# AIP9 - what should the quorum be for a proposal to pass?

- Space: [AssangeDAO](https://snapshot.box/s:assangedao.eth.md)
- Author: 0xC42d7E776cB079C3C3b205BD307D0CdbB2431Dd3
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2022-03-19 00:28 UTC
- End: 2022-03-22 00:28 UTC
- Votes: 271
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:assangedao.eth/proposal/0xa1cdc1fb13df8f91f1cd49624e918950847f134d087b337febf5fec5fb1c6694

## Results

- 25% $JUSTICE voting overall: 491,566,367.73 voting power, 11.9%
- 25% $JUSTICE voting in favor: 44,077,361.28 voting power, 1.1%
- 20% $JUSTICE voting overall: 7,221,682.71 voting power, 0.2%
- 20% $JUSTICE voting in favor: 57,832,814.06 voting power, 1.4%
- 15% $JUSTICE voting overall: 200,325,895.91 voting power, 4.9%
- 15% $JUSTICE voting in favor: 345,479.59 voting power, 0.0%
- 10% $JUSTICE voting overall: 1,467,310,609.69 voting power, 35.7%
- 10% $JUSTICE voting in favor: 66,820,217.57 voting power, 1.6%
- 5% $JUSTICE voting overall: 1,764,485,380.23 voting power, 42.9%
- 5% $JUSTICE voting in favor: 14,319,638.42 voting power, 0.3%
- 1% $JUSTICE voting overall: 0 voting power, 0.0%
- 1% $JUSTICE voting in favor: 420,410.19 voting power, 0.0%
- none of the above: 0 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

### Summary

**This proposal addresses the quorum requirement of the new governance system of the AssangeDAO.** 

The current voting system implements a simple choice voting system pursuant to which a minimum of 3,470,307,901 $JUSTICE tokens equivalent to 20% of the $JUSTICE token supply are necessary to vote in order for a proposal to pass. Once this threshold has been met, whichever decision has more votes wins. If a proposal does not reach the quorum threshold, a proposal fails. An alternative system could also specify that a certain quorum of votes is necessary to vote in favor of the winning choice, or otherwise a proposal fails.

**For the new governance structure, what should the quorum requirement be for a proposal to pass?**

### Details 

**What should the quorum for a governance proposal be to pass?**

1. **25%** of token supply voting overall (i.e. 4,337,884,877 $JUSTICE)
2. **25%** of token supply voting in favor of the successful choice (i.e. 4,337,884,877 $JUSTICE)
3. **20%** of token supply voting overall (i.e. 3,470,307,901 $JUSTICE) 
4. **20%** of token supply voting in favor of the successful choice (i.e. 3,470,307,901 $JUSTICE) 
5. **15%** of token supply voting overall (i.e. 2,602,730,926 $JUSTICE)
6. **15%** of token supply voting in favor of the successful choice (i.e. 2,602,730,926 $JUSTICE) 
7. **10%** of token supply voting overall (i.e. 1,735,153,951 $JUSTICE)
8. **10%** of token supply voting in favor of the successful choice (i.e. 1,735,153,951 $JUSTICE) 
9. **5%** of token supply voting overall (i.e. 867,576,975 $JUSTICE) 
10. **5%** of token supply voting in favor of the successful choice (i.e. 867,576,975 $JUSTICE) 
11. **1%** of token supply voting overall (i.e. 173,515,395 $JUSTICE) 
12. **1%** of token supply voting in favor of the successful choice 
 (i.e. 173,515,395 $JUSTICE)
13. **None of the above** / discuss further

### Motivation

The current quorum was set up by the core team members to get the DAO started. The DAO however should make its own decisions. This is one of several snapshot proposals to decide the new governance structure of AssangeDAO.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

