# Banning projects identified in the high-severity Watchdog Program cases - Good Entry

- Space: [Arbitrum DAO](https://snapshot.box/s:arbitrumfoundation.eth.md)
- Author: 0xb4c064f466931B8d0F637654c916E3F203c46f13
- State: Closed
- Voting type: Single choice
- Start: 2026-09-10 21:30 UTC
- End: 2026-09-17 21:30 UTC
- Votes: 1,002
- Discussion: https://forum.arbitrum.foundation/t/banning-projects-identified-in-the-high-severity-watchdog-program-cases/31407
- Open in Snapshot: https://snapshot.box/#/s:arbitrumfoundation.eth/proposal/0x472fb3b40d3df9b1a65de03b85e4867a76f7b1ec014e2d69f347256b0d08184c

## Results

- FOR - Ban Good Entry: 163,882,585.95 voting power, 100.0%
- AGAINST - Do not ban Good Entry: 7,518.7 voting power, 0.0%
- ABSTAIN: 15,648.89 voting power, 0.0%

## Proposal

# Abstract

The following case from the [Watchdog Program](https://alt.gov.arbitrum.foundation/proposal/28485587559812799913134094629469849411398475232393607771326861344548198896843?govId=eip155:42161:0x789fc99093b09ad01c34dc7251d0c89ce743e5a4) has been deemed to constitute high-severity misuse. Accordingly, the Watchdog Committee is proposing to ban this project from the ArbitrumDAO:

-   [Good Entry](https://forum.arbitrum.foundation/t/good-entry-final-stip-round-1/16763)
    

# Rationale

To strengthen oversight of grant allocations by the DAO and reduce misuse, the ArbitrumDAO approved the [Watchdog Program](https://alt.gov.arbitrum.foundation/proposal/28485587559812799913134094629469849411398475232393607771326861344548198896843?govId=eip155:42161:0x789fc99093b09ad01c34dc7251d0c89ce743e5a4) to reward verifiable reports of misused funds. As of September 2, 2026; 90 reports have been submitted to the program, ~532K ARB has been recovered, and ~268K ARB has been distributed for reporter bounties.

### What constitutes a high-severity misuse?

As per the original Watchdog Proposal, high-severity misuse involves large-scale, deliberate misuse of DAO-allocated funds, including but not limited to fabrication of deliverables and theft.

As mentioned in the [Watchdog Retrospective Report](https://forum.arbitrum.foundation/t/watchdog-retrospective/30732), the Watchdog Committee (comprising Entropy Advisors, MinistroDolar, the Arbitrum Foundation, and the OpCo) has deemed the following case to constitute high-severity misuse:

### Good Entry

**Rationale: Ineligible Users + Suspected Self-Sybil during** [**STIP**](https://forum.arbitrum.foundation/t/good-entry-final-stip-round-1/16763)

On-chain analysis confirms that 142,839 ARB was distributed to 1,032 ineligible users during and after the STIP period. There was also evidence of self-farming of incentives by wallets connected to the team’s addresses. When Good Entry was contacted to provide clarifications, they refused to cooperate.

Since STIP, this project has [ceased operations](https://x.com/goodentrylabs/status/1815264320428855523).

# Steps to Implement

Before raising this proposal to an off-chain vote, this project had 1 week to present their case to the ArbitrumDAO as a reply on [this thread](https://forum.arbitrum.foundation/t/banning-projects-identified-in-the-high-severity-watchdog-program-cases/31407).

Unfortunately, the ArbitrumDAO did not receive a response from this project and the respective funds were not returned. Accordingly, the Watchdog Committee is seeking a vote from the ArbitrumDAO on the following:

-   Should Good Entry (including all founders, current team members, and affiliated contributors), be permanently banned from all future ArbitrumDAO programs?
    

As this project is no longer operational, this ban will only apply to the founders.

The ArbitrumDAO will have the following voting options to choose from:

-   FOR - Ban Good Entry from the ArbitrumDAO
    
-   AGAINST - Do not ban Good Entry from the ArbitrumDAO
    
-   ABSTAIN
    

This proposal will not require an on-chain vote because there are no on-chain actions to be taken. Accordingly, this Snapshot vote aims to get social consensus from the DAO, and will serve as the final decision.

# Timeline

The following dates are tentative and subject to change.

1.  September 3rd: Publish proposal to the forum.
    
2.  September 10th: Deadline for projects to respond.
    
3.  September 10th: Publish off-chain vote to Snapshot.
    

If the DAO votes to ban this project, then the respective project will be ineligible to apply for any ArbitrumDAO programs going forward.

---

To vote or create proposals from an AI assistant, connect the Snapshot MCP at https://mcp.snapshot.box

