# Renewal of Compound’s Security Service Providers 2026-2027

- Space: [Compound](https://snapshot.box/s:comp-vote.eth.md)
- Author: 0x0579A616689f7ed748dC07692A3F150D44b0CA09
- State: Rejected
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2026-09-23 16:00 UTC
- End: 2026-09-26 16:00 UTC
- Votes: 16
- Discussion: https://www.comp.xyz/t/renewal-of-compounds-security-service-providers-2026-2027/8071
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:comp-vote.eth/proposal/0x1ed8593c0e7e4d63c6f921bda01e30d217a9e65a385b82d0c6c89e3d6e336c79

## Results

- For: 627,011.28 voting power, 25.8%
- Against: 1,799,025.62 voting power, 74.2%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

## Summary

The Compound Foundation ("Foundation") and Compound Governance Working Group ("CGWG") are submitting this Snapshot to seek community approval for a one-year renewal of Compound DAO's security service provider arrangement, covering all three providers that secure the protocol today, as described in the Foundation's forum proposal: "Renewal of Compound's Security Service Providers 2026-2027".

The package saves the DAO $341,000, or 17%, against what these same three services cost today. Combined spend today is $2,036,000 — $2,000,000 of DAO-funded security spend plus the $36,000 of ChainPatrol coverage the Foundation has been carrying since the DAO's own funding line for it lapsed. The renewal brings that to **$1,695,000**, and to **$1,395,000** annualised once the vCISO component comes off, a reduction of $641,000, close to a third.

This Snapshot asks the community to approve the renewal on terms materially consistent with the forum proposal, authorize CGWG to coordinate with the Foundation and relevant stakeholders to finalize the arrangements, and approve disbursement from funds administered under the Treasury Management Committee ("TMC") framework.

## Background

The current arrangement was selected through the Security Service Provider RFP the Foundation ran in mid-2025, to which sixteen proposals were submitted. Delegates selected ChainSecurity & Certora as SSP at $1.75M annually, with monitoring and incident response carved out to zeroShadow under a separate $250,000 engagement, taking the DAO's security spend from roughly $4M annualised to $2M.

ChainPatrol sits outside that structure, and this proposal returns it to the DAO rather than adding it. It was engaged on the DAO's behalf in 2024 and funded from the Growth Program budget. When that programme was not renewed, the coverage would have lapsed along with the authorisation the DAO had just granted; the Foundation has carried the $36,000 a year directly since then so that it did not. The service, the scope, and the DAO's authorisation have been continuous throughout; only the payer changed.

The DAO held two one-year renewal options at the prior commercial terms. Rather than exercise them at $1.75M, the Foundation renegotiated both security engagements from open-ended continuous models into defined, measurable ones, with reported utilisation. That restructuring is the substance of this proposal.

## Cost

| Provider | Current term | Proposed renewal |
| --- | --- | --- |
| ChainSecurity & Certora | $1,750,000 | **$1,324,000**, reducing to **$1,024,000** annualised if the vCISO component comes off |
| zeroShadow | $250,000 | **$335,000** |
| ChainPatrol | $36,000 (carried by the Foundation) | **$36,000** (returns to the DAO) |
| **Total** | **$2,036,000** | **$1,695,000**, reducing to **$1,395,000** annualised |


Coverage is mostly restructured rather than cut. The auditor allocation is smaller than last year's consumption because routine governance proposal review moves to zeroShadow, where it costs less. zeroShadow's scope grows to absorb it: $93,000 of new scope less $8,000 of savings on the services being renewed, a net increase of $85,000.

Of the ChainSecurity & Certora figure, $300,000 is the vCISO component. The Foundation retains the vCISO for now and is not committing to a transition during this term. It is charged monthly, so the DAO pays only for the months in which it is provided and any balance not drawn stays with the TMC.

The renewal term runs twelve months, from **August 18, 2026 to August 17, 2027**, the day after the current funded term ended, so the renewal continues it without a gap. The three engagements have run to different anniversaries until now; this term brings them onto one.

## Scope of Engagement

Scope is described at a high level; detailed statements of work sit with the Foundation.

**ChainSecurity & Certora.** An annual allocation of auditor capacity that Compound directs across its own priorities — smart contract audits, formal verification, web2 security reviews, and security architecture advice — rather than a fixed schedule of deliverables. Surge capacity is available for periods of exceptional activity, which is how a V4 audit programme would be funded once V4 is audit-ready, without a mid-term renegotiation. Both firms continue to hold a signer seat on the community multisig. Terms secured: 58 audit weeks a year with unused weeks rolling over, monthly usage reporting, and V4 surge rates locked now.

