# EIP-12: Credibility-Influence Delta

- Space: [Ethos](https://snapshot.box/s:ethos-labs.eth.md)
- Author: 0xCe8fDFA1dDad65878dC1E5C65BA490666C07D82a
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2025-10-24 21:54 UTC
- End: 2025-10-27 21:54 UTC
- Votes: 319
- Discussion: https://app.ethos.network/activity/review/536034/eip-12-credibility-influence-delta
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:ethos-labs.eth/proposal/0x451c31f5c1ad82e74ba353401048cc941821a8c6c505d6c0c3b18803bd278be5

## Results

- For: 282 voting power, 88.4%
- Against: 26 voting power, 8.2%
- Abstain: 11 voting power, 3.4%

## Proposal

## Abstract
This proposal introduces the **Credibility–Influence Delta (CID)**, a balancing mechanism within the Ethos credibility system that compares a user’s **Credibility Score bracket** with their **Influence Factor percentile**.  
The system measures alignment between reputation and reach, penalizing users whose influence level is disproportionately low relative to their score bracket.

The goal is to ensure that top-tier credibility scores represent individuals who are both reputable *and* influential — those who have earned trust locally and carry meaningful weight globally.

By applying a penalty for significant misalignment, the CID discourages artificial score inflation, strengthens the upper tiers of credibility, and makes spoofing harder without authentic social presence or network effect.

---

## Specification

### Overview
Ethos classifies users into discrete **Credibility Score brackets** and **Influence Factor percentiles**.  
The **Credibility–Influence Delta** measures the *difference* between these two tiers.

#### Credibility Score Brackets

| **Score Range** | **Bracket Label** |
|------------------|-------------------|
| 2200+ | Distinguished |
| 2000–2199 | Exemplary |
| 1800–1999 | Reputable |
| 1600–1799 | Established |
| 1400–1599 | Known |

#### Influence Factor Percentiles

| **Percentile Range** | **Band Label** |
|------------------------|----------------|
| Top 10% | Elite Influence |
| Top 25% | High Influence |
| Top 50% | Moderate Influence |
| Bottom 50% | Low Influence |
| Bottom 25% | Minimal Influence |

The system evaluates the **difference in bands** between the Credibility Score and the Influence Factor.  
A difference of zero or one (“in range”) indicates alignment.  
A difference greater than one (“out of range”) indicates misalignment and applies a proportional penalty.

---

### Mechanics

#### 1. Delta Calculation
Each user’s Score Bracket (**S**) and Influence Percentile (**I**) are mapped to numeric indices (e.g., 1–5).  
The **Credibility–Influence Delta (CID)** is calculated as: CID = | S − I |
**Example:**  
A user in *Bracket 4 (Exemplary)* but *Influence Band 2 (Low Influence)* has `CID = 2` (a “miss of 2”).

---

#### 2. Penalty Application
A penalty is applied when `CID ≥ 1`.  
Penalties increase in severity as the gap widens, but remain relatively soft to preserve fairness and accessibility.

| **CID Difference** | **Impact Level** | **Description** |
|---------------------|------------------|-----------------|
| 1 | Negligible | Alignment is mostly consistent; no or minimal adjustment. |
| 2 | Small | Slight misalignment; small penalty applied. |
| 3 | Medium | Noticeable misalignment; moderate penalty applied. |
| 4+ | Large | Strong misalignment; significant penalty applied. |

Alignment (`CID = 0`) yields no change, and *over-influential* users (higher I than S) are not penalized.

---

#### 3. Intent
- Ensure *Exemplary* (2000) and above tiers reflect individuals with both **high trust** and **high reach**.  
- Prevent spoofed or low-impact accounts from attaining high credibility.  
- Maintain fairness: users can still achieve *Reputable* status with limited influence, but *Exemplary* requires either broader recognition or market validation.

---

## Motivation
Ethos aims to reward **authentic, socially validated reputation**.  
Currently, users can achieve high credibility through review and vouch activity even if their influence factor is low.  
This creates inflated top-end scores that do not correlate with actual visibility or impact.

The **Credibility–Influence Delta** introduces balance between **depth of trust** and **breadth of influence**.  
It ensures that the highest scores (2000+) represent users who are both respected *and recognized*.

This update helps to:
- Prevent Sybil clusters and reputation farming.  
- Encourage genuine participation and organic network growth.  
- Strengthen the credibility signal at the top of the scoring ladder.

---

## Score Component Adjustments

| **Component** | **Change** | **Rationale** |
|----------------|-------------|----------------|
| *Credibility–Influence Delta* | New component (penalty scales by CID difference: small, medium, large) | Penalizes misalignment between reputation and influence. |
| *Top-end thresholds (2000+)* | Slightly rebalanced upward | Reflects higher expectations for influence + reputation alignment. |

---

## Rationale
Ethos believes true credibility is *two-dimensional*:  
- **Reputation** — earned through trustworthy behavior and peer validation.  
- **Influence** — earned through reach, visibility, and impact.

Someone reputable but unknown is locally trusted yet globally invisible.  
Someone known but untrustworthy is visible yet unreliable.  
The **Credibility–Influence Delta** ensures that *Exemplary* represents those who are both **trusted and known** — the benchmark for global credibility within the Ethos ecosystem.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

