# Signal Gnosis Guild to revive GIP-99?

- Space: [GnosisDAO](https://snapshot.box/s:gnosis.eth.md)
- Author: 0x918c30482462C8024ba6Cf34a18ba1f8bBdb755F
- State: Rejected
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2026-08-20 11:53 UTC
- End: 2026-08-27 11:53 UTC
- Votes: 20
- Quorum: 75,000 voting power
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:gnosis.eth/proposal/0x8a278f5f4a8704eb9c337f4e5e5a04564febe1ca0d1e61f29a7cbed8daecfed1

## Results

- For: 35.26 voting power, 0.7%
- Against: 5,078.21 voting power, 98.7%
- Abstain: 31.74 voting power, 0.6%

## Proposal

# Summary & Purpose

This proposal is a non-binding signaling vote to gauge **community appetite for inviting Gnosis Guild to revisit the formally steward GnosisDAO governance** under the structural principles originally outlined in GIP-99 (with modular governance infrastructure, staged funding milestones, explicit KPIs, and an independent firewall between governance operations and treasury allocation).

# Disclaimer: Direct All Heat Here

**Zero Prior Coordination:** Gnosis Guild (and Auryn specifically) was **not** consulted, informed, or asked to endorse the posting of this Snapshot.

**Separate the Messenger from the Mandate:** If you take issue with this vote being brought forward or have personal grievances against me, direct all of that friction toward me (@Citrullin). 
**Do not project any political hostility onto Gnosis Guild!**

**Status of GIP-156:** The outcome of the active ban proposal (GIP-156) stands entirely on its own merit and remains fully in effect regardless of how this vote concludes. This signaling vote is strictly about ecosystem governance architecture, not my personal standing.

# Why This Is Directly on Snapshot

Due to the ongoing forum suspension on Discourse, I am restricted from opening standard preliminary discussion threads. Because the forum is inaccessible, submitting this directly as an on-chain Snapshot signaling vote is the only permissionless mechanism available to gauge token-weighted sentiment across all holders.

# Motivation: Technical Stewardship vs. Stagnation

In the public Gnosis Guild Discord, when asked whether Gnosis Guild would be open to stewarding GnosisDAO governance with robust accountability firewalls, Auryn stated:

"Yeah, Gnosis Guild would definitely be interested in something like this. However it's met hard resistance every time we've proposed this in the past, so I'm pretty hesitant to burn time/energy on a new proposal unless there is some strong upfront signal that this is wanted by a critical mass of stakeholders."
![screenshot_gnosis_guild.png](ipfs://bafkreifajr7im55zduyjntma4zqmkuhiudkyma3itiibsjdsvlgnfyluri)
source: https://discord.com/channels/881881751369175040/884778883512147999/1535365809680154727

With major multi-million-dollar treasury requests on the table and critical strategic decisions ahead for Gnosis Chain, stakeholders face a straightforward choice:

**Independent Technical Stewardship:** Empowering an established technical team with deep infrastructure expertise (Zodiac, modular account permissions, anti-bribery governance tooling) to run transparent, accountable operations.

**Status-Quo Stagnation:** Continuing with informal delegate networks, centralized administrative gatekeeping, and the absence of strict firewalls between treasury extraction and governance administration.

This vote exists to provide the unambiguous, **token-weighted signal needed to determine if the ecosystem wants Gnosis Guild to bring forward a formal plan.**

# Voting Options

**YES:** Signal that GnosisDAO stakeholders want Gnosis Guild to draft and submit a refreshed governance stewardship proposal based on GIP-99 principles.

**NO:** Maintain the current governance structure and don't ask Gnosis Guild for a refreshed GIP-99 proposal.

**ABSTAIN:** No preference.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

