# BIP-91B: Art Basel Hong Kong Mint and Sales

- Space: [Botto](https://snapshot.box/s:botto.eth.md)
- Author: 0x4eDA60dD2f38177C55cF8587f41B0AE40caAb085
- State: Passed
- Voting type: Basic
- Start: 2026-02-27 21:00 UTC
- End: 2026-03-02 21:00 UTC
- Votes: 23
- Quorum: 500,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://forum.botto.com/d/134-bip-91b-art-basel-hong-kong-mint-and-sales
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:botto.eth/proposal/0x5c77203b8c927dadd5a97ff666769f7323a6842ba65e6b0d336b77a2494a0ba6

## Results

- For: 2,890,193.65 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

> `Note: Snapshot is only a summary and may leave ambiguities that are covered in the full BIP in the forum which takes precedent.`

## Summary

This proposal requests targeted adjustments to the minting and sales mechanics approved under BIP-91 for the Art Basel Hong Kong installation.

The project remains:

-   Within approved budget
    
-   Within approved revenue distribution
    

No changes are proposed to revenue splits or budget caps.  
Adjustments concern sales format, series number, pricing, and treasury strategy.

---

## Proposal Specification

### 1. Final Canvases — Sales Format

**Original Plan**  
5 final canvases (4 individual + 1 group) auctioned live during the fair.

**Observation**  
-Auctions over a 5-day live generation event were identified as sub-optimal.  
-The largest buyers typically engage in the first two days, making late auction closures inefficient.

**Updated Proposal**  
-Replace auctions with buy-now pricing.  
-Grant flexibility on final sales mechanism if optimization is needed.

---

### 2. Final Canvas Series Number

**Original Plan**  
5 final canvases (4 individual + 1 group).

**Observation**  
-Live generation allows for more works to be completed than initially anticipated.  
-As benchmark, p5.js produced 19 auctioned works (+1 held for treasury), averaging ~20k.

**Updated Proposal**  
-Size the final series using the p5.js benchmark (~19 works, with 1 held for treasury).  
-Grant flexibility to finalize exact count based on generation pacing.

---

### 3. Pricing Structure

**Original Plan**  
Auction-based price discovery.

**Observation**  
-p5.js averaged ~20k across 19 works.  
-This provides a benchmark for sizing and pricing.

**Updated Proposal**  
Anchor pricing around the p5.js benchmark (~20k average), with flexibility for variation depending on final series size and event dynamics.

---

### 4. Open Edition (Seed Image)

**Original Plan**  
Unlimited edition for successful participants ($50–100) with corresponding NFT.

**Observation**  
An open edition of the seed image aligns with the transformation theme and broadens accessibility.

**Updated Proposal**  
-Offer an open edition of the seed image primarily online.  
-Price range: $10–$100.  
-Edition may remain open while generation continues on that seed.

---

### 5. Gaze Recognition Artifacts

**Original Plan**  
Participants receive token of participation, potentially free or low cost.

**Observation**  
Charging participants for recognition artifacts conflicts with participation logic.

**Updated Proposal**  
-Do not charge participants.  
-Use installation proceeds (net of booth costs) to buy back $BOTTO and distribute it as governance stake.  
-No change to revenue distribution parameters.

---

### 6. Secondary Works & Treasury Sales

**Original Plan**  
-1 Genesis secondary (physical + NFT) with 10% royalty and additional 10% commission.  
-Potential additional secondary works pending availability.

**Observation**  
Treasury inventory is available:  
-8x 13th mints  
-2x p5.js works  
Reference: First 13th mint sold at Sotheby’s for $31,200 USD.

**Updated Proposal**  
-Price remaining 13th mints around 20k.  
-Price p5.js works around 20k.  
-Prepare treasury works for sale during the fair.  
-Genesis Attempt Deepen secondary proceeds as described (production recoup before commission).

---

## What Is Not Changing

-   Revenue distribution (as approved in BIP-91)
    
-   Budget cap (no >15% overrun)
    

---

## Scope of Discretion

Approval grants flexibility to adjust:

-   Sales format
    
-   Final series number
    
-   Pricing structure
    
-   Open edition configuration
    
-   Treasury work pricing
    

Any change to revenue distribution or budget overrun >15% requires a new vote.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

