# [BIP-921] 1-BAL-1-Vote Reconfiguration for `balancer.eth` Snapshot Space

- Space: [Balancer](https://snapshot.box/s:balancer.eth.md)
- Author: 0x58865c1B463Fd2772cD50EB50976A07FaE3Dc6F1
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Weighted
- Start: 2026-05-15 18:00 UTC
- End: 2026-05-19 18:00 UTC
- Votes: 7
- Quorum: 2,000,000 voting power
- Discussion: https://forum.balancer.fi/t/bip-xxx-1-bal-1-vote-reconfiguration-for-balancer-eth-snapshot-space/7052
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:balancer.eth/proposal/0xeb3d43a0e527fb7bbe9f5090d52dcae336c8904aea6d0b0237b65862157bc208

## Results

- Yes, let's do it: 2,879,230.48 voting power, 100.0%
- No, this is not the way: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- Abstain: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

# Abstract

Implement the dual voting system from [BIP-919](https://forum.balancer.fi/t/bip-919-bal-tokenomics-revamp/7001). Replace the two veBAL-based Snapshot strategies with a seven-strategy stack denominated in raw BAL across all production chains with BAL deployed.

# Voting Power Formula (`BalVotingPower.sol`)

Instead of giving voting power based on (decaying) veBAL balances, the DAO switches to a simple "1-BAL-1-Vote" model based on raw BAL balances and delegations across all production chains. In addition, BAL underlying any 80/20 BAL/WETH BPT position is included, both held directly and locked in veBAL (face value, i.e. decay ignored).

For voter `u` at the snapshot block:

* Every chain: `BAL.balanceOf(u)` + delegated-in raw BAL (per chain's Snapshot Delegate Registry)
* Ethereum only: `+ BAL underlying 80/20 BAL/WETH BPT held by u`
* Ethereum only: `+ BAL underlying 80/20 BPT locked in veBAL by u`

This formula is implemented in a stateless, ownerless, singleton view contract on Ethereum. It has one function: `votingPower(address)` which returns `uint256`. See https://github.com/balancer/bal-voting-power.

# Strategy Stack

|Chain|Strategy|(BAL) Address|
| --- | --- | --- |
|Ethereum|`delegation(contract-call(BalVotingPower))`|`0x411e723E6652347FF3Dd31749913A834e3D43DB4`|
|Gnosis|`erc20-balance-of-delegation`|`0x7eF541E2a22058048904fE5744f9c7E4C57AF717`|
|Arbitrum One|`erc20-balance-of-delegation`|`0x040d1EdC9569d4Bab2D15287Dc5A4F10F56a56B8`|
|Base|`erc20-balance-of-delegation`|`0x4158734D47Fc9692176B5085E0F52ee0Da5d47F1`|
|Polygon (PoS)|`erc20-balance-of-delegation`|`0x9a71012B13CA4d3D0Cdc72A177DF3ef03b0E76A3`|
|Optimism|`erc20-balance-of-delegation`|`0xFE8B128bA8C78aabC59d4c64cEE7fF28e9379921`|
|Avalanche (C-Chain)|`erc20-balance-of-delegation`|`0xE15bCB9E0EA69e6aB9FA080c4c4A5632896298C3`|

Any other chain Balancer is deployed on is excluded because it is either deprecated (zkEVM, Fraxtal, Mode; [BIP-906](https://forum.balancer.fi/t/bip-906-deprecation-of-polygon-zkevm-fraxtal-and-mode/6951)) or does not have canonical BAL deployed (HyperEVM, Monad, Plasma). Polygon/Optimism/Avalanche are "under review" per [BIP-918](https://forum.balancer.fi/t/bip-918-operational-restructuring-for-balancer/7000); they remain included until formally sunset.

[`erc20-balance-of-delegation`](https://github.com/snapshot-labs/score-api/blob/master/src/strategies/strategies/erc20-balance-of-delegation/index.ts) is a default Snapshot strategy which sums raw token balance + delegated balance for that chain. Note that this is a [Snapshot Pro](https://docs.snapshot.box/user-guides/spaces/turbo-plan) strategy, and thus requires the current active subscription for it to remain active. `delegation(contract-call(BalVotingPower))` is a combination of the default [`delegation`](https://github.com/snapshot-labs/score-api/tree/master/src/strategies/strategies/delegation) and [`contract-call`](https://github.com/snapshot-labs/score-api/tree/master/src/strategies/strategies/contract-call) strategies. It simply calls the `votingPower(address)` function on the `BalVotingPower` contract mentioned above, adding any delegated voting power.

# Threshold Changes

Quorum for a vote to be valid is simply converted from the current 2M veBAL to 10M BAL (rough scaling vector of 5x). The minimum voting power required to submit a proposal is removed; only registered `members` of the `balancer.eth` space can submit proposals. As per [BIP-838](https://forum.balancer.fi/t/bip-838-balancer-dao-governance-process-guidelines/6542), new governance proposals have to pass through the forum anyway before they can be submitted, so submitting a proposal to Snapshot directly is outdated. Lastly the 45% delegation cap ([BIP-521](https://forum.balancer.fi/t/bip-521-cap-individual-voter-weight-on-snapshot/5413)) is removed.

# Delegation

Per chain via Snapshot's native Delegate Registry (`0x469788fE6E9E9681C6ebF3bF78e7Fd26Fc015446`, deterministic on all supported chains). Holders delegate once per chain they hold BAL on. Note that existing delegations for the current veBAL-based strategies will not carry over!

# Technical Specifications

Update the `balancer.eth` Snapshot space to use the following new configuration JSON: https://github.com/balancer/bal-voting-power/pull/3/changes

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

