# Balance Upgrade: Switch of attack and defense stats to ranges

- Space: [Blockchain Cuties Universe](https://snapshot.box/s:cutiesofficial.eth.md)
- Author: 0x1F77D6577D1F08827F9BFE73877fD4FbCc68f1C4
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2022-08-05 13:00 UTC
- End: 2022-08-19 15:00 UTC
- Votes: 38
- Discussion: https://t.me/blockchaincuties_en
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:cutiesofficial.eth/proposal/0x44f7f2f8193026502c2d861e75568aae3eb3bde858d090730df9d7d47d8bb1b7

## Results

- For: 32,035.31 voting power, 20.7%
- Against: 4,319.3 voting power, 2.8%
- Abstain: 118,392.13 voting power, 76.5%

## Proposal

Hi Cutieneers! 

Recently we have run a vote on the first change impacting the game and in-game market economy directly, and you have been the voice for that decision. 

Now, it is time to start thinking about a slightly different but very impactful change. Today the team proposes to change how the stat values work in battle across BCU. 

## The Change
The idea here is to change how attack and defense stats interact during battles. Where an attack can do damage in a specified range, and defense can block out incoming damage within the specified range. The difference in attack vs defense would be the damage dealt that turn. If the defense is rolled higher than the attack, the damage is absorbed completely. The first iteration of this change would be to adjust the bottom ranges correctly according to half of its current state and the top of the range value will be its current value in the said stat (attack or defense)

This will allow us to test the waters of this approach and set it up for later updates which will be rolling out for all of the items with manual adjustments according to item scarcity, level, etc. 

The items will not going to be rebalanced and will still be within the same niche as they are right now according to the power curves. Exceptions will be problematic items and sets that are negatively affecting tournaments. 

The first iteration of the ranges will be automated for the majority of items. Ranges will be adjusted manually later giving different items and setting better placements in the meta, reinforcing possible builds in the HP-based Battles that the game is gradually transitioning to fully. 

## Outcomes
If the majority vote **for** the change, the change will be implemented in one of the upcoming patches with beforehand announcements. 

If the majority vote is **against** the change, the change will not be introduced at this time, and another proposition with adjustments will be introduced for the voting.


### Happy hunting

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

