# Adopt Optimistic Governance for Market Parameter Updates

- Space: [Compound](https://snapshot.box/s:comp-vote.eth.md)
- Author: 0x0579A616689f7ed748dC07692A3F150D44b0CA09
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2025-12-02 19:11 UTC
- End: 2025-12-09 19:11 UTC
- Votes: 46
- Discussion: https://www.comp.xyz/t/adopt-optimistic-governance-for-market-parameter-updates/7385
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:comp-vote.eth/proposal/0x32334a7a89b6f2f08cf6975a77270c45e197bb4a2ef68309cb2ef736809f767a

## Results

- For: 819,390.88 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

## **Executive Summary**

Following Tally's successful RFP response to become Compound's Voting Service Provider, we explored visibility improvements for MarketAdmin transactions. However, consultations revealed that MarketAdmin represents a suboptimal operational model with fundamental limitations:

- **Inherent Opacity:** Single guardian entity limits distributed oversight
- **Limited Scalability:** Only deployed on OP Mainnet
- **Restricted Community Visibility:** Guardian model provides minimal delegate oversight

This proposal implements Optimistic Governance as a transparent alternative to MarketAdmin for market parameter updates. Optimistic governance reduces proposal lead times by >80% (from ~20 days to ~5 days) while maintaining DAO oversight and improving transparency.

## **Background**

### **Current State**

Compound parameter changes occur through:
1. **Full DAO Vote**: 30+ days to complete
2. **MarketAdmin**: Mid-2024 solution, only on OP Mainnet

### **The Problem**

- **Inefficiency**: Monthly cycles create delays for time-sensitive decisions
- **Voter Fatigue**: Routine changes consume governance bandwidth
- **Lack of Transparency**: Opaque process with limited visibility
- **Limited Scope**: Only deployed on OP Mainnet

## **The Solution: Optimistic Governance**

Optimistic governance assumes proposals are approved unless explicitly vetoed by delegates. This streamlines decision-making while maintaining oversight for maintenance upgrades, technical changes, and parameter adjustments.

### **Key Benefits**

1. **Transparency**: All proposals publicly visible on Tally
2. **Efficiency**: 4 day lifecycle vs 20+ days (>80% reduction)
3. **Maintained DAO Control**: Token holders retain veto authority
4. **Reduced Voter Fatigue**: Delegates engage only when disagreeing
5. **Faster Risk Response**: Adjustments in days, not weeks
6. **Accountability**: Clear attribution to council members

## **Proposed Implementation**

### **Phase 1: Pilot on Arbitrum, Base, and Optimism**

Deploy optimistic governance for market parameters on three established networks with appropriate risk profiles before mainnet deployment.

### **Council Composition**

5 key stakeholders with 3 of 5 votes required:
1. Gauntlet (main proposer)
2. Compound Foundation
3. WOOF
4. ChainSecurity
5. Certora

### **Governance Parameters**

- **Council Quorum:** 3 of 5 members
- **Proposal Expiration:** 1 week
- **Veto Voting Duration**: 3 days
- **Veto Quorum**: 400,000 COMP
- **Veto Quorum Extension:** 3 days (at 200K COMP votes)
- **Timelock Delay**: 1 day

### **How It Works**

1. **Proposal Creation**: Council member creates proposal visible on Tally. 3 of 5 votes advances to veto stage. Expires if quorum not reached in 7 days.

2. **Veto Period**: 3 days for COMP delegates to review and cast veto votes on Tally.

3. **Execution**:
   - Veto quorum NOT reached → proposal passes, enters 1-day timelock
   - 200K COMP veto votes → 3-day extension for more delegate review
   - 400K COMP veto quorum → proposal canceled

### **Clickable Demo**

End-to-end lifecycle demo available [here](https://www.figma.com/proto/Sgu9ekfqnhuQkTV1TP8gEY/Veto-Councils?page-id=595%3A15207&node-id=605-19828&viewport=1053%2C528%2C0.1&t=Psjhozk75ofqBtoc-8&scaling=scale-down-width&content-scaling=fixed&starting-point-node-id=605%3A19828&hide-ui=1) (pw: onchain)

### **Scope of Authority**

Market admin authority over Arbitrum, Base, and Optimism including:
- Adding/removing collateral assets
- Adjusting risk parameters
- Setting interest rate models
- Configuring supply/borrow caps

### **Transparency & Monitoring**

All proposals will be:
- Displayed on Tally with full details
- Announced in Discord and forum
- Subject to same transparency standards as regular governance

## **Implementation Details**

Cross-chain optimistic governance system:
- Runs on Ethereum mainnet
- Council membership assigned to 5 parties
- COMP delegates can veto proposals
- Timelock contracts on Arbitrum, Base, and Optimism accept cross-chain messages from L1
- Main Compound governance can add/remove council members

On execution: Assign admin permissions to timelocks on Arbitrum, Optimism and Base.

## **Future Expansion**

If successful:
1. Expand to Ethereum Mainnet
2. Expand to all chains

## **Cost**

**$40k** for complete implementation (partnership discount from typical $100K+ market cost).

Covers:
- Smart contract development and deployment
- Security review and testing
- Tally integration
- Documentation and education materials

## **Comparison: MarketAdmin vs. Optimistic Governance**

| Feature | MarketAdmin | Optimistic Governance |
|---------|-------------|----------------------|
| Transparency | Opaque | Fully visible on Tally |
| Timeline | Variable | 4 days (consistent) |
| DAO Oversight | Guardian veto | Delegate veto (400K quorum) |
| Chains | OP Mainnet only | Arbitrum, Base, Optimism |
| Engagement | Minimal | Active veto opportunity |

## **Success Metrics** (3 months)

1. Average time from proposal to execution
2. Proposals reviewed vs. vetoed
3. Community feedback on visibility
4. Contentious proposals and veto rate
5. Volume processed through optimistic governance

## **Voting Options**

- **FOR**: Deploy Optimistic Governor on Ethereum mainnet covering Arbitrum, Base, and Optimism
- **AGAINST**: Maintain current MarketAdmin for Optimism, full governance for other chains
- **ABSTAIN**

## **Next Steps**

1. Community Discussion
2. Snapshot Vote
3. Security Review by Certora and ChainSecurity
4. On-Chain Vote on Tally
5. Deployment if approved

Optimistic governance enables Compound to be more responsive to market conditions while reducing governance overhead without compromising transparency and DAO oversight.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

