# TIP-121a: Consolidation

- Space: [Fei](https://snapshot.box/s:fei.eth.md)
- Author: 0x4e474B76C3F09dfF4cC493802462E780C6515449
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Approval
- Start: 2022-08-23 19:00 UTC
- End: 2022-08-25 19:00 UTC
- Votes: 89
- Quorum: 10,000,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://tribe.fei.money/t/tip-121-proposal-for-the-future-of-the-tribe-dao/4475
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:fei.eth/proposal/0xfe4dd76c4bea843fc5a422e1c0cb5dca2f7e985419d2ceeea7618e8c20dcef11

## Results

- keep ~50,000 stETH: 40,824,495.93 voting power, 50.8%
- discuss selling params stETH: 38,811,557.91 voting power, 48.3%
- keep 21,754 ETH: 38,271,324.77 voting power, 47.6%
- sell 21,754 ETH: 41,607,174.45 voting power, 51.8%
- keep 18,751,529 LUSD: 7,252,644.39 voting power, 9.0%
- sell 18,751,529 LUSD: 57,646,986.72 voting power, 71.8%
- keep all protocol FEI: 1,000,534.53 voting power, 1.2%
- withdraw & burn all protocol FEI: 65,944,716.29 voting power, 82.1%
- keep all gov tokens except gOHM: 3,977,956.45 voting power, 5.0%
- explore gov token OTC: 63,756,290.89 voting power, 79.4%

## Proposal

## Proposal
This snapshot is a non-binding signal vote for the PCV Consolidation step of [TIP-121](https://tribe.fei.money/t/tip-121-proposal-for-the-future-of-the-tribe-dao/4475)

In order for the community to make specific decisions on different treatment of PCV assets, this vote is multiple choice with a binary option to keep/sell each of:
* ~50,000 stETH
* 21,754 ETH
* 18,751,529 LUSD
* All protocol FEI (withdraw and burn not sell)
* All remaining gov tokens (except gOHM)

gOHM could use the snapshot approved FIP-108 and the OTC unwind would be included in the first consolidation on-chain DAO vote.

All options that are voted to be sold would also be included in the subsequent consolidation DAO vote except for:
* “All remaining gov tokens”
* stETH

If “explore OTC options for remaining gov tokens” passes, we would invite any community quotes for each position of veBAL, FOX, LQTY, INDEX, vlAURA, veANGLE. We can then have a subsequent snapshot next week to decide how to treat each specifically.

If “sell stETH” passes, due to liquidity constraints there should be a subsequent discussion on execution parameters such as a floor sale price relative to ETH and expected timelines.

ETH and LUSD would use a 2-day Balancer LBP sale into DAI. Withdrawing protocol FEI would use a “withdraw as much as possible when liquidity available” algorithm.

## Voting rules:
This is a non-binding multiple-choice signal vote. Each of the binary keep/sell pairs above would be included. The larger option which also reaches 10M TRIBE quorum would proceed as outlined in the snapshot proposal.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

