# Wind down the safety staking module?

- Space: [dYdX](https://snapshot.box/s:dydxgov.eth.md)
- Author: 0xDf71878436e521e430fACf36ee5e3D74fA519F2c
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2022-10-25 19:49 UTC
- End: 2022-10-29 19:49 UTC
- Votes: 748
- Discussion: https://forums.dydx.community/discussion/7013-dydx-safety-staking-review
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:dydxgov.eth/proposal/0x756f174ea610a5891365f19881b3e300c719a80b16e8d67643aace30d4ca3bc4

## Results

- Yes: wind it down: 7,731,394.02 voting power, 92.9%
- No: do nothing: 586,834.43 voting power, 7.1%

## Proposal

### Overview
* The dYdX [safety staking module](https://docs.dydx.community/dydx-governance/staking-pools/safety-staking-pool) is as a pool of DYDX tokens that is meant to backstop the protocol in the case of a shortfall event, such as an exploit or a failure to liquidate a large quantity of positions on the exchange. 
* The protocol gives 383,561 DYDX per 28-day epoch to fund this pool. However, we argue that the actual **insurance power**, i.e. the USDC value that the pool would realistically be able to raise in the case of a shortfall event, is severely less than the nominal value of the safety staking module. This renders the safety staking module nearly useless as it stands today.
* We considered a number of solutions that would bolster the insurance power, whereby we would change the staking asset to a better insurance asset, however changing the asset now is not possible due to limitations on dYdX engineering time.
* Since there is already a $17M+ USDC insurance fund operated by dYdX Trading Inc., we believe it is relatively low risk to discontinue DYDX safety staking module emissions until we are able to implement a more effective insurance fund after the release of dYdX V4.
* **We propose halting DYDX emissions to the safety staking module, and instead routing them to the community treasury.** This will serve to effectively lower token emissions and increase the holdings of the community treasury.

### Implementation
Although these changes will be require an on-chain DIP to implement, they will not require any significant engineering lift. The details of the implementation will be quite similar to that of the [liquidity staking module wind-down](https://snapshot.org/#/dydxgov.eth/proposal/0x6a0c11c6749661fa59f887e521deada80d30dcbc0961af555227a5c4d0b00a4e).

### Voting Options
* Yes: Execute the proposed changes by:
  * Turning off rewards generated by staking DYDX to the Safety Staking Module
  * removing the deposit functionality for the Safety Staking Module from https://dydx.community/dashboard, and
  * sending the remaining rewards (383, 562 DYDX per epoch) allocated to users who stake DYDX to the Community Treasury.
* No: Do nothing.

### Links
* [Research paper](https://xenophonlabs.com/papers/dydx_safety_staking.pdf)
* [Forum discussion](https://forums.dydx.community/discussion/7013-dydx-safety-staking-review)
* [Safety staking AMA](https://twitter.com/dydxfoundation/status/1580565622760812544)
* [Xenophon Labs](https://xenophonlabs.com/)

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

