# GIP-156: Should @Citrullin be banned from GnosisDAO Governance and Communication Channels?

- Space: [GnosisDAO](https://snapshot.box/s:gnosis.eth.md)
- Author: 0x918c30482462C8024ba6Cf34a18ba1f8bBdb755F
- State: Rejected
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2026-08-17 02:21 UTC
- End: 2026-08-24 02:21 UTC
- Votes: 20
- Quorum: 75,000 voting power
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:gnosis.eth/proposal/0x11e2eb1c02f57a6e48790275e5ccd80685c0bd877a58bef3981b3b9f52ad6aa7

## Results

- For: 23,331.08 voting power, 99.8%
- Against: 12.76 voting power, 0.1%
- Abstain: 25.01 voting power, 0.1%

## Proposal

**Author:** Philipp-Alexander Blum (@Citrullin)
**Status:** Phase 3 (Direct Snapshot Referendum)
**Category:** Governance, Transparency & Contributor Rights
**Voting System:** Single-Choice Voting (YES / NO / ABSTAIN)

# Executive Summary

This proposal puts a direct question to GNO token holders and validators: 
**Should independent engineer and contributor Philipp Blum (@Citrullin) remain banned from GnosisDAO Discourse, Discord, and official communication channels?**

Following the [publication of an open-source proof-of-concept for a stateless zkEVM Account-Lattice](https://forum.gnosis.io/t/gip-xx-sovereign-reth-multi-chain-composability-poc/12412/13) and sustained critique of [GIP-153: Transition into the Ethereum Economic Zone (EEZ)](https://forum.gnosis.io/t/gip-153-should-gnosis-chain-transition-into-the-ethereum-economic-zone/12397/38), Gnosis Ltd. personnel placed the author's Discourse account on administrative hold and issued cross-platform bans under the justification of *"Threatening demeanour and unable to listen to moderator feedback".*

Taking leadership up on their public commitment to "Transparency Maximalism", this vote removes the decision from private Discord channels and places it directly on-chain.

- **A "YES" vote** requires delegates and DAO participants to publicly record their token weight in favor of administrative censorship of technical research.
- **A "NO" vote** or passive non-participation confirms the absence of a community mandate for the ban, establishing that the moderation action was an arbitrary exercise of centralized control.

# Procedural Justification & Context

This referendum is submitted directly to Snapshot, bypassing Phase 1 and Phase 2 Discourse stages because an administrative account hold makes forum posting physically impossible without creating sybil accounts.

The complete timeline and administrative statements are documented on X(formally known as Twitter):
- [Citrullin's Public Statement & Evidence Log](https://x.com/Citrullin/status/2088375732942541098)
- [0xKenk's Public Response](https://x.com/0xKenk/status/2088533161386864827)

# Addressing the Administrative Pretexts

*1. "Ignoring Governance Process and Submitting Incomplete GIPs"*
- **The Claim:** Pointed primarily at [GIP-155: Transition to an Independent Structural Governance Engine and Complete Separation of Powers.](https://forum.gnosis.io/t/gip-155-transition-to-an-independent-structural-governance-engine-and-complete-separation-of-powers/12383/17)
- **The Record:** Gnosis Ltd. personnel actively ignored community threads advocating for voting caps and independent board oversight. Meanwhile, insider proposals such as [GIP-152: Gnosis App Spin-Out](https://forum.gnosis.io/t/gip-152-should-gnosisdao-spin-out-the-gnosis-app-into-an-independent-company/12390/64) ($2.5M capital/IP transfer) advanced through governance despite community calls to restart Phase 1 and Phase 2. The standard for procedural compliance has not been applied equally.

*2. "Numerous Unfounded Accusations Against Participants"*
- **The Claim:** Characterizing critiques of delegate coordination as baseless attacks.
- **The Record:** Official delegate communications confirm that retail and minor token proposals are routinely bypassed without private lobbying. As documented in [Staworth's Delegate Platform](https://forum.gnosis.io/t/staworth-limited-delegate-platform/8770/26):
"It would also be helped to engage in some outreach to delegates or large tokenholders during the early stages of a proposal... Proposals that have festered on the forum for a few weeks with limited engagement are likely to be ignored in favour of newer topics and larger conversations."

*3. "Spamming Forum Threads Constantly"*
- **The Record:** The [Citrullin Discourse Activity Log](https://forum.gnosis.io/u/citrullin/activity) shows a three-day gap between the August 11 post and the August 14 update on the [Sovereign Reth Multi-Chain Composability PoC](https://forum.gnosis.io/t/gip-xx-sovereign-reth-multi-chain-composability-poc/12412/13). Routine technical updates do not constitute spam.

# Technical & Economic Substance

The friction leading to this ban stems from demonstrating that Gnosis Sovereign Chain does not need to abandon its L1 consensus layer to achieve multi-chain composability:
![snapshot_poc_table.png](ipfs://bafkreiadc4igfh6xjwpeccsev7paiue6cvy3qlhlwp4ftoy5ewche6pjhu)

Gnosis Chain currently maintains ~37,200 active validators ([Gnosis Metrics](https://metrics.gnosischain.com/?dashboard=overview&tab=main)). Merging this infrastructure into Ether exposes the ecosystem to extreme centralization:
- 70%+ of Ethereum Mainnet stake is concentrated in Liquid Staking Tokens (LSTs) and institutional custodians ([Dune ETH2 Staking](https://dune.com/hildobby/eth2-staking)).
- Solo stakers represent only ~6.5% of Ethers validators ([Rated Network Solo Staking Report](https://blog.rated.network/blog/solo-stakers)).
- Economies of scale consistently disadvantage small staking operations ([ArXiv: 2306.10777](https://arxiv.org/abs/2306.10777)).

# Legal & Regulatory Considerations

Operating a DAO through back-channel coordination while unilaterally de-platforming dissenting technical contributors introduces substantial legal vulnerabilities:
- **General Partnership Liability (Samuels v. Lido DAO):**
Federal court rulings establish that governance token holders who exercise managerial control in unincorporated DAOs operate as general partners, exposing participants and large delegates to joint and several liability.
- **EU MiCA Title VI (Market Abuse Regime):**
Evaluates economic substance over legal form (wirtschaftliche Betrachtungsweise). Coordinated treasury extraction, balance-sheet maneuvers, and the suppression of minority token holder oversight establish a clear evidentiary paper trail for supervisory authorities.

# The Precedent of Selective Moderation

Gatekeeping technical discourse under the guise of "private forum rules" replicates patterns seen elsewhere in the ecosystem, such as the Ethereum Foundation's EthResearch forum being moderated by Virgil Griffith under an explicit "our house, our rules" policy despite his federal IEEPA conviction ([Public Evidence Archive](https://x.com/Citrullin/status/2058006691698847851)). GnosisDAO must decide whether it operates as a permissionless public good or a centrally curated entity.

# Voting Options

- **YES / Ban Citrullin:** 
Ratify the administrative actions of Gnosis Ltd., confirming that Philipp Blum (@Citrullin) shall remain banned from Discourse, Discord, and official Gnosis channels, and establishing that contributor access is subject to centralized administrative discretion.
- **NO / Do Not Ban Citrullin:**
Reject the ban and direct Gnosis Ltd. administrators to immediately restore full access to all governance and communication channels, affirming that open technical dissent, validator advocacy, and alternative scaling proposals are protected within GnosisDAO.
- **ABSTAIN:**
Formally record token presence without casting a directional vote.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

