# Snapshot Governance: Updated Voting Framework

- Space: [Compound](https://snapshot.box/s:comp-vote.eth.md)
- Author: 0xfd947c72f09703210eeCbcab9c9206fE5e1Bb6e2
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-11-18 19:32 UTC
- End: 2026-11-21 19:27 UTC
- Votes: 18
- Discussion: https://www.comp.xyz/t/snapshot-governance-updated-voting-framework/8265
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:comp-vote.eth/proposal/0xae83dfb1acf44ef54f65453aded016903166c91f2ab730c5705b6df1b0cb59d9

## Results

- Yes: 1,194,267.7 voting power, 38.2%
- No: 1,930,763.22 voting power, 61.8%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

### Summary

This sentiment proposal introduces an updated voting framework for the comp-vote.eth Snapshot space. The framework sets eligibility criteria for voting and proposal creation, based on identity, voting power and participation history, and applies documented security exclusions. As before, each eligible address’ vote counts in proportion to its COMP voting power. The framework applies only to Snapshot; onchain governance through the Compound Governor is unchanged.

### Background

As set out in the [Foundation’s published record](https://www.comp.xyz/t/recent-governance-activity-in-context-the-record-since-2024/8120), Compound’s ecosystem and governance have faced a pattern of alleged malicious activity since 2024. That record covers alleged governance attacks, disruption to protocol operations, and obstruction of security measures. The Proposal Guardian’s recent cancellations of [Proposals 612, 613](https://www.comp.xyz/t/proposal-guardian-cancellation-of-proposals-612-and-613/8147), [618](https://www.comp.xyz/t/proposal-guardian-cancellation-of-proposal-618/8190), and [619](https://www.comp.xyz/t/proposal-guardian-cancellation-of-proposal-619/8221) underline the continuing need for protective action.



The Compound Governance Working Group (CGWG) will therefore update the comp-vote.eth Snapshot space to protect the ecosystem and preserve effective governance. Under its mandate renewed in [Proposal 537](https://www.tally.xyz/gov/compound/proposal/537?govId=eip155:1:0x309a862bbC1A00e45506cB8A802D1ff10004c8C0), the CGWG coordinates Compound's Snapshot and onchain votes, and its mandated objectives include “ensuring that no malicious governance attempts are executed successfully.” The safeguards set out here are intended to protect the community’s ability to scrutinize proposals while keeping governance operational.

### Scope

* The aforementioned framework applies to voting and proposal creation on the comp-vote.eth Snapshot space.

* Onchain voting and execution through the Compound Governor, like routine parameter changes, continue exactly as before.

* The existing comp-vote.eth Snapshot space will be updated. No new space will be created.

### Eligibility Criteria

To vote on comp-vote.eth under the new framework, an address must meet all of the following:



* Identity: The address is identifiable through a forum delegate profile, a known individual or organization, existing CGWG voter records, or an ENS or Tally name associated with the voting address.

* Voting power: The address holds at least 1 COMP of eligible delegated voting power, after security adjustments, at the proposal’s reference block (its Snapshot block).

* Participation history: The address has voted on at least five distinct Compound governance proposals, onchain or on comp-vote.eth, in the 12 months before the reference block, or it qualifies through the alternative admission route below.



Addresses with fewer than five prior votes may still qualify through a CGWG review. The review confirms that the applicant controls the address, has an identifiable governance profile, and holds COMP or represents delegators who do, and it applies the same security checks as for all addresses. Delegates who have moved to a new address can carry over their voting history from the old one; only the new address will be eligible.

### Security Exclusions

Security exclusions apply to addresses linked onchain to the dCOMP voting position, the concentrated voting power described in the [Foundation’s record](https://www.comp.xyz/t/recent-governance-activity-in-context-the-record-since-2024/8120). An address is excluded where the evidence establishes common control with, coordinated proxy activity for, or other documented coordination with the dCOMP voting position. Examples include, but are not limited to, COMP transferred to the dCOMP owner, voting power supplied by the vault or its owner, and funding or delegation links to known associated wallets.



* Incidental or unsolicited transfers or delegations alone will not disqualify a recipient.

* Where excluded-source voting power can be reliably attributed, only that portion will be removed. Unrelated voting power is not affected.

* Disagreement with CGWG, the Foundation, or any proposal is not an exclusion criterion. Participation history is assessed without regard to how an address voted.

### Initial Roster and Ongoing Review

An initial analysis identified 24 eligible addresses, representing approximately 1.3 million COMP of voting power. The current roster is maintained on [this spreadsheet](https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1zS5ZFpppWYq6FXg-Zz8hCZXPQsCMV1jyxqOVWmuTN_M/edit?gid=0#gid=0). Any address that believes it has been excluded in error may request a review. Requests for inclusion or correction may be submitted to CGWG through forum DMs (via @CompoundGWG). 



CGWG will review the roster, check new addresses, and publish any changes before each vote goes live. 

### Voting and Proposal Rules

* Applicability: This update applies to all new comp-vote.eth Snapshot votes.

* Eligibility: Only addresses on the eligible roster can vote, meaning those that meet the Eligibility Criteria above and are not subject to a security exclusion.

* Weighting: Each eligible address’ COMP voting power at the proposal’s reference block, as in standard Snapshot voting, after any documented security adjustments.

* Passing threshold: At least 400,000 COMP voting Yes, with Yes votes outnumbering No votes.

* Proposal creation: Requires 10,000 COMP of voting power, as before, from an address on the eligible roster.

* The Treasury Management Committee (TMC) has endorsed this framework and will execute budgetary proposals that pass on Snapshot under its existing mandate.

### Sentiment Vote

This present vote gauges community sentiment on the proposed Snapshot voting framework for comp-vote.eth. It is held under the space’s current settings as a read of community views. Vote For to support adopting the framework, Against to oppose it, or Abstain to record no position. Forum discussion remains open throughout, and feedback is welcome in the thread.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

