network hard forks.
## Enhanced Security: 
By decentralizing control and involving the community in crucial network functions, the proposal aims to improve the overall security and resilience of the Harmony network.

# Conclusion
Achieving complete decentralization of the Harmony Validator Network is a monumental step towards realizing our vision of a fully inclusive, transparent, and community-governed blockchain ecosystem. This HIP represents a commitment to these principles, inviting all stakeholders to participate in this transformative journey.


# Achieving Quorum

1) Capture the total_stake and validator_stakes from all validators in the network at a given block.
2) Ensure that the sum of all votes (Yes/No/Abstain) received is at least 50% of the total_stake, excluding stakes from known centralized exchanges and large validators who do not wish to participate in governance. (Up to today, only Binance stake are excluded)
3) Achieve a 66.67% consensus vote (Yes) based on the voting pool in point 2.

For questions and additional information, visit the forum.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

