# [Community Poll] GIP-0009: Arbitration Charter

- Space: [The Graph](https://snapshot.box/s:graphprotocol.eth.md)
- Author: 0x37BC95e38235Ec42F185E945922a4E2C9795B391
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2021-06-04 16:00 UTC
- End: 2021-06-11 16:00 UTC
- Votes: 191
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:graphprotocol.eth/proposal/QmTbDGkeaSty1vNirLkpmMPtTqiKLVdSU67ECL5aZmWV43

## Results

- Yes: 931,732,918.28 voting power, 99.9%
- No: 517,523.81 voting power, 0.1%

## Proposal

This is a community poll to measure support for GIP-0009, as well its dependencies: GIP-0008, GIP-0007, and GIP-0005. These changes were presented at recent [protocol town halls](https://forum.thegraph.com/tag/graph-townhall).

- [**GIP-0009**](https://hackmd.io/MMHefHW5TxOOLtqqutP-VA) proposes an Arbitration Charter to clarify the behavior of the Arbitrator in the protocol and specify additional protections for Indexers. 
- [**GIP-0008**](https://hackmd.io/FU2VmNI6QnKK9vj3bQB4MQ) proposes a strategy for specifying the canonical version of subgraph API functionality in the protocol, as well as a support matrix that defines the support level for subgraph API features in the protocol.
- [**GIP-0007**](https://hackmd.io/5MvmhaIARw2ohq2F9xn53w) proposes separate slashing percentages for indexing and query related faults, in order to balance the slashing risk to Indexers of participating in both activities. 
- [**GIP-0005**](https://hackmd.io/Ou0goFbrQGK4uwtogh-cfg) proposes a gas costing scheme for subgraphs in order to implement deterministic timeouts for long-running subgraph handler executions.

The full text of all the above GIPs can be found in [the Radicle repo](https://forum.thegraph.com/t/gip-0001-and-getting-started-with-gips-grps-grcs-etc/1722).  The latest commit as of this poll is `4bba37e454f67201dca8eb51837189a767e1dcc9`. For convenience, copies of the GIPs are also linked above.

**Note**: This is a community poll to gauge support for the current state of the above GIPs. Proposals are subject to change based on community feedback.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

