# Take back remaining whitehat bounty to compensate exploit losses

- Space: [Cream Finance](https://snapshot.box/s:cream-finance.eth.md)
- Author: 0xCC876be657B5d3d80cB9D483fb846766a8b80185
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2022-03-21 11:13 UTC
- End: 2022-03-24 11:20 UTC
- Votes: 4
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:cream-finance.eth/proposal/0x1d01d10f9e75b245235848795ce41c8315d2c2ea34829e1e548b2a73839ff00c

## Results

- End bounty; pay exploit losses: 5,103.93 voting power, 100.0%
- Change nothing: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

## Summary
Ethereum Cream depositors experienced a total loss after the October 2021 exploit. Whitehats from the AMP exploit recovery have already received 12.5% of recovered funds. It’s time to recover this bounty and put it toward compensating exploit losses from the October 2021 exploit. 


## Action
FOR: Cream Team must stop payment to whitehats named “Lossless/ Pascal” and distribute remaining, 1932.15 ETH, to all impacted depositors on Ethereum Cream based on percentage of Supply - Borrowed assets valued at October 28, 2021, excluding crETH2 deposits. 

AGAINST: Cream Team makes no change and pays out the remaining 1932.15 ETH to the whitehats named “Lossless/ Pascal”.


## Background
In August 2021, Cream Ethereum was exploited. Two “whitehat” groups emerged, with the first earning 10% bounty and the second earning 50% of the remaining 90% of returned funds. Standard industry bounty for whitehat is 10%. Condition for 50% bounty according to the blog post required “leading to the arrest and prosecution” of the perpetrators - none of this ever happened yet somehow we as a protocol honored a 50% bounty without a vote. 

In October 2021, another exploit happened that made the Cream Ethereum system to become insolvent, leaving depositors in a total loss scenario. Then the team gave back everything they got back- yearn yCRV recovered and the crETH2 rugged back from the exploiter. Plus they gave up all of their team vesting and treasury tokens.

Everyone got hurt - token holders, team, depositors. Just not these whitehats. 

According to Cream Dev:
The current agreement is a 50% bounty of recovered funds to the whitehats in Lossless/ Pascal from the AMP exploit from August 2021. The bounty is being paid out over a 2 year period linearly:

- Recovered funds: 5152.5 ETH
- 50% bounty: 2576.25 ETH
- Payments for 6 months so far: 644.1 ETH
- Remaining for this bounty: 1932.15 ETH

## Motivation
To find all available funds to use toward recouping losses for depositors. 


## Rationale
Industry standard is 10% of recovered funds for whitehats. We have already overpayed these second set of whitehats by giving them 12.5% of recovered funds. Plus they did not meet the conditions of “leading to the arrest and prosecution” of the perpetrators.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

