# BIP-23: BMX Treasury Burn

- Space: [BMX](https://snapshot.box/s:bmxonbase.eth.md)
- Author: 0xB1dD2Fdb023cB54b7cc2a0f5D9e8d47a9F7723ce
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-03-03 21:43 UTC
- End: 2026-03-10 21:43 UTC
- Votes: 35
- Quorum: 750,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://discord.com/channels/892431105339306044/975375332435714058/1477799992130404392
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:bmxonbase.eth/proposal/0x4e1a3da993ca7643bf228e004adb31bda6baa2dbdf4cc46f7714f8f77846449c

## Results

- Yes: 824,171.07 voting power, 100.0%
- No: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

### This proposal asks BMX holders to vote to permanently burn the approximately 57,607 BMX held in the prior protocol governance treasury.

- A YES vote authorizes the permanent destruction of these tokens. They will be burned onchain and permanently removed from supply. The Boardwalk Governance framework described in this document will be implemented concurrently with this action. As part of this process, the team will execute an administrative transfer of the funds held in the legacy protocol safety module to the Boardwalk protocol Treasury.

- A NO vote leaves the prior protocol governance treasury unchanged, and the Boardwalk Governance framework will not be implemented.

*Note: The governance framework described in this document outlines how protocol fee allocation will be directed on a weekly basis following implementation. It is provided here for full transparency so that BMX holders have complete context when casting their vote.*

# Boardwalk Governance  
Treasury will receive 30% protocol fee allocation, and 70% will be vote-directed by governance participants. Treasury is not under governance control. Treasury’s purpose is to fund development, growth, and operations/expenses. The protocol is built on the premise of requiring active participation to receive governance outcomes. BMX holders can participate in governance by staking their BMX. The protocol includes a configurable governance participation burn (range: 0 to 1 BMX per vote) that may be activated by Treasury with a 21-day timelock. At launch, this is set to zero.

## 1) Staked BMX
- It is the exclusive governance participation token for the weekly allocation vote. 
- Non-transferable (soulbound) — staked BMX cannot be sold, transferred, or traded independently. It exists as an onchain representation of a staked position only.
- No change to the BMX staking contract — the existing staking mechanism is preserved.
- Governance weight formula: BMX staked + accumulated participation points
 
## 2) Participation Points (Multiplier Points)
**Participation points and multiplier points refer to the same mechanic:**
- Accrued at a rate of 100% per year on staked BMX upon claim (must claim) — 1 year of staking 100 BMX earns 100 points
- Accrue continuously while staked, proportional to time
- Governance weight: BMX staked + accumulated points
- Allocation weight formula: (staked BMX amount + points) / (total staked + total points)
- BMX stakers: points increase both governance voting power AND allocation weight.
- On unstake: points burned proportionally (25% unstake → 25% of points burned, 75% preserved)
- Burns reduce total pool supply → all remaining stakers' weight increases automatically
- Sustained participation increases governance weight over time as unstaking penalizes the leaver and increases the governance weight of remaining stakers. 

## 3) Weekly Governance Vote
Every 7 days, staked BMX holders vote on where the 70% governance-directed allocation goes the following week.

**Core Rules:**
- Advance voting — votes cast in week N direct fees collected in week N+1. Stakers vote on unknown future fees, not a known current amount.
- Winner-takes-all — the full 70% routes to the single winning option.
- 51% quorum required — vote must reach majority of total eligible voting power; if quorum is not met, the 70% reverts to treasury automatically
- Consecutive win cap: 3x — an option that wins 3 consecutive weeks is ineligible in week 4, regardless of vote outcome; it returns as a valid option in week 5. This prevents any single option from producing a sustained, predictable, recurring pattern.
- Contract-enforced routing: the 70% allocation is set at deployment and immutable, with a 21-day timelock for destination changes. Voting is onchain. The keeper triggers execution mechanically; the routing outcome is determined by the voting contract.
 - Votes are public and visible onchain during the voting window. 
- Voting requires having 1.5% of staked BMX amount in earned participation points.

