# CIP-202: City Council 2.0 International v.2

- Space: [CityDAO](https://snapshot.box/s:daocity.eth.md)
- Author: 0xF46902313f7cBcAc6A3154F214E88d0085D062DE
- State: Rejected
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2023-10-24 23:41 UTC
- End: 2023-10-31 23:41 UTC
- Votes: 140
- Quorum: 500 voting power
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:daocity.eth/proposal/0x30b9b592fc462be5efe0f38196e8baeb17bd7243a8f1d1f53e82e92c2b90fee7

## Results

- Approve: 177 voting power, 95.2%
- Reject: 9 voting power, 4.8%

## Proposal

TLDR

The purpose of this CIP is to create a more inclusive CityDAO Council and to fund the Community Team, which will make sure we have engagement across multiple communities. This CIP will last for 6 months, followed by democratic, open elections. The quorum for this CIP is 500 votes and the requested total budget is $107K. This CIP combines both a council CIP and the community team CIP, which is why the budget is high.

Why is this needed?

For the past year, CityDAO has had some very important problems that we cannot fix without authorization by the community through a CIP. The main problems can be explained in three categories: administrative, legal and taxes.

Administrative:

Our multisig wallet has members who are no longer part of the DAO. This is not safe.
Our quorums make it too easy to request large amounts of money and only require 51% approval from voters, no matter how much money is requested.
Our voting allows for certain individuals to control the votes.
Our international communities do not have enough representation.
We have no process for complaints and grievances, which has led to negative behavior on the discord. This destabilizes our community and makes it harder for citizens to get involved with CityDAO.
How to make sure that people who are paid to do work do not get paid unless they accomplish their work.

Legal:

We don’t have clarity on what CityDAO can do to earn money as an American DAO LLC. Without this, we keep spending money without making any money.
We don’t have anyone who can legally sign contracts on behalf of CityDAO for our events, partnerships, or for when we hire independent contractors for work.

Taxes:

We need to pay our taxes and send out the proper forms from the American IRS to anyone who gets paid more than $600 per year. We need a CPA (certified public accountant) to handle some of these tax issues.

The proposed City Council 2.0 would include the following seven people: Blackacres, David, Nico, Ming, Lupei, SimplePixel, Serkan

Blackacres
North American (NA) community communication
Advisory board communication lead
Handling and filing taxes including CPA oversight and paperwork
Clarify the charter (GROUP)
Clarify how an NFT holder confirms their citizenship for forum likes
Clarify Snapshot voting to refine algorithmic quorums and/or implement quadratic voting
Human Resource Management (GROUP)
Complaint and grievance process

David
Work with outside counsel to handle legal issues in CityDAO
Clarify who can sign contracts on behalf of CityDAO
Clarify the charter (GROUP)
Clarify how an NFT holder confirms their citizenship for forum likes
Clarify Snapshot voting to refine algorithmic quorums and/or implement quadratic voting
Human Resource Management (GROUP)
Complaint and grievance process
Hiring and dismissal of independent contractors
Dismissal of council members and other DAO members from groups
Clarification on DAO tool access

Nico
Taking notes on meetings
Summarize round-ups
Keeping things in check on that we’re on topic at meetings
Community (GROUP)
Cross channel communication across communities
Help out with community calls, especially with NA and China areas.
Hosting Twitter (X) Spaces
Strategic operations (GROUP)
If someone proposed something and didn’t follow through, should they still get paid? The work people say they’ll do and what they actually do should be documented and shared with the DAO.
How can we ensure accountabilities for passed CIPs
Assist with strategic communications about the long term development for CityDAO - what are we building?

Ming
CN community communication
Wechat group management and public account management
IRL meetups in China
Translate newspapers and round-up into Chinese
Partnerships and communication with other CN DAOs
DAO TALK Twitter Space
Strategic operations (GROUP)
Develop operational and marketing plans
Plan CityDAO branding activities

Lupei
Thai community communication
Translation and content tailoring in Thai community
IRL meetups in Thailand (as needed)
Community operations (GROUP)
Making sure everyone in the DAO has the same information
Community activities / projects management
CityDAO contest organization
Publishing newspaper
Twitter(X) management/access.

SimplePixel
Co-lead Turkish community communication
Management of partnerships with Turkish DAO/web3 organizations
IRL events in Turkey
Community operations (GROUP)
Management of community activities and projects for overall DAO
Hosting TR Twitter spaces
CityDAO contest organization
Strategic operations (GROUP)
Clarifying the CIP process
Making a clear template for the creation of CIPs
Clarify the charter (GROUP)
Clarify how an NFT holder confirms their citizenship for forum likes
Clarify Snapshot voting to refine algorithmic quorums and/or implement quadratic voting
Marketing / Events (GROUP)
Figure out what upcoming events are happening globally and locally
Make a CIP and work with others on an events budget
Sponsorship & event participation for Turkish Community

Serkan
Co-lead Turkish community communication
Co-hosting biweekly Discord TR community calls
Translation of newspaper and round-up into Turkish
Community (GROUP)
Representing the First & Founding citizens
Connecting and gathering info about active/passive citizens on Discord & Twitter
Strategic operations (GROUP)
Research other DAOs about success / failure

Advisory / CityDAO Assembly (non voting): Anyone with more than 50 Citizen NFTs or any Founder NFTs. Being a member of the CityDAO Assembly provides streamlined access to the council and community team, which includes efficient feedback, communication, development of ideas and assistance in turning ideas into viable CIPs. This will be implemented after discussion and after main priorities are accomplished.

If any council member misses more than two meetings without explanation, they will be removed from the council. They will not be replaced until the next election. Voting on all issues within the council will require 4 of 7 votes to pass, except that choosing members of the multisig will require unanimous council approval. 

RESPONSIBILITIES

City Council 2.0 is meant to accomplish very specific goals. Each of these goals is directly tied to the effectiveness of CityDAO. The planned goals are as follows:

Month 1-3

How to confirm citizenship for likes
Adjusting quorums
Update Charter
Operations
Clarify the process of CIP creation → Forum → Snapshot
Making a clear template for the creation of CIPs
Clarify how an NFT holder confirms their citizenship
Ensure that only verified citizens are able to “like” CIPs on the Discourse forum
Clarify Snapshot voting to refine quorums and/or implement quadratic voting
Who posts Snapshot votes when the 20 like threshold is reached
Clarification of DAO tool access
Clarifying access process for Twitter & Discord
Taxes and CPA relationship management and organization
Appoint the 8-person multisig, remove non-participating members, and make clear rules

Month 3-6

Legal
Establishing contact with outside council
Making sure there is a clear pipeline for legal questions to be answered
Who can sign contracts
CityDAO treasury payments from projects
Using NFTs as compensation to citizens
Maintaining or hiring people to maintain the DAO tools including Discord, Discourse, Snapshot, Website, Notion, and Twitter

Human Resource Management
Make rules for how members are removed in the future
Establishing and enforcing regulations for behavior on Discourse and Discord
Establishing a complaint and grievance process for CityDAO citizens

BUDGET BREAKDOWN

Council Members: $1500 per member per month ($63,000 total)
Lawyers, Accountants and Other Professionals: $12K total
Council Fund (only used for bounties and hiring): $20K total
Community Fund : $12K total

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

