# EIP-5: Reputation boost for existing social graphs

- Space: [Ethos](https://snapshot.box/s:ethos-labs.eth.md)
- Author: 0xC527Bcb5328f9f118074B03ba1BB07Ecc44C22A7
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2025-07-14 17:08 UTC
- End: 2025-07-17 17:08 UTC
- Votes: 1,049
- Discussion: https://app.ethos.network/activity/review/289120/eip-5
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:ethos-labs.eth/proposal/0x89d315e0065fffde6d1e8361950d4fb0403d43312379a49179ce3a67a9935797

## Results

- For: 808 voting power, 77.0%
- Against: 235 voting power, 22.4%
- Abstain: 6 voting power, 0.6%

## Proposal

# Summary

Introduce a new reputation-score element: "Reputation boost for existing social graphs"

For every non-Ethos user we count how many "Reputable"-tier (or higher) Ethos profiles follow them on connected social networks and allocate up to +400 points on a percentile basis.

## Impact

External accounts with strong reputable followership gain an initial credibility boost, better reflecting their existing credibility.

## Motivation

* Improve Ethos score evaluation for users still outside the platform.
* Provide a bootstrap path for newcomers who are already widely recognized.

# Specification

1. **Definitions**

   * **Reputable User** – any Ethos profile with score higher than 1600.
   * **External Account** – a social-network identity or wallet address without an Ethos profile.
   * **Reputable Follower Count (RFC)** – number of distinct Reputable Users following the External Account

2. **Score Calculation**

   a. Identify all External Accounts with RFC > 0.
   b. Compute the percentile rank of each External Account by number of followers.
   c. Assign a sigmoid calculation to the percentile rank, stretching the 0-100 range to a 0-400 range.

3. **Dynamic Population Updates**

   * Percentiles are recomputed regularly. This implies that a change in the user's percentile rank will change the score contribution, even if the user's individual RFC did not change.

4. **Decay on Ethos-Profile Creation**

   * When an External Account is claimed and becomes an Ethos profile, its stored Reputable Followers Impact begins a linear decay from its current value to 0 over the next 60 days.
   * After the decay period the factor is permanently 0; the user's score is then governed entirely by standard Ethos mechanisms.

5. **Caps & Interaction**

   * Max +400 pts; no negative values.
   * The global 2800-point cap remains unchanged. Because non-Ethos profiles cannot have reputation markets, that range can safely overlap this one.

## Rationale

* Percentile scaling normalizes follower-count variability.
* Decay clause prevents double-counting: once a user is on Ethos, their credibility should stem from on-platform activity, not indefinitely from external follows.

## Considerations & Safeguards

* Sybil resistance: acquiring Reputable status is costly, limiting fake-follower farms.

# Future considerations

* Today this EIP covers only adding reputation. In the future we could use this as a basis for determining when there is a significant mismatch between reputation and existing social graph presence and potentially remove score in the event someone has a very high Ethos reputation score with very low.
  * Example: User A is in top 1% of all Ethos scores (i.e. 2400), but bottom 10% of reputable followers (i.e. 4 followers) could eventually penalize users one day.
* This EIP also is only for users who are NOT on Ethos, we could eventually also extend this to users with profiles too.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