## 4) Vote Options
### Option 1 — Treasury
The 70% governance-directed allocation routes to the protocol treasury. Combined with the automatic 30%, the treasury receives 100% of protocol fees that week.

Use case: Protocol needs to build reserves rapidly, or the community prefers treasury growth over other outcomes in a given period.
 
 ### Option 2 — Buy and Burn BMX
Protocol fees (ETH) are used to:
- Buy BMX from the open market
- Burn the purchased BMX permanently

This reduces total BMX supply.
 
### Option 3 — Buy and Burn BMX/wETH LP
Protocol fees (ETH) are used to:
1. Buy BMX and wETH from the open market
2. Pair as a BMX/wETH LP position
3. Burn or lock the LP token permanently — the position cannot be withdrawn or recovered 

**Key properties:**
- Deepens permanent, protocol-owned BMX/wETH liquidity every time this option wins
- Treasury earns all trading fees generated by the burned LP position

### Option 4 — Staked BMX Participation Allocation
The 70% governance-directed allocation streams to eligible staked BMX holders as BMX, linearly over 7 days.

**Eligibility:**
- Must have voted in the prior period's governance vote
- Eligibility is locked at the point of voting — stakers do NOT need to remain staked through the 7-day stream to receive the allocation. The allocation tracks the wallet address at the time of vote, not the staking position.

**Delivery:**
- The participation allocation is delivered as BMX
- Streamed linearly across 7 days
- Amount per holder is proportional to their governance weight at time of voting   


## BMX Consumptive Use
BMX is a consumptive and participatory utility token. It is burned — permanently removed from supply — as the cost of accessing and using protocol features. These consumptive interactions are independent of governance participation and occur regardless of any governance outcome. Each burn is a one-way transaction: BMX spent to use the protocol is not recoverable, redeemable, or refundable.

The consumptive use of BMX is intrinsic to how the protocol functions, not incidental to it. Holding BMX without using it confers no automatic benefit. Value, where it exists, flows from participation — not from possession.  

BMX has two distinct functions: it is burned as the cost of accessing protocol features, and staked to participate in active protocol governance. Neither function is designed to generate passive returns — consumptive use requires expenditure, and governance participation requires active voting on uncertain, unknown future outcomes with no guaranteed allocation. 

## Disclaimer
*Participation in Boardwalk governance — including staking BMX, accumulating participation points, and casting votes — does not confer any ownership interest, equity stake, or property right in the Boardwalk protocol or its treasury. Governance participants have no claim on protocol fees, treasury assets, or the assets of any other participant.*

*Participation points have no monetary value, are non-transferable, and cannot be redeemed, sold, or exchanged for any asset. They exist solely to reflect the degree of a participant's sustained governance engagement and have no function outside of the governance system.*

*Governance weight does not represent a financial instrument. Voting on weekly governance directives is an active governance act, not an investment activity. No governance outcome is guaranteed. The receipt of any allocation under Option 4 is contingent on multiple independent conditions — including prior voting, winning the weekly vote, and quorum being met — none of which are assured. All votes are cast on unknown future protocol activity.*

*Nothing in this document constitutes financial advice, an offer of securities, or a promise of financial return. This document does not constitute an offer or solicitation in any jurisdiction where such activity is prohibited. Participants are solely responsible for any tax obligations arising from governance participation or receipt of any governance outcome.*

*Protocol mechanics are enforced by smart contracts, which may contain errors or vulnerabilities. The protocol fee allocation subject to governance is dependent on protocol usage and volume — there is no guarantee fees will be generated at any level. Changes in applicable law or regulation could materially affect participation in governance. Governance participation below the 51% quorum threshold will result in the full 70% allocation reverting to treasury. Voters should understand that their participation is required for the system to function.*

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

