# Donor Tokenomics

- Space: [Big Green DAO](https://snapshot.box/s:biggreendao.eth.md)
- Author: 0x7D4EFd9b4fFECA3e1Db5178f13CeA1eaF69D86d2
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2022-11-09 21:01 UTC
- End: 2022-11-19 06:59 UTC
- Votes: 6
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:biggreendao.eth/proposal/0x3e893a2aa7eeaeea094f00f7c16c8f0ccbacda8e401317c764a5f411d54a9e24

## Results

- For: Reform Donor Tokenomics: 6 voting power, 100.0%
- Against: Same Donor Tokenomics: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

**Summary**
Restructure Donor tokenomics of Big Green DAO, formally ending the one year experimental period of Big Green DAO operations.  

**Abstract**
This proposal modifies donor tokenomics of Big Green DAO, and marks the conclusion of the initial experimental period of Big Green DAO’s operation.

**Tokenomics** in a DAO can be understood as the way in which power in general, and voting power in particular, is distributed across members of the community, as well as a mechanism through which membership in the community itself is determined and controlled. A tokenomic policy specifically outlines how voting power is measured, to what and how it is applied, and the fundamental dynamics of the token itself, for example, including but not limited to: its supply, longevity or if it is transferable or can be bought and sold on the open market.  

The following changes will be made to the Big Green DAO Donor token ($GARDENDONOR) tokenomics: 

1. **Inclusion of all 1 ETH+ Donors.** Following [deferral of including donors of 1 ETH to $100K](https://snapshot.org/#/biggreendao.eth/proposal/0x97a37a991a2abaec55d1c6f791bea2f94d5a5bc96c3ed6cbbdd103bc0216e804)  into DAO governance and grantmaking, Big Green DAO will open a two-week governance token claim window on January 1, 2020, for all donors of 1 ETH and above from the experimental period. 

2. **One-Year Donor Token Empowerment Period.** Each donor token will burn - or have its voting power voided - 1 year (365 days) after its official claim. Donor tokens will remain non-transferable, however, similar to $GARDEN tokens, their voting power cannot be delegated.   

3. **Token-Granting Donation Threshold.** Each year, DAO Community Member organizations ($GARDEN token holders) will vote on the donation threshold to qualify for a DAO Donor Token. Parameters (potential donation threshold values) of the vote will be determined by a consensus vote of the DAO Committee. 

4. **Donor Token Powers.** $GARDENDONOR tokens will have the same powers as $GARDEN tokens (held by DAO Community Member Organizations), unless otherwise recommended by the DAO committee and voted upon by DAO Community Organizations.

5. **KYC Requirement.** Donor tokens will be issued when donors meet an established threshold for KYC (know your customer) as determined by Big Green
 

**Motivation**
How to include donors in the governance and grantmaking process of Big Green DAO has remained an important topic of discussion throughout the experimental period of the DAO’s operation. At the heart of this discussion was a question surrounding how to preserve the DAO’s central mission of putting organizations in the driver’s seat of grantmaking, while at the same time including donors in the governance and grantmaking process.  

The **Big Green DAO Lite Paper** delineated a tokenomic policy with three different types of governance tokens for DAO Community Members: tokens for organizations ($GARDEN), tokens for the DAO Committee ($GARDENEXEC), and tokens for Donors (TBD). Herein, the Donor token will be referred to as $GARDENDONOR. However, during the experimental period, the three Donors included in the DAO were temporarily issued $GARDEN tokens. The smart contract for Donor tokens will be developed based on the results of this proposal. 

The **current tokenomics** for each Community Member category is as follows: 

**$GARDENEXEC**
- DAO Committee Member token
- DAO Committee Members must be a DAO Community Member
- Each token is identical in value and voting weight
- Non-transferable
- Used only for DAO Committee Votes

**$GARDEN** 	
- DAO Community Member Organization token
- Each token is identical in value and voting weight
- Non-transferable to prevent their accruing of value
- Voting power can not be delegated
- Token is burned if not used in two successive Grants Rounds
- Tokens must be burned to apply for additional funding
- Used on governance proposals & to access grantmaking portal  

**$GARDENDONOR** 
- DAO Community Member Donor token
- Each token is identical in value and voting weight
- Non-transferable to prevent their accruing of value
- Donor may maintain control of the token indefinitely
- Voting power can be delegated
- Voting power auto-delegates to Big Green if not used in two successive Grants Rounds
- Used on governance proposals & to access grantmaking portal

The solution presented in this proposal, and introduced in detail below, aims to both include donors in the governance and grantmaking process, while at the same time, centering “sovereign” power over the DAO and its operations firmly in the hands of non-profit organizations. 

**Specification**
**Donor** is defined as someone who makes a financial contribution to Big Green DAO. Donor may be an individual or a collective, for example an organization or DAO.

- As part of this proposal, all KYC Donors of 1 ETH and above from the experimental period of the DAO will be eligible to claim a $GARDENDONOR token, during a two week claim period starting on January 1, 2023. 

- $GARDENDONOR tokens have a one year empowerment period and can be claimed/minted on a rolling basis. A $GARDENDONOR token will be disempowered (i.e. have its voting power in the DAO removed) exactly 365 days (1 year) after it is minted/claimed. 

- The $GARDEN tokens of the Donors of $100K and above from the experimental period of the DAO will be burned on December 31, 2022. These three donors can claim $GARDENDONOR tokens if they decide to make a subsequent donation in FY2023, and their contribution passes the established donation threshold, discussed in more detail below.

- $GARDENDONOR tokens will be designed as an [ERC-1155](https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/standards/tokens/erc-1155/) multi-standard smart contract, which enables the same functionality as an ERC-20 token (i.e. same potential functionality as the $GARDEN token); however, with the flexibility and customizability of and ERC-721 token, or in other words, an NFT (non-fungible token). 

- The donation threshold to qualify for a $GARDENDONOR token will be determined by vote of non-profit organizations in the DAO ($GARDEN token holders), in January (Q1) of each year. The range of donation threshold to be included in the vote will be set by a consensus vote of the DAO Committee. The Donation threshold set by this vote will only be applied to donations received in and throughout the entirety of the same fiscal year.

- $GARDENDONOR tokens will have the same powers as $GARDEN tokens (held by non-profit organization DAO members), unless otherwise recommended by the DAO committee and voted upon by the Community of $GARDEN token holders.

- Only KYC’d donors are eligible to claim a donor governance token.

**Voting Options** 

This is a DAO Committee ($GARDENEXEC) vote, requiring a consensus to pass. 

**For:** Reform structure of Big Green DAO donor tokenomics
**Against:** Keep Donor Tokenomics as specified in Lite Paper
**Abstain**

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

