# Donor Voting and $GARDEN Governance Token Distribution

- Space: [Big Green DAO](https://snapshot.box/s:biggreendao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x7D4EFd9b4fFECA3e1Db5178f13CeA1eaF69D86d2
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2022-03-31 18:04 UTC
- End: 2022-04-01 18:05 UTC
- Votes: 5
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:biggreendao.eth/proposal/0xbfeb687da9b6635d02fc4fd1ded0d70992a64895b24aac12c2be1042cb6d14d3

## Results

- For: $GARDEN Tokens to Donors: 5 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: Delay Tokens to Donors: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

**Summary**
In Grants Round 2 (GR2) Big Green DAO will distribute $GARDEN governance tokens to 10 new grantee organizations. This proposals calls for  issuing $GARDEN tokens to KYC’d donors above the $100K USD threshold at the same time - in line with the Lite Paper; and issuing governance tokens to all KYC’d donors above 1ETH with Grants Round 3 (GR3) organizations.  

**Abstract**
The Big Green DAO Lite Paper calls for the phased inclusion of donors into the governance and grant making process, incrementally decreasing the threshold for $GARDEN governance token-granting donations from $1M USD to 1 ETH. According to the Lite Paper, only KYC’d donors of $100K and above must be issued a $GARDEN governance token during the initial experimental phase of the DAO, however, DAO Committee members have determined that it is prudent to introduce a process for including all KYC’d donors of 1ETH or more into the governance and grantmaking process before the final grants round of the experimental phase - Grants Round 4 (GR4). 

Donors will be included in two separate cohorts, with those donating $100K USD and above issued governance tokens with GR2 token distribution to organizations; and those donating 1ETH and above issued governance tokens with GR3 token distribution to organizations. 

This proposal further recommends that the DAO develop a pathway for $GARDEN governance token distribution to contributors that may not be able to make a fiscal donation, but provide time and other value to the community. Details of this process

**Motivation**
One of the major objectives of Big Green DAO is to create an inclusive and representative philanthropic space. It is thus important that while we seek to disrupt hierarchies of power in philanthropy and put organizations in the driver’s seat of grantmaking, that we do not repackage exclusionary structures. This proposal provides an initial pathway for incorporating donors into the DAO’s grantmaking and governance process during the experimental period, leaving to future discussion the question of how to balance the continued inclusion of donors, without overpowering the voice and influence of organizations over the long term.

**Specification**
According to the Big Green DAO Lite Paper, donors are to be progressively included in the governing and grantmaking apparatus of the DAO, receiving $GARDEN governance tokens in stages based on their donation size: 

- Stage 1: $1M USD
- Stage 2: $100K USD 
- Stage 3: $10K USD
- Stage 4: 1ETH (approx. $3K USD)

Donors will be included into the DAO and issued $GARDEN governance tokens as follows:
- Grants Round 2 (GR2): Stage 1 & Stage 2 - KYC’d donors making contributions of $100K USD or more.
- Grants Round 3 (GR3): Stage 3 & Stage 4 - KYC’d donors making contributions of 1ETH or more.

$GARDEN Governance tokens will also be distributed in GR3 to a select number of early contributors and community members who have not or were unable to make financial donations, however, have “donated” to the DAO with their time and engagement. The mechanics of how and how many of these individuals will be selected will be determined through DAO Community consensus building and detailed in a future proposal. 

A Future proposal will also address relative voting power of non-profit organizations and donors in the DAO, balancing between the need to incentivize donations and donor engagement while maintaining the core purpose of the DAO to amplify the voice of non-profit organizations and empower those on the frontlines of food justice to direct the allocation of grantmaking resources.

**Voting Options**
**For:** Distribute $GARDEN tokens as specified above
**Against:** Do not distributed $GARDEN tokens as specified above

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