**zeroShadow.** Continued operation of the 24/7/365 virtual Security Operations Center, incident response, monitoring maintenance across onchain activity and Compound's front end, participation as an independent security signer in the DAO's multisig structure, and threat intelligence platform access.

The substantive change is that zeroShadow expands its coverage of governance proposal review. Proposal simulation and mitigation becomes a defined, separately scoped part of the engagement rather than something absorbed informally alongside monitoring, freeing auditor capacity for code. Routine proposal review therefore sits with zeroShadow, with ChainSecurity and Certora engaged on request where a proposal warrants auditor attention. Terms secured: incident SLAs of acknowledgement under 15 minutes and escalation within three hours; and 200 hours of engineering support, split 120 to the current protocol version and 80 to V4, with unused hours rolling over.

**ChainPatrol.** Unchanged. Real-time monitoring for brand impersonation, phishing domains, fake social profiles, and wallet drainers targeting Compound, with takedowns across domains, app stores, and social platforms.

## Rationale for Renewal

**The cost has moved in the DAO's favour without a concession on coverage.** The DAO held contractual options to renew at $1.75M. It is instead being asked to approve $1,324,000 now and $1,024,000 on a steady-state basis for the audit and advisory mandate, alongside a monitoring engagement that has grown in scope but reduced overall cost.

**The track record of security service partners is good.** 92 proposals reviewed in the first six months with no execution-related incident, and the cadence maintained through proposal 603. Eleven protocol audits with every critical and high finding resolved before deployment. Five proposals stopped and corrected before a vote. Two live events — deUSD and the rsETH exploit — met with same-day emergency action, every step reviewed before execution.

**Protocol-specific context is expensive to rebuild.** The team holds the proposal decoding and simulation tooling, sits on the community multisig, and has run the multisig fire drills. Re-tendering a year after a sixteen-proposal competitive RFP would cost more in transition risk than it could recover in price. On ChainPatrol, restoring a $36,000 line the DAO already voted for is the correction of an accident of administration, not a new commitment.

## Funding and Process

This proposal follows the below timeline:

- **RFC period:** seven days, September 16 through September 23, with questions answered in the forum thread by the Foundation, CGWG, or the providers.
- **Snapshot vote:** three days, opening Wednesday, September 23 at 12:00 PM ET and closing Saturday, September 26 at 12:00 PM ET.
- **Funding:** on approval, the TMC will fund the required streams and administer back pay.

Consistent with the Woof Year 3 and Cactus renewals, funding will be disbursed from the pool administered under the TMC, subject to the onchain controls described in that framework. Upon approval, the TMC would fund the term through four separate streams, with the capital committed upfront:

- **ChainSecurity & Certora — $1,024,000**, excluding the vCISO component
- **vCISO — $300,000**, cancellable independently of the rest
- **zeroShadow — $335,000**
- **ChainPatrol — $36,000**

Funding each provider separately means the DAO can act on one engagement without disturbing the others, and carving the vCISO out means it can be stopped at the point the Foundation's own security leadership takes the function on, without touching the audit retainer underneath it. The portion accrued from August 18 through the start of the streams will be released upfront as back pay for the trailing period, as was done for the Cactus renewal, with the remainder streamed over the rest of the term.

Each stream is cancellable by the Foundation after a 60-day notice and cure period, no further governance proposal is needed to exercise it, and any balance not yet streamed remains under TMC control. Because the streams are separate, a cancellation reaches only the provider concerned. Cancelling the vCISO stream on transition needs no cause or cure period, since it is a planned handover rather than a remedy.

A lapse in security coverage is not a risk the DAO should carry for the length of an onchain cycle. The engagements remain fully subject to the service levels and reporting obligations agreed with the Foundation, and ratification by Snapshot does not waive them.

## Approval Requested

By voting "For," the community approves the renewal of the ChainSecurity & Certora, zeroShadow, and ChainPatrol engagements on terms materially consistent with the Foundation's forum proposal, authorizes the CGWG and Foundation to finalize documentation and operational arrangements, and authorizes the applicable $1,695,000 in payments, or equivalent arrangement, to be funded from TMC-administered funds through the four streams described above.

For a complete reading of the proposal, visit the Foundation's forum post below.

## Voting Options

**For:** Approve the renewal and authorize funding from TMC-administered funds on the basis described above.

**Against:** Do not approve the renewal or the proposed funding route.

**Abstain:** Register no position on the proposal.

Note: This vote will pass if "Yes" votes reach at least 400,000 COMP and outnumber the "No" votes.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

