# Breeding Ruleset Change

- Space: [Blockchain Cuties Universe](https://snapshot.box/s:cutiesofficial.eth.md)
- Author: 0x1F77D6577D1F08827F9BFE73877fD4FbCc68f1C4
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2023-04-07 07:53 UTC
- End: 2023-04-14 18:00 UTC
- Votes: 21
- Discussion: https://t.me/blockchaincuties_en
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:cutiesofficial.eth/proposal/0xcc582e48211c6736ed01305c56d5df457c629b2b426a44688b1e6aea0dc9141f

## Results

- (15 - R, 20- C/U): 46,626.53 voting power, 27.4%
- New limit of 20 For All: 123,810.1 voting power, 72.6%

## Proposal

### Hello, Cutieneers 👋 

Since the last time the breeding fee was adjusted we have communicated with the community and done our best to make it fair for everyone involved. 

The initial goal that the team wanted to achieve with the changes was to bring all chains closer together in terms of price and exploration ability for the community and try to find a sweet spot for competitive breeding so that players would have intention and interest towards the process. As we saw before, some of the breeding was done in order to spam as many Cuties as possible to gain an advantage. 

Ever since the adjustment of the breeding fee, many things have changed in Cutieland in terms of the in-game economy and how we approach the market ecosystem that Blockchain Cuties offers to the players as a playground. 

## The Proposition

As the team is preparing an update for the community regarding the recent discussions and developments about the breeding process and what we see now as a direct result of the changes introduced up to this day, we would like to propose a slight change in regard to breeding limits. 

This is primarily aimed at mitigating clone armies and introducing a more intentional approach to breeding. 

The current proposal is to adjust the breeding limit on Cuties, lowering the limit from **30 to 15 breeds** for **regular** Cuties, and **20** for **Creator** and **Unique** Cuties. 
Alternatively, make it a blanket approach change, and change it to 20 breeds per Cutie regardless of its Creator or Unique status. 

An important piece of the information is that the breed limit is not a hard cap of times a Cutie can be bred. It is initially the number of times that Cutie can be given Elixirs of Life before it will stop working, and the Cutie’s cooldown will eventually cap out and become less efficient to use as a breeding pair, thus hindering clone army building, introducing a more sustainable model for tribute breeding.  
How did the team arrive at the aforementioned breed limit numbers? 

Before doing anything that is around game design, data has to be analyzed. That is what the team did as the discussion in the game chat started to gain traction. 

We analyzed data from the last few months. Looking into the amounts of Cuties bred and how much the same parents were utilized for that purpose. 

Out of 2105** parent Cuties, only **59 Cuties (~3%)** were bred more than **20** times, since November 2022.  Here are some more data to make it a bit more clear: 
Cuties bred more than **15** times - **93 (~4.5%)**
Cuties bred more than **10** times - **167 (~8%)**
Cuties bred more than **5** times - **368 (~17.5%)**

As we see, the number of breeding attempts is lower than the proposed limit, however, when a “purebred” is found, it would be mass-producing a much more scarce Cutie type, like Water Dragons, before breeding limits have been introduced. This allows players to be competitive with knowledge, instead of just buying into a pair of Cuties and tanking rare Cutie’s market value.  

There are two options that the team is looking at this time: 

• Introduce a new limit of 15 for Regular Cuties, and 20 for Creator/Unique Cuties ***(15 - R, 20- C/U)*** 
• Introduce a new limit of 20 for all Cuties 

We hope to hear from the community and share their feedback in our ***[in-game chat](blockchaincuties.com)***, ***[telegram](https://t.me/blockchaincuties_en)***, and ***[discord](https://discord.com/invite/C6KCEU7)***.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

